Lale ÖZGENEL

Antik Yunan Konut Yazını: Kaynaklar, Sorunlar ve Yeni Yaklaşımlar Üzerine Bir Değerlendirme

Antik Yunan konut mimarisi pek çok araştırmacı tarafından cinsiyet odaklı bir model üzerinden tariflenmiş ve tartışılmıştır. Bu makalede, bu modelin içerdiği problemler yazılı kaynakların eleştirel bir çerçevesi kapsamında ele alınmaktadır. Makalede ele alınan temalar içerisinde, 'cinsiyet odaklı modelin oluşumu (kadın/ erkek karşıtlığı)', 'Yunan konutu ve cinsiyet eşleştirmesi üzerine kısa bir değerlendirme' ve 'antik Yunan konut yazınının yeniden düşünülmesi' vardır. Sonuç kısmında, mimari bulguların sunduğu daha somut verilerin kullanılmasıyla antik Yunan konutunun 'mahremiyet' ve/veya 'özel alan' gibi başka kavramlara dayalı çerçevelerde de tartışılabileceği önerilmektedir.

The Literature on Ancient Greek Domestic Architecture: an Evaluation of Sources, Problems and New Approaches

The Literature on Ancient Greek Domestic Architecture: an Evaluation of Sources, Problems and New Approaches Many scholars described and discussed ancient Greek domestic architecture in reference to a gender based model. This paper addresses the problems inherent in this model by looking at the written accounts in a critical perspective. The themes addressed include 'the formation of the gender based model (male/female opposition)', 'a brief critical overview of the association between Greek house and gender', and 'rethinking the literature of ancient Greek house'. In conclusion it is suggested that the ancient Greek house can also be studied in reference to some other perspectives based on concepts such as 'privacy' and/or 'private sphere' by using more concrete data provided by the architectural evidence.

___

Becker 1886 Becker, J. A., Charicles, or the Illustrations of the Private Life of the Greeks. Londra.

Berard 1989 Berard, C, "The Order of Women", A City of Images, Iconography and Society in Ancient Greece, der. C. Berard ve dig., 89-108.

Berquist 1994 Berquist, B., "Sympotic Space: a functional aspect of Greek dining-rooms", Sympotica, a Symposium on the Symposion, der. O. Murray, 37-65.

Cahill 2002 Cahili, N., Household and City Organization at Olynthus, New Haven ve Londra.

Cantarella 1987 Cantarella, E., Pandora's Daughters, the role and status of women in Greek and Roman antiquity, Baltimore ve Londra.

Cohen 1989 Cohen, D., "Seclusion, Separation and the Status of Women in Classical Athens", 3-15.

Cohen 1991 Cohen, D., Law, Sexuality and Society. Cambridge.

Fehr 1990 Fehr, B., " Entertainers at the Symposion: the Akletoi in the Archaic Period, Sympotica, a Symposium on the Symposion, der. O. Murray, 85-195.

Foxhall 1989 Foxhall, L., "Women's Ritual and Men's Work in Ancient Athens", Women in Antiquity: new assessments, der. R. Hawley - B. Levick, 97-110.

Foxhall 1989 Foxhall, L., Household, Gender and Property in Classical Athens, Classical Quarterly 39, 22-44.

Goldberg 1999 Goldberg, M. Y., "Spatial and Behavioural Negotiation in Classical Athenian City Houses", The Archaeology of Household Activities, der. P. M.Allison, 142-161.

Gould 1980 Gould, J. P., "Law, Custom and Myth: Aspects of the Social Position of Women in Classical Athens", Journal of Hellenic Studies 100, 38-59.

Graham 1972 Graham, J. W, "Notes on Houses and Housing Districts at Abdera and Himera", American Journal of Archaeology 72, 295-301.

Haagsma 2003 Haagsma, M. J., "The Houses of New Halos", Housing in New Halos, a Hellenistic Town in Thessaly, Greece, der. H. R. Reinders -WPrummel, 37-79.

Hammond 1953 Hammond, N. G. L., "Hellenic Houses at Ammotopos in Epirus", Annual of the British School at Athens 48, 135-140.

Havelock 1982 Havelock, C. M., "Mourners on Greek Vases: remarks on the social history of Women", Feminism and Art History, questioning the litany, der. N. Broude - M. D. Garrard, 45-61.

Hellmann 1996 Hellmann, M., "L'espace domestique", l'espace Grec, 150 ans de fouilles de l'Ecole Française d'Athenes, 167-182.

Humphreys 1983 Humphreys, S. C, The Family, Women and Death, comparative studies, Londra.

Jameson 1990 Jameson, M. H., " Domestic Space in the Greek City-state", Domestic Architecture and the Use of Space, der. S. Kent, 92-113.

Jenkins 1986 Jenkins, I., Greek and Roman Life, Londra.

Kampen 1975 Kampen, N., "Hellenistic Artists", Archaeologia Classica 27, 9-17.

Katz 1995 Katz, M. A., "Ideology and 'the Status of Women' in Ancient Greece", Women in Antiquity, new assessments, der. R. Hawley -B. Levick, 21-43.

Lacey 1968 Lacey, W. K., The Family in Classical Greece. Ithaca ve New York.

Lawrence 1957 Lawrence, W., Greek Architecture, Londra.

Lefkowitz-Fant 1992 Lefkowitz, M. R. - M. B. Fant, Women's Life in Greece and Rome, Londra.

Lissarrague 1990 Lissarrague, E, "Around the Krater: an aspect of banquet imagery", Sympotica, a Symposium on the Symposion, der. O. Murray, 196-209.

MacDovell 1989 MacDowell, D. M., "The Oikos in Athenian Law", Classical Quarterly 39, 10-21.

McIntosh Snydr 1991 Mclntosh Snyder, J., "Public Occasion and Private Passion in the Lyrics of Sappho of Lesbos," Women's History and Ancient History, der. S. B. Pomeroy, 1-19.

Mitoliji Sözlüğü Antik Dünya ve Geleneksel Toplumlarda Dinler ve Mitolojiler Sözlüğü, der. Y. Ponnefoy, 2 cilt, çev. L. Yılmaz, Ankara.

Morgan 1982 Morgan, C, "Euphiletos' House: Lysias I", Transactions of the American Philological Association 112, 115-123.

Nevett 1999 Nevett, L. C, House and Society in the Ancient Greek World. Cambridge.

Nevett 1995 Nevett, L. C, "Gender relations in the Classical Greek Household: the archaeological evidence", Annual of the British School at Athens 90363-81.

Nevett 1994 Nevett, L. C, "Separation or Seclusion? Towards an archaoelogical approach to investigating women in the Greek household in the fifth to third centuries BC", Architecture and Order, Approaches to Social Space, der., 98-112.

Özgenel Baskıda 2001 Özgenel, L., "'Mahremiyet' Kavramının Eskiçağ Açılımları: Antik-çağ'da Konut Mimarisi ve Kullanımı Üzerinden bir Örnekleme", Türkiye'de Sanat ve Mimarlık Tarihçiliği Sorunları Sempozyumu, Nisan 2005, Erciyes Üniversitesi.

Özgenel 2001 Özgenel, L., "Anadolu'daki Yunan Dönemi Konutlarında Mekan Tanımı, Kullanımı ve Cinsiyet," OLBA4, 125-143.

Özgenel 2001 Özgenel, L., "Antik Dönem Evleri ve Sahipleri: Batı Anadolu'daki İyon Konutları,"Arkeoloji ve Sanat 78,14-24.

Padel 1993 Padel, R. "Women: model for possession by Greek daemons", Images of Women in Antiquity, der. A. Cameron ve A. Kuhrt, 3-19.

Pellizer 1990 Pellizer, E., "Outlines of a Morphology of Sympotic Entertainment", Sympotica, a Symposium on the Symposion, der. O. Murray, 177-184.

Pameroy 1975 Pomeroy, S. B., Goddesses, Whores, Wives and Slaves, women in Classical Antiquity, New York.

Rider 1916 Rider, B. C, The Greek House, its history and development from the Neolithic period to the Hellenistic Age, Cambridge.

Robertson 1969 Robertson, D. S., Greek and Roman Architecture, Cambridge.

Schaps 1998 Schaps, D. M., "What was Free about a Free Athenian Woman?", Transactions of the American Philological Association 128, 161-188.

Schede 1964 Schede, M., Die Ruinen von Priene, Berlin.

Sennett 1994 Sennett, R., Flesh and Stone, the body and the city in Western civilization, New York.

Skinner 1991 Skinner, M. B., "Nossis of Thelyglössos: the private text and the public book", Women's History and Ancient History, der. S. B. Pomeroy, 20-47.

Steiner 2002 Steiner, A., "Private and Public, Links between Symposion and Sys-sition in Fifth-Century Athens", Classical Antiquity 21, 347-379.

Trümper 1998 Trümper, M., Wohnen in Delos, Eine Baugeschichtliche Untersu-chungen zum Wandel der Wohnkultur in ellenistischer Zeit, Internationale Archâologie 46, Rahden.

Walker 1993 Walker, S., "Women and Housing in Classical Greece: the archaeological evidence", Images of Women in Antiquity, der. A. Cameron -A. Kuhrt, 81-91.

Walter-Karydi 1998 Walter-Karydi, E., The Greek House, the rise of the noble houses in late Classical times, Atina.

Williams 1993 Williams, D., "Women on Athenian Vases: problems of interpretation", Images of Women in Antiquity, der. A. Cameron - A. Kuhrt, 92-106. Antik Yunan Konut Yazını 219

he Private Life of ages, Iconography dig., 89-108. aspect of Greek e Symposion, der. it Olynthus, New i status of women dra. itus of Women in ie Akletoi in the s Symposion, der. ı Ancient Athens", R. Hawley - B. Classical Athens, iation in Classical ısehold Activities, -ts of the Social ırnal of Hellenic »istricts at Abdera '2, 295-301. Housing in New sr. H. R. Reinders )topos in Epirus", 10. larks on the social , questioning the Grec, 150 ans de Humphreys 1983 Jameson 1990 Jenkins 1986 Kampen 1975 Katz 1995 Lacey 1968 Lawrence 1957 Lefkowitz-Fantl992 Lissarrague 1990 MacDowell 1989 Mclntosh Snyder 1991 Mitoliji Sözlüğü Morgan 1982 Nevett 1999 Nevett 1995 Nevett 1994 Özgenel baskıda Özgenel 2001 Özgenel 1997 Humphreys, S. C, The Family, Women and Death, comparative studies, Londra. . Jameson, M. H., " Domestic Space in the Greek City-state", Domestic Architecture and the Use of Space, der. S. Kent, 92-113. Jenkins, I., Greek and Roman Life, Londra. Kampen, N., "Hellenistic Artists", Archaeologia Classica 27, 9-17. Katz, M. A., "Ideology and 'the Status of Women' in Ancient Greece", Women in Antiquity, new assessments, der. R. Hawley -B. Levick, 21-43. Lacey, W. K., The Family in Classical Greece. Ithaca ve New York. Lawrence, W., Greek Architecture, Londra. Lefkowitz, M. R. - M. B. Fant, Women's Life in Greece and Rome, Londra. Lissarrague, F., "Around the Krater: an aspect of banquet imagery", Sympotica, a Symposium on the Symposion, der. O. Murray, 196-209. MacDowell, D. M., "The Oikos in Athenian Law", Classical Quarterly 39,10-21. Mclntosh Snyder, J., "Public Occasion and Private Passion in the Lyrics of Sappho of Lesbos," Women's History and Ancient History, der. S. B. Pomeroy, 1-19. Antik Dünya ve Geleneksel Toplumlarda Dinler ve Mitolojiler Sözlüğü, der. Y. Ponnefoy, 2 cilt, çev. L. Yılmaz, Ankara. Morgan, C, "Euphiletos' House: Lysias I", Transactions of the American Philological Association 112, 115-123. Nevett, L. C, House and Society in the Ancient Greek World. Cambridge. Nevett, L. C, "Gender relations in the Classical Greek Household: the archaeological evidence", Annual of the British School at Athens 90363-81. Nevett, L. C, "Separation or Seclusion? Towards an archaoelogical approach to investigating women in the Greek household in the fifth to third centuries BC", Architecture and Order, Approaches to Social Space, der., 98-112. Özgenel, L., "'Mahremiyet' Kavramının Eskiçağ Açılımları: Antik-çağ'da Konut Mimarisi ve Kullanımı Üzerinden bir Örnekleme", Türkiye'de Sanat ve Mimarlık Tarihçiliği Sorunları Sempozyumu, Nisan 2005, Erciyes Üniversitesi. Özgenel, L., "Anadolu'daki Yunan Dönemi Konutlarında Mekan Tanımı, Kullanımı ve Cinsiyet," OLBA 4, 125-143. Özgenel, L., "Antik Dönem Evleri ve Sahipleri: Batı Anadolu'daki İyon Konutları,"Arkeoloji ve Sanat 78,14-24. 220 Lale Özgenel

Padel 1993 Pellizer 1990 Pomeroy 1975 Rider 1916 Robertson 1969 Schaps 1998 Schede 1964 Sennett 1994 Skinner 1991 Steiner 2002 Triimper 1998 Walker 1993 Walter-Karydi 1998 Williams 1993 Padel, R. "Women: model for possession by Greek daemons", Images of Women in Antiquity, der. A. Cameron ve A. Kuhrt, 3-19. Pellizer, E., "Outlines of a Morphology of Sympotic Entertainment", Sympotica, a Symposium on the Symposion, der. O. Murray, 177-184. Pomeroy, S. B., Goddesses, Whores, Wives and Slaves, women in Classical Antiquity, New York. Rider, B. C, The Greek House, its history and development from the Neolithic period to the Hellenistic Age, Cambridge. Robertson, D. S., Greek and Roman Architecture, Cambridge. Schaps, D. M., "What was Free about a Free Athenian Woman?", Transactions of the American Philological Association 128,161-188. Schede, M., Die Ruinen von Priene, Berlin. Sennett, R., Flesh and Stone, the body and the city in Western civilization, New York. Skinner, M. B., "Nossis of Thelyglössos: the private text and the public book", Women's History and Ancient History, der. S. B. Pomeroy, 20-47. Steiner, A., "Private and Public, Links between Symposion and Sys-sition in Fifth-Century Athens", Classical Antiquity 21, 347-379. Triimper, M., Wohnen in Delos, Eine Baugeschichtliche Untersu-chungen zum Wandel der Wohnkultur in ellenistischer Zeit, Internationale Archâologie 46, Rahden. Walker, S., "Women and Housing in Classical Greece: the archaeological evidence", Images of Women in Antiquity, der. A. Cameron -A. Kuhrt, 81-91. Walter-Karydi, E., The Greek House, the rise of the noble houses in late Classical times, Atina. Williams, D., "Women on Athenian Vases: problems of interpretation", Images of Women in Antiquity, der. A. Cameron - A. Kuhrt, 92-106.