Küreselleşen Dünyada rekabete ilişkin uluslararası sorunlar: çokuluslu şirketlerin artan gücü ve gelişmekte olan ülkeler

Bu çalışmada, küreselleşmeyle birlikte ticaret ve rekabet politikaları arasındaki sınırın bulanıklaşması, ticaret ve rekabet politikalarının iç içe geçmesi üzerinde durulmaktadır. Bu çerçevede, rekabete ilişkin ticaretle bağlantılı uluslararası sorunların ağırlığı giderek artmaktadır. Uzun bir tartışma döneminden sonra, konunun Dünya Ticaret Örgütii(DTÖ) kapsamına alınmaması yönünde karar verilmiş olmakla birlikte, ortaya çıkan uluslararası meselelerin ışığında konu güncelliğini sürdürmektedir. Ticaretle ilişkili rekabete ilişkin uluslararası sorun alanlarının başında uluslararası karteller, üçüncü ülkeler üzerinde taşma etkileri olan birleşmeler ve uluslararası oligopoller gelmektedir. Her üç durum da, küreselleşmeyle birlikte ekonomik ağırlıkları ve hâkimiyetleri önemli ölçüde artan çokuluslu şirketlerle yakından ilgilidir. Serbest ticarete yönelerek iç piyasalarını dış rekabete açan gelişmekte olan ülkeler, gerek iç, gerek dış piyasalarda çokuluslu şirketlerle rekabet etmek durumunda kalmaktadırlar. Gelişmekte olan ülkelerin(GOÜ) gerek uluslararası karteller, gerek taşma etkileri olan birleşmeler konusunda haklarım arayabilmeleri olanakları son derece sınırlıdır. Uluslararası oligopoller ise, gelişmekte olan ülkelerin uluslararası piyasalarda rekabetçiliğini önemli ölçüde engellemektedir, O nedenle, bu çalışmada özellikle gelişmekte olan ülkelerin çokuluslu şirketler karşısındaki konumları üzerinde durulmaktadır.

Interenational issues about competition in the globalized world: increasing power of transnational corporations and developing countries

In the era of globalization, the line between trade and competition policies is getting blurred. The developments like elimination of trade restrictions, liberalization of capital jlows and rapid technological improvements have changed conditions of competition deeply. By definition, trade policy deals with competition issues behind the boundaries of the count ly, whereas competition policy within those boundaries. But in open economy conditions, many international anticompetitive practices like international cartels, and mergers and acquisitions with international spillovers occur.In this context, there has been a long discussion on whether trade related international issues about competition should be included in the WTO agenda or not. The proposal in this direction was announced at Singapore Ministerial Conference in 1996for the first time. At Cancun Ministerial Conference in 2003 this issue was decided to be removed from the WTO agenda. But on the ground that trade related international competition issues are getting important, the discussion about these subjects didıı't cease İn the international arena.In this study, the increasing power of transnational corporations is particularly emphasized. Of course, the presence of transnational corporations is not new. But with the process of globalization their weight and global domination in global markets have increased apparently. Transnational firms have a leading role in international cartel formations. International cartels can create serious barriers of entiy for other producers and have negative effects on consumers. Now that transnational corporations are backed by their countiy of origin, even developed countries find themselves in severe difficulties İn getting information and legal help from other countries about carl el firms and their activities. In this context, developing countries have much bigger problems. Certainly, a developing countiy would have more difficulties in pushing a developed countiy to cooperate in a cartel investigation against a cartelist transnational firm its own countiy of origin. Moreover, in case of a cartelist transnational firm has important weight and dominance İn a sector of a developing countiy, that countiy may refrain from cooperation in a cartel investigation against the cartelist firm. Developing countries may endure negative effects of cartels for not to loose production and employment created in their countries by cartelist firms.On the other hand, mergers and acquisitions between big transnational corporations can form a new firm with stronger market power and affect some third country markets and even industries tremendously. In order to protect their firms' benefits, developed countries monitor mergers and acquisitions of foreign transnational firms and bargain with each other effectively. However, even if developing countries monitor transnational firms' mergers and acquisitions and doubt to face a potential harm, they wouldn V have the necessaiy power to oppose it. Furthermore, in many industries, industrial concentration has deepened. In this context, global oligopolies constitute another international problem area thai blurs the line between trade and competition policies. By cooperating in developing the highest technology, global oligopolist firms can create serious enliy barriers for developing country firms.In the light of the issues discussed in this study, it is understood that trade liberalization doesn't always end up in perfect competition conditions. Now that there are asymmetrical power relations between transnational corporations of developed countries and small and medium sized firms of developing countries, enhancing of market access opportunities may not serve automatically to enhance competition in domestic markets. It is obvious that, in order to be able to compete in domestic and global markets, developing countiy firms have to be and stay competitive. Reminding that nearly half of the UTO members don'/ have domestic competition laws, this study recommends that developing countries should be more aware of the international aspects of the competition issues and build their own appropriate national competition laws designedfor their own needs.

___

  • BONANNO, Alessandro, CONSTANCE, Douglas H. and LORENZ, Heather. "Powers And Limits Of Transnational Corporations: The Case Of ADM", Rural Sociology, Vol. 65, No. 3, (September 2000).
  • CHESNAIS, François. "Multinational Enterprises And The International Diffusion Of Technology", Technical Change And Economic Theory, Ed. Giovanni Dosi, Christopher Freeman, Richard Nelson, Gerard Silverberg and Luc Soete, Pinter PubL, UK, (1988).
  • CHESNAIS, François. "World Oligopoly, Rivalry Between 'Global' Firms And Global Corporate Competitiveness", Technological Innovation, Multinational Corporations And New International Competitiveness, Ed. Jose Molcro. Harvard Academic Publ., (UK, 1995).
  • ÇAŞICURLU, Sibel. "TRIPS'le Nereye: İlaç Sektörü Örneğinde Bir Değerlendirme", Ekonomik Yaklaşım, Sayı 55, Cilt 16, (2005).
  • EROL, Kemal. "Rekabet Kurallarının Ülke Dışı Uygulanması", www.rekabet.gov.tr/dosyaIar/tezler/tez85.pdf Erişim tarihi: 27.12.2010.
  • EVENETT, Simon J., LEVENSTEIN, Margaret C. and SUS LOW, Valene Y.. "International Cartel Enforcement: Lessons From The 1990s", World Economy, Vol. 24, No. 9, (2001).
  • HOEKMAN, Bernard and HOLMES, Peter. "Competition Policy, Developing Countries and The WTO", The World Economy, Vol. 22, No. 6, (August, 1999), s.877.
  • HOPE, Einar. "Introduction", Competition And Trade Policies: Coherence Or Conflict?. Ed. Einar Hope And Per Maeleng, Routledge, UK,(I998).
  • JOEKES, Susan and EVANS, Phil. Competition And Development: The Power Of Competitive Markets. International Development Research Ccntre(lDRC), (Canada, 2008).
  • KHEMANI, R. Shyam. "A Brief Note On The Role Of Competition Policy In Economic Development", Competition And Trade Policies: Coherence Or Conflict?. Ed. Einar Hope And Per Maeleng, Routledge, UK,(1998).
  • KUNT ALP, Erden, ÖZDEMIR, A. Murat ve ARIKEL, Sülün. "Rekabet Hukukunda Temel Yaklaşımlar: Chicago Ve Harvard Okullarının Rekabet Kanunu Açısından Karşılaştırılması", Perşembe Konferansları 10, Rekabet Kurumu Yayını, (Ekim 2000).
  • LEVENSTEIN, Margaret and SUSLOW, Valene. "Contemporary International Cartels and Developing Countries: Economic Effects and Implications For Competition Policy", Antitrust Law Journal, Vol. 71, No 3, (2004).
  • OECD Background Report. Enhancing The Role Of SMEs In Global Value Chains, OECD Global Conference,Tokyo, 31 May- Uune 2007, www.oecd.org.
  • SCHERER, Frederic M.. "International Trade And Competition Policy", Competition And Trade Policies: Coherence Or Conflict?. Ed. Einar Hope And Per Maeleng, Routledge, UK,(1998).
  • TARULLO, Daniel K.. "Norms And Institutions In Global Competition Policy", The American Journal Of International Law, Vol. 94, No. 3, (July 2000).
  • WAVERMAN, Leonard. "Competition And/Or Trade Policy?", Competition And Trade Policies: Coherence Or Conflict?. Ed. Einar Hope And Per Maeleng, Routledge, (UIC, 1998).