GÜVENLİ CERRAHİ KONTROL LİSTESİNİN ETKİNLİĞİ: SİSTEMATİK İNCELEME
Öz Amaç: Güvenli Cerrahi Kontrol Listesinin etkinliğinin değerlendirildiği araştırmaların gözden geçirilmesi ve gelecekteki araştırmalara ışık tutması amacıyla gerçekleştirilmiştir. Yöntem: Tanımlayıcı çalışmada Pubmed/MEDLINE ve Cochrane Library veri tabanları üzerinden “güvenli cerrahi kontrol listesi”, “dünya sağlık örgütü güvenli cerrahi kontrol listesi”,“etkinlik” ve “etki” anahtar kelimeleri kullanıldı. Kasım 2015 öncesindeki yayınlanmış 49 makale ele alındı. Etkinlik sonuçları uyum, komplikasyon ve mortalite oranı, hasta güvenliği, ekip iletişimi, çalışan ve hasta memnuniyeti ve maliyet açısından değerlendirildi. Bulgular: Uyumun en kolay olduğu bölüm insizyon öncesiyken, en zor olduğu bölüm ise çıkış kontrolü evresidir. Listenin kullanımı sonrası komplikasyon ve mortalite oranlarında anlamlı bir düşüş bulunmaktadır. Listenin kullanımı plansız ameliyathaneye dönüşlerde, yeniden ameliyat olma oranında ve istenmeyen etkilerde azalma olurken hasta kimliğinin doğrulanmasında ve hastanın tıbbi durumunda farkındalıkta artma görüldü. Ekip iletişiminde artma ve iletişim hatalarında düşme görüldü. Çalışanlar listenin uygulanmasını %50 ile %95 oranında olumlu buldu. Ameliyathane harcamaları düştü. Hasta memnuniyeti %57.1’den %90.8’e yükseldi. Sonuçlar: Listenin kullanımı ile komplikasyon ve mortalite oranlarındaki ciddi azalma olduğu, ameliyathanede ekip çalışmasını ve iletişimi geliştirdiği, ameliyathaneden plansız geri dönüşleri azaltması, ameliyat olma oranını azaltması, hasta kimliğinin doğrulanma sıklığını arttırması ve cerrahinin istenmeyen etkilerini azaltması nedeniyle hasta güvenliğini geliştirmektedir. GCKL ekip üyeleri arasında iletişimi, işbirliğini ve hasta güvenliğini geliştiren bir araç olarak önerilmektedir.
___
- Yuan CT, Walsh D, Tomarken JL, Alpern R,
Shakpeh J, Bradley EH. Incorporating The World
Health Organization Surgical Safety Checklist into
Practice at Two Hospitals in Liberia.The Joint
Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety.
2012; 38(6): 254-60.
- Yavuz van Giersbergen M. Hasta Güvenliğini
Sağlamada Güncel Yaklaşımlar. Yavuz van
Gıersbergen M, Kaymakçı Ş. editör. Ameliyathane
Hemşireliği. 1.Baskı. İzmir:Metabasım; 2015. p.131-
142.
- World Health Organization-WHO. Patient Safety.
2016 http://www.euro.who.int/en/healthtopics/Health-systems/patient-safety.
(Erişim tarihi:
05.10.2016).
- World Health Organization-WHO. (2009). WHO
Guidelines for safe surgery, safe surgery saves lives.
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/44185/1/9789
241598552_eng.pdf (erişim tarihi:23.07.2015)
- World Health Organization-WHO. (2008) WHO.
The second global patient safety Challenge: Safe
Surgery Saves Lives.
http://www.who.int/patientsafety/safesurgery/knowle
dge_base/SSSL_Brochure_finalJun08.pdf (erişim
tarihi:23.07.2015)
- Weiser TG, Regenbogen SE, Thompson KD,
Haynes AB, Lipsitz SR, Berry WR, Gawande AA.
An Estimation of The Global Volume of
Surgery:Amodelling Strategy Based on Available
Data. The Lancet. 2008; 372(9633): 139-144.
- Weiser TG, Haynes AB. Dziekan G, Berry WR,
Lipsitz SR ve ark. Effect of A 19-Item Surgical
Safety Checklist During Urgent Operations in A
Global Patient Population. Annals Of Surgery, 2010;
251(5): 976-80.
- Vogts N., Hannam J. A., Merry A.F. ve ark.
Compliance and Quality in Administration of A
Surgical Safety Checklist in A Tertiary New Zealand
Hospital. New Zealand Medical Journal.
2011;124:1342, 48-58.
- Safety Checklist" on In-Hospital Mortality: A Cohort
Study. The Annals of Surgery. 2012; 255(1): 44-9.
- van Klei WA, Hoff RG, van Aarnhem EE,
Simmermacher RK, Regli LP, Kappen TH ve ark.
Effects of The Introduction of The WHO "Surgical
- Urbach DR, Govindarajan A, Saskin R, Wilton
AS, Baxter NN. Introduction of Surgical Safety
Checklists In Ontario, Canada. The New England
Journal of Medicine. 2014; 370(11): 1029-38.
- Truran P, Critchley RJ, Gilliam A. Does Using The
WHO Surgical Checklist Improve Compliance to
Venous Tromboembolism Prophylaxis Guidelines?.
The Surgeon, 2011; 9(6): 309-311.
- Takala RS, Pauniaho SL, Kotkansalo A, Helmiö P,
Blomgren K, Helminen M ve ark. A pilot Study of
The Implementation of WHO Surgical Checklist in
Finland: Improvements in Activities and
Communication. Acta Anaesthesiologica
Scandinavica. 2011; 55(10): 1206-14.
- Sparks EA, Wehbe-Janek H, Johnson RL, Smythe
WR, Papaconstantinou HT. Surgical Safety
Checklist Compliance: A Job Done Poorly! Journal of
the American College of Surgeons. 2013; 217(5):
867-73.
- Sivathasan N, Rakowski KRM, Robertson BFM,
Vijayarajan L. The World Health Organization's
‘Surgical Safety Checklist’: Should Evidence-Based
Initiatives Be Enforced in Hospital Policy? Journal of
The Royal Society of Medicine Short Reports. 2010;
1(40): 1-5.
- Sewell M, Adebibe M, Jayakumar P, Jowett C,
Kong K, Vemulapalli K ve ark. Use of The WHO
Surgical Safety Checklist in Trauma and Orthopaedic
Patients. International Orthopaedics. 2011; 35(6):
897-901.
- Semel ME, Resch S, Haynes AB, Funk LM, Bader
A, Berry WR ve ark. Adopting a Surgical Safety
Checklist Could Save Money and Improve The
Quality of Care in U.S. Hospitals. Health Aff
(Millwood). 2010; 29(9): 1593-9.
- Saturno PJ, Soria-Aledo V, Da Silva Gama ZA,
Lorca-Parra F, Grau-Polan M. Understanding
WHO Surgical Checklist Implementation: Tricks and
Pitfalls. An Observational Study. World Journal of
Surgery. 2014; 38(2): 287-95.
- Rydenfält C, Johansson G, Odenrick P, Åkerman
K, Larsson PA. Compliance with The WHO Surgical
Safety Checklist: Deviations and Possible
Improvements. International Journal for Quality in
Health Care. 2013; 25(2):182-7.
- Russ S, Rout S, Caris J, Mansell J, Davies R,
Mayer E ve ark. Measuring variation in use of the
WHO surgical safety checklist in the operating room:
a multicenter prospective cross-sectional study.
Journal of the American College of Surgeons. 2015;
220(1): 1-11.
- Rosenberg NM, Urman RD, Gallagher S, Stenglein
J, Liu X, Shapiro FE. Effect of An Office-Based
Surgical Safety System on Patient Outcomes. Eplasty.
2012; 12(e59): 493-99.
- Rodrigo-Rincon I, Martin-Vizcaino MP, TirapuLeon
B, Zabalza-Lopez P, Zaballos-Barcala N,
Villalgordo-Ortin P ve ark. The Effects of Surgical
Checklists on Morbidity and Mortality: a Pre- and
Post-Intervention Study. Acta Anaesthesiologica
Scandinavica. 2015; 59(2): 205-14.
- Rateau F, Levraut L, Colombel AL, Bernardb JL,
Quarantac JF, Cabarrotd P ve ark. Check-List
"Patient Safety" in The Operating Room: One Year
Experience of 40,000 Surgical Procedures at The
University Hospital of Nice. Annales Françaises
d'Anesthésie et de Réanimation. 2011; 30(6): 479-83.
- Poon SJ, Zuckerman SL, Mainthia R, Hagan SL,
Lockney DT, Zotov A ve ark. Methodology and
Bias in Assessing Compliance with A Surgical Safety
Checklist. The Joint Commission Journal on Quality
and Patient Safety. 2013; 39(2): 77-82.
- Pickering SP, Robertson ER, Griffin D, Hadi M,
Morgan LJ, Catchpole KC ve ark. Compliance and
Use of The World Health Organization Checklist in
U.K. Operating Theatres. British Journal of Surgery.
2013; 100(12): 1664-70.
- Paugam-Burtz C, Guerrero O. French Surgical
Checklist In A Universitary Hospital: Achievements
One Year After Implementation. 2011; 30(6): 475-8.
- Papaconstantinou HT, Smythe WR, Reznik SI,
Sibbitt S, Wehbe-Janek H. Surgical Safety Checklist
and Operating Room Efficiency: Results from A
Large Multispecialty Tertiary Care Hospital. The
American Journal of Surgery. 2013; 206(6): 853-9.
- Panesar SS, Noble DJ, Mirza SB, Patel B, Mann B,
Emerton M ve ark. Can The Surgical Checklist
Reduce The Risk of Wrong Site Surgery in
Orthopaedics?--Can The Checklist Help? Supporting
Evidence From Analysis of A National Patient
Incident Reporting System. Journal of Orthopaedic
Surgery and Research. 2011; 6(18): 1-7.
- Omi A, Terai Y, Muro D. Successful Trial for
Introduction of The WHO Surgical Safety Checklist.
Masui, The Japanese Journal of Anesthesiology.
2014; 63(1): 105-11.
- Norton EK, Rangel SJ. Implementing a pediatric
Surgical Safety Checklist in The OR and Beyond.
AORN Journal. 2010; 92(1): 61-71.
- Morgan PJ, Cunningham L, Mitra S, Wong N, Wu
W, Noguera V ve ark. Surgical Safety Checklist:
Implementation in An Ambulatory Surgical Facility.
Canadian Journal of Anesthesia. 2013; 60(6): 528-38.
- Lübbeke A, Hovaguimian F, Wickboldt N, Barea
C, Clergue F, Hoffmeyer P ve ark. Effectiveness of
The Surgical Safety Checklist in A High Standard
Care Environment. Medical Care. 2013; 51(5): 425-9.
- Levy SM, Senter CE, Hawkins RB, Zhao JY,
Doody K, Kao LS ve ark. Implementing A Surgical
Checklist: More Than Checking A Box. Surgery.
2012; 152(3): 331-6.
- Lepänluoma M, Rahi M, Takala R, Löyttyniemi E,
Ikonen TS. Analysis of Neurosurgical Reoperations:
Use of A Surgical Checklist and Reduction of
Infection-Related and Preventable ComplicationRelated
Reoperations. Journal of Neurosurgery. 2015;
123(1): 145-52.
- Kwok AC, Funk LM, Baltaga R, Lipsitz SR,
Merry AF, Dziekan G ve ark. Implementation of
The World Health Organization Surgical Safety
Checklist, Including Introduction of Pulse Oximetry,
in a resource-Limited Setting. Annals of Surgery.
2013; 257(4): 633-9.
- Kim RY, Kwakye G, Kwok AC, Baltaga R,
Ciobanu G, Merry AF ve ark. Sustainability and
Long-Term Effectiveness of The WHO Surgical
Safety Checklist Combined with Pulse Oximetry in A
Resource-Limited Setting: Two-Year Update From
Moldova. JAMA Surgery. 2015; 150(5): 473-9.
- Kearns RJ, Uppal V, Bonner J, Robertson J,
Daniel M, McGrady EM. The Introduction of A
Surgical Safety Checklist in A Tertiary Referral
Obstetric Centre. BMJ Quality and Safety. 2011;
20(9): 818-22.
- Kawano T, Taniwaki M, Ogata K, Sakamoto M,
Yokoyama M. Improvement of Teamwork and
Safety Climate Following Implementation of The
WHO Surgical Safety Checklist at A University
Hospital in Japan. Journal of Anesthesia. 2014; 28(3):
467-70.
- Helmiö P, Blomgren K, Takala A, Pauniaho SL,
Takala RS, Ikonen TS. Towards Better Patient
Safety: WHO Surgical Safety Checklist in
Otorhinolaryngology. Clinical Otolaryngology. 2011;
36(3): 242-7.
- Haynes AB, Weiser TG, Berry WR, Lipsitz SR,
Breizat AS, Dellinger EP ve ark. Changes in Safety
Attitude and Relationship to Decreased Postoperative
Morbidity and Mortality Following İmplementation of
A Checklist-Based Surgical Safety Intervention. BMJ
Quality and Safety. 2011; 20(1): 102-7.
- Haynes AB, Weiser TG, Berry WR, Lipsitz SR,
Breizat AS, Dellinger EP ve ark. A Surgical Safety
Checklist to Reduce Morbidity and Mortality in A
Global Population. The New England Journal of
Medicine. 2009; 360(5): 491-9.
- Haugen AS, Søfteland E, Eide GE, Sevdalis N,
Vincent CA, Nortvedt MW ve ark. Impact of The
World Health Organization's Surgical Safety
Checklist on Safety Culture in The Operating Theatre: A Controlled İntervention Study. British Journal of
Anaesthesia. 2013; 110(5): 807-15.
- Haugen AS, Søfteland E, Almeland SK, Sevdalis N,
Vonen B, Eide GE ve ark. Effect of The World
Health Organization Checklist on Patient Outcomes:
A Stepped Wedge Cluster Randomized Controlled
Trial. Annals of Surgery. 2015; 261(5): 821-8.
- Hannam JA, Glass L, Kwon J, Windsor J,
Stapelberg F, Callaghan K ve ark. A Prospective,
Observational Study of The Effects of
Implementation Strategy on Compliance with A
Surgical Safety Checklist. BMJ Quality and Safety.
2013; 22(11): 940-7.
- Gueguen T, Coevoet V, Mougeot M, Pierron A,
Blanquart D, Voicu M ve ark. Deployment of The
Checklist "Patient Safety in The Operating Room" in
Two Lorraine Hospitals. Performances and
Difficulties. Annales Françaises d'Anesthésie et de
Réanimation. 2011; 30(6): 489-94.
- Global Burden of Disease-GBD. Global, Regional,
and National Age-Sex Specific All-Cause and CauseSpecific
Mortality For 240 Causes of Death, 1990-
2013:A Systematic Analysis For The Global Burden
of Disease Study 2013. The Lancet Journal. 2015;
385(9963): 117-71.
- Fourcade A, Minvielle E, Blache JL, Bourgain JL.
Assessment of The French Surgical Checklist: The
Experience of 17 French Cancer Centres. Annales
Françaises d'Anesthésie et de Réanimation. 2011;
30(6): 495-500.
- Fargen KM, Velat GJ, Lawson MF, Firment CS,
Mocco J, Hoh BL. Enhanced Staff Communication
and Reduced Near-Miss Errors with A
Neurointerventional Procedural Checklist. Journal of
Neurointerventional Surgery. 2013;5(5): 497-500.
- Delgado Hurtado JJ, Jiménez X, Peñalozo MA,
Villatoro C, de Izquierdo S, Cifuentes M.
Acceptance of The WHO Surgical Safety Checklist
among Surgical Personnel in Hospitals in Guatemala
City. BMC Health Services Research, 2012;12(169):
1-5.
- de Vries EN, Prins HA, Crolla RMPH, den Outer
AJ, van Andel G, van Helden SH ve ark. Effect of
A Comprehensive Surgical Safety System on Patient
Outcomes. The New England Journal of Medicine.
2010; 363(20): 1928-37.
- Da Silva-Freitas R, Martín-Laez R, Madrazo-Leal
CB, Villena-Martin M, Valduvieco-Juaristi I,
Martínez-Agüeros JÁ ve ark. Establishment of A
Modified Surgical Safety Checklist for The
Neurosurgical Patient: Initial Experience in 400
Cases. Neurocirugía. 2012; 23(2): 60-9.
- Çakmakçı M, Akalın HE. Hasta Güvenliği Türkiye
ve Dünya. 1. Baskı. Ankara Türk Tabipler Birliği.
2011. p.11-17.
- Cullati S, Le Du S, Raë AC, Micallef M, Khabiri E,
Ourahmoune A ve ark. Is The Surgical Safety
Checklist Successfully Conducted? An Observational
Study of Social Interactions in The Operating Rooms
of A Tertiary Hospital. BMJ Quality and Safety.
2013; 22(8): 639-46.
- Bliss LA, Ross-Richardson CB, Sanzari LJ,
Shapiro DS, Lukianoff AE, Bernstein BA, Ellner
SJ. Thirty-Day Outcomes Support Implementation of
A Surgical Safety Checklist. Journal of the American
College of Surgeons. 2012; 215(6): 766-76.
- Biskup N, Workman AD, Kutzner E, Adetayo OA,
Gupta SC. Perioperative Safety in Plastic Surgery: Is
The World Health Organization Checklist Useful in a
Broad Practice? Annals of Plastic Surgery. 2016;
76(5): 550-5.
- Bashford T, Reshamwalla S, McAuley J, Allen NH,
McNatt Z, Gebremedhen YD. Implementation of
the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist in an Ethiopian
Referral Hospital. Patient Safety in Surgery. 2014;
8(16): 1-11.
- Askarian M, Kouchak F ve Palenik CJ. Effect of
Surgical Safety Checklists on Postoperative Morbidity
and Mortality Rates, Shiraz, Faghihy Hospital, A 1-
Year Study. Quality Management in Health Care.
2011; 20(4): 293-7.