Tanrı'nın Mahiyeti ve Basitlik Sorunu

To think that God has a quiddity is to admit that he has some essential/necessary properties. The main opponent view to this "divine quiddity" assertion is what is called "divine simplicity" thesis. According to this thesis, ascribing a "quiddity" to God and signify him with related properties should be rejected. Since this goes against the idea that God is a necessary, causless and asiety being. In this article both approachas will be evaluated and compared with reference to the views of the philosophers/theologians such as Farabi, İbn Sina, Aquinas, Gazali and contemporary thinkers like A. Plantinga, B. Leftow and R. Swinburne. The "divine quiddity" thesis will be advocated for two reasons. Firstly, God's having a quiddity is a precondition for mentioning about his existence and the nature of this existence. Secondly, "divine quiddity" view can be advocated together with the idea that God is necessary, causless being.

___

  • Avrain, Bruno, Kierkegaard et Freud, Paris, 1988.
  • Benac, Henrie, Nouveau Vocabulaire de la Dissertation de la Philosophic, Paris 1972.
  • Bochenski, I.M., Çağdaş Avrupa Felsefesi, Çev. Serdar Rifat Kırkoğlu, İst. 1983.
  • Bouillet, M. N., Dictionnaire Üniversel des Sciences, des Lettres et des arts, Paris 1861.
  • Coffy, Robert, Ateistlerin Tanrısı, Çev. Murtaza Korlaelçi, Ankara 2003.
  • Coffy, Dieu des athees, Paris 1970.
  • Foulquie, Paul, Dictionnaire de la Langue Philosophique, Paris 1992.
  • Garaudy, Roger, Yirminci Yüzyılda Marksizm, Çev. Galip Üstün, İst. 1968.
  • Garaudy, Şahitlerim, Çev. Cemal Aydın, İst. 2006.
  • Garaudy, İslamın ve İnsanlığın Geleceği, Çev. Cemal Aydın, İst. 2007.
  • Gilson, Etienne, Orta Çağda Felsefe, Çev. Ayşe Meral, İst. 2007.
  • Girardi, Jule, "Çağdaş Ateizmin Problemi", Çev. Murtaza Korlaelçi, A. Ü. İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi XLI, Ankara 2000.
  • Heidegger, Martin, Nietzsche'nin Tanrı Öldü Sözü ve Dünya Resimleri Çağı, Çev. Levent Özşar, Bursa 2006.
  • Http://fr. Wikipedia. Org/wiki Jean Rostand
  • Http://www. Sevde de/yabancilar/roger garaudy.htm.
  • İsmail Fennî,Lugatçe-i Felsefe, İst. 1341.
  • Janet, Paul, Seilles, Gabriel, Histoire de la Philosophic, Paris 1971.
  • Lagard, Andre- Michard Laurent, XX. Siecles, Bordace 1973.
  • Lalande, Andre, Vocabulaire Technique et Critique de la Philosophic, Paris 1980.
  • Le Dantec, Felix L'Atheisme, Paris 1929.
  • Legrand, Gerard, Vocabulaire de la Philosophic, Paris 1993.
  • Lepp, Ignace, Psychanalyse de 1'atheisme Moderne, Paris 1966.
  • Litre, Emile, Dictionnaire de la Langue Française, Paris 1873. Meydan Larausse, Cilt 4.
  • Moeller, Charles, Jean Paul Sartre ve Tabiatüstünün Bilinmemesi, Çev. Mehmet Toprak, İst 1969.
  • Moeller Aspect de l'atheisme dans Litterature Contemporain (1' Atheisme dans la vie et culture contemporaines, torn I, Paris 1967).
  • Neusch, Marcel, Aux Source de l'atheisme Contemporain, Le Centurion 1977.
  • Nietzsche Friedrich, Böyle Buyurdu Zerdüşt, Çev. A. Turhan Oflazoğlu, İst. 2005
  • Nietzsche Friedrich, L'Antechrists trad. Dominique Tassel, Paris 1967
  • Nietzsche Friedrich, Güç İstenci, Çev. Sedat Ümran, İst. 2002.
  • Nietzsche Friedrich, İyinin ve Kötünün Ötesinde, Çev. Ahmet İnam, İst. 2004.
  • Robert, Paul, Dictionnaire Alphabetique et Analogique de la Langue Française, Paris 1974.
  • Robert , Dictionnaire Üniversel des noms Propres Alphabetique et Analogique, Paris 1984.
  • Robert , Le Petit Robert, Paris 1974.
  • Rosenthal, M. -Yudin, P., Materyalist Felsefe Sözlüğü, Çev. Aziz Çalışlar, İst. 1975.
  • Sartre, Jean Paul, Sartre Sartre'ı Anlatıyor, Çev. Turhan İlgaz, İst. 1994.
  • Shirbekk, Gunnar- Gilje, Nils, Antik Yunan'dan Modern Dünya'ya Felsefe Tarihi, Çev.
  • Emrah, Akbaş, Şule Mutlu, İst. Tarihsiz.
  • Verneaux, Roger, Çağdaş Ateizm Üzerine Dersler, Çev. Murtaza Korlaelçi, Ankara 2001.
  • Verneaux, Egzistansiyalizm Üzerine Dersler, Çev. Murtaza Korlaelçi, Kayseri, 1994.
  • Verneaux, Histoire de la Philosophie Contemporaine, Paris 1987.
  • Von Aster, Ernst, İlk ve Orta Çağ Felsefe Tarihi, Uyarlayan Vural Okur, İst. 1999.
  • West, David, Kıta Avrupası Felsefesine Giriş, Çev. Ahmet Cevizci, İst. 1998.
  • Lagarde-Laurant Michard, XX* Siecle, Bordas 1973.