THE ROLE OF JUDICIAL COMMISSION IN SUPERVISING THE JUDGES AGAINST THE DILEMMA OF THE JUDICIAL INDEPENDENCY

Hakimlerin ve yüksek yargı kurumlarının işleyişinin denetlenmesinde kontrol ve dengeler ilkesi etkilidir. Bu görüş davranışsal ve ahlaki sapmalara uğradığı ölçüde bir yargı diktatörlüğüne dönüşmesine karşın yargı bağımsızlığını gözetme düşüncesine dayanır. Hakimler Yüksek Kurulu, hakimleri, etik ve davranışsal kuralları ihlal etmeleri halinde kalıcı süreyle işten men ile sonuçlanabilecek şekilde yaptırım mekanizmaları üzerinden denetler. Yaptırımın tahmili, kontrol ve dengeler ilkesi uygulanması bağlamında Adliye Encümeni ile Yargıtayın yetki ve etki alanındadır.

Yargı Komisyonunun Hâkimleri Yargı Bağımsızlığı İkilemine Karşı Denetleme Rolü

Accountability against the performance of judges and the institutions of Supreme Court is the implementation of the principle of checks and balances of the judicial institution. The idea is based on the concept of the independency of judicial power dilemma which is potentially judicial tyranny as the deviation of behavior and ethics. Instrument of the accountability to the performance of judges is done by enforcement effort on mechanism of the Honorary Assembly of Judges against the judges who has proven violated the Code of Ethics and Code of Conduct of judges with the sanctions in the form of permanent dismissal. The imposition of the sanction is the authority or domain of the Judicial Commission and the Supreme Court as the application of the principle of checks and balances.

___

Alamsyah, Bunyamin, 2010. Position and the Judicial Commission's authority in the state system of Indonesia, Bandung: The Islamic Educational Publishing Foundation Al-Musdariyah Cileunyi.

Asrun, A. Muhammad, 2004. Justice Crisis: The Supreme Court Under Soeharto, Jakarta: Elsam.

Budiardjo, Miriam, 1978. Basics of Political Science, Jakarta: PT. Gramedia.

Diansyah, Febri, 2010. "Map of Blind" Legal Mafia Eradication: Could Eradicate Mafia Mafia?, The Justice Reform and Responsibility of the State, Jakarta: Judicial Commission of the Republic of Indonesia.

Falaakh, M. Fajrul, 2009. Judicial system in Indonesia, in Bridges with Africa: Images of Law Enforcement in Indonesia, Jakarta: The Judicial Commission of the Republic of Indonesia.

Indrayana, Denny, 2007. Amendment of 1945 Constitution: Between Myth and Demolition, Bandung: Mizan.

Istanto, F. Sugeng, 2007. Legal Research, Yogyakarta: CV. Ganda.

Supreme Court, 2003. Academic texts and the Draft Law On the Judicial Commission, Jakarta: Supreme Court.

Marzuki, 2005. Peter Mahmud. Legal Research, Jakarta: Kencana.

Marzuki, Suparman, 2011. Supervision of the Fair Judge for Justice, the Judiciary Towards Clean grounding determination, Jakarta: Judicial Commission of the Republic of Indonesia.

Muqoddas, M. Busyro, 2008. Role in the Transformation of the Judicial Commission and Court Reform (Constraints and Prospects), the Commission on Judicial and Social Justice, Jakarta: Judicial Commission of the Republic of Indonesia.

Muqoddas, M. Busyro, M. Busyro, 2010. "Institutional Dynamics KY, An Education", Paper Seminar on Comparative Models of Judicial Commissions, Jakarta.

Muqoddas, M. Busyro, M. Busyro, 2011. Intelligence Regime Hegemony: Dark Side of Justice Case Jihad, Yogyakarta: PUSHAM-UII.

Pompe, Sebastian, 2012. The collapse of the Supreme Court Institute, the Institute for Research and Advocacy for the Independence of the Judiciary, Jakarta: Institute for Research and Advocacy for the Independence of the Judiciary.

Saleh, Abdul Rahman, 2008. Not Kampung Maling, not the Village feat; Memoir 930 Days in the Roundhouse Peak, Jakarta: PT Media Nusantara Compass.

Santoso, Mas Achmad, 2005. Towards the Establishment of the Judicial Commission, COMPASS, March 2.

Shetreet, Shimon, 1995. "Judicial Independence: New Conceptual Dimentions and Contemporary Challenges", in Shimon Shetreet and J. Deschenes (eds), Judicial Independence, Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff publishe.

Subekti, Valina Singka, 2008, Constructing the Constitutional Transition: Interest and Thought Struggle in the Process of the 1945 Amendment, Jakarta: PT. RajaGrafindo Persada.

Sumali, 2002. Reduction in the Executive Power Sector Regulation in Lieu of Law, Malang: UMM Press.

Syahuri, Taufiqurrohman, 2011, Various Aspects of Law Constitutional Commentary, Jakarta: Kencana Prenada Media Group, 2011.

Syahuri, Taufiqurrohman, Taufiqurrohman, Strengthening Constitutional Functions and Duties of the Judicial Commission, Jakarta: Judicial Commission of the Republic of Indonesia.

Thohari, A. Ahsin, 2010. "Constitutional Design in the state system of the Judicial Commission of Indonesia", Journal of Legislation of Indonesia, Vol. No. 7. 1, March, Jakarta: Directorate Kenderal Legislation Ministry of Justice and Human Rights.

Voermans, Wim, 2002. Judicial Commission of the European Union Countries,Jakarta: LeIP and The Asia Foundation-USAID.

Widjojanto, Bambang, 2006. Judicial Commission: Checks and Balaces and Urgency Supervision Authority, Bridges with Africa in the Judicial Commission of the Republic of Indonesia, Jakarta: The Secretariat General of the Judicial Commission of the Republic of Indonesia.

Widjojanto, Bambang, Bambang, 2010. "Constitutional Reform: Perspectives of Justice's power, Journal of Legislation Indonesia", Vol. No. 7. 1, March, Jakarta: Directorate General Legislation Ministry of Justice and Human Rights.