İKİLİ GÜVEN KAVRAMININ; BİRBİRİNE RAKİP İKİ ÖRGÜT (İŞYERİ-SENDİKA) ÜZERİNDEN İNCELENMESİ

Araştırmanın Amacı: İlgili yazında güven kavramı ağırlıklı olarak tek yönlü olarak ele alınıp; örgütsel süreçlerdeki rolü incelenmiştir. İkili güven kavramını araştıran çalışmamızda, işgörenlerin hem örgüte hem de sendikaya bağlı olmaları nedeniyle, güvenin iki yönlü (sendika/örgüt) olarak incelenmesi ve bir tarafa duyulan güven ya da güvensizliğin diğer tarafı nasıl etkileyeceği, konusu önem taşımakta olup; ilgili yazında bu yetersizliğin belli ölçüde giderilmesi amaçlanmıştır. Yazındaki bu boşluğu doldurabilmek için, bu çalışmada örgütsel güven kavramı iki yönlü olarak ele alınıp incelenecektir. Yöntem: Araştırmanın teorik kısmı ilgili yazın taraması ve yararlanılarak araştırma araştırması ise Enerji, Sağlık ve Eğitim olmak üzere üç farklı Kamu sektöründen 553 işgörene anket yöntemi kullanılarak tamamlanmıştır. Elde edilen veriler SPSS ve LISREL istatistik programlarında temel ve ileri düzey (Yapısal Eşitlik Modellemesi) testlere tabi tutulmuş ve sonuçlara ulaşılmıştır. Bulgular ve Sonuç: Yapısal Eşitlik Modeli (YEM) analizi sonucuna göre örgütsel güven düzeyinin bütün alt boyutlarının, sendikaya güven düzeyindeki bütün alt boyutları pozitif şekilde etkilediği, sendika yöneticisine karşı olan güven düzeyinin sendikaya olan güveni pozitif yönde etkilediği ve en yüksek güven düzeyinin enerji sektöründe, en düşük ise eğitim sektöründe olduğu sonucuna ulaşılmıştır.

DUAL TRUST CONCEPT OVER TWO RIVAL ORGANIZATIONS (WORKPLACE- TRADE UNION); SAMPLE OF HEALTH, ENERGY AND EDUCATION SECTORS

Objectives of the Research: In related literature, the concept of trust, approached from such one-way perspective, and its role in the organizational process, has thoroughly been discussed and studied. Our research aims to investigate the concept of dual trust, built upon experience of two-way relations and commitments of the employees towards both sides of their polarised environment to better reflect the character of these dual links with the organization on one, and the trade union, on the other side of this polar structure. Examining the issue of trust from this new perspective will allow to better establish, how exactly, the measure of confidence or distrust, existing in relation with any one side of such environment, can simultaneously be found affecting the relation of the employee with the other side of the organizational system. Thus existing theoretical deficiency is intended to be resolved upon the results of this study, to fill the gap in literature with concept of organizational trust, which comprises of extended model of analysis of these dual, simultaneous relations. Methods: The theoretical part of the study has been developed based on reviews of literature and in conjunction with conducted researches. Field research has been completed by using a questionnaire method, applied to 553 employees from three different public sectors: Energy, Health, and Education. Data obtained has been subjected to basic and advanced tests (Structural Equation Modeling) in SPSS and LISREL statistical software suites and results achieved were evaluated. Results: According to the results of Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) analysis, it is concluded that all the sub-dimensions of organizational trust level affect all the sub-dimensions of trust toward the trade union, the level of trust towards the union leaders, positively affects the trust towards the union itself and, that the highest levels of the trust in general, are seen in energy sector, while the lowest levels, within the scope of this research, respectively, are seen in the sector of educationroblem of the Research: If employees work in a situation of direct and simultaneous relations with two organizations (workplace and a trade union) which are both, competing with each other in conflict of interest. This situation, can be found in literature, described as a 'dual link' (Stagner, 1954). The necessity of maximizing organizational aims through relations with employees on both sides will be seen directly affecting the perceptions and behaviors of employees towards both of the organizations. Within such a context, the concept of 'organizational trust' will also have to be seen as linked to, and in either positive or negative manner affected by these dual links relations. However, when the relevant literature is examined, it is seen that this concept is discussed and approached, either as a trust to the union, or only to the workplace. The concept of trust of the employees, built upon the two conflicting influences and affected by rival organizations, not being previously examined as a concept of 'dual trust', can thus be highlighted, as the problem of this study. Objectives of the Research: In related literature, the concept of trust, approached from such one-way perspective, and its role in the organizational process, has thoroughly been discussed and studied. Our research aims to investigate the concept of dual trust, built upon experience of two-way relations and commitments of the employees towards both sides of their polarised environment to better reflect the character of these dual links with the organization on one, and the trade union, on the other side of this polar structure. Examining the issue of trust from this new perspective will allow to better establish, how exactly, the measure of confidence or distrust, existing in relation with any one side of such environment, can simultaneously be found affecting the relation of the employee with the other side of the organizational system. Thus existing theoretical deficiency is intended to be resolved upon the results of this study, to fill the gap in literature with concept of organizational trust, which comprises of extended model of analysis of these dual, simultaneous relations. Methods: The theoretical part of the study has been developed based on reviews of literature and in conjunction with conducted researches. Field research has been completed by using a questionnaire method, applied to 553 employees from three different public sectors: Energy, Health, and Education. Data obtained has been subjected to basic and advanced tests (Structural Equation Modeling) in SPSS and LISREL statistical software suites and results achieved were evaluated. Results: In this study, how the employees' level of trust towards two organizations (Trade Union/Work Place) which are in conflict of interest influence the other is attempted to be determined with 'dual trust' approach. In this context, these following conclusions have been reached. It is found that there is a positive relationship between three sub- dimensions of the trust level to the organization and three subdimensions of the trust level to the trade union as a result of an analysis of all the variables through Structural Equation Model. According to this result it is concluded that the level of trust to the organization has a positive effect on the level of trust to the union. These results demonstrate us that being connected to two rival organizations improves perception of trust to the both sides. Apart from this study in related literature, because there isn't a study related to dual trust, making a comparison hasn't been possible. However, Stagner (1954) who asserts dual trust points that two-way commitment shapes with the tendency of perceiving organizations and trade unions as a whole and the tendency of trusting to the both organizations when the working conditions are good. Additionally, the level of trust to the union management's positive influence on the trust to the union is another new relation discovered in this study of research. With reference to this result, it is seen that trust to the manager is the key role in achieving trust to the organization. In the research, it is found that the average level of trust of the employees to the union is %42, the average level of trust to the work place is %46. On the other hand, according to the 2000 World Values Survey results (www.bahcesehir.edu.tr) it is indicated that trust towards union is %75; trust towards organization %73. The research has been conducted in three different institutions. Among these institutions, energy sector has the highest level of trust, the second one is health sector and the third one is education sector. The reason of having the lowest level of trust in education sector can be having a higher level of education in comparison with other sectors. Because most of the teachers have bachelor's degree and the lowest level of trust belongs to the bachelor's in our study. Through this study, which is considered the Pioneer study in this area of work, dealing with concept of Dual Trust within three different concepts and improving models with reference to the issue have reached important conclusions. On the other side, by virtue of lack of study on 'dual trust' has not permitted to do a literal comparison. This case can be shown one of the restrictions of this study of research.

___

  • Arı, G.S.(2003) Yöneticiye Duyulan Güven Örgütsel Bağlılığı Artırır mı?", Gazi Üniversitesi T.T.E.F. Dergisi, Sayı:2, s.17-36.
  • Amogbokpa, T. G.(2010). The Connectıon Between The Two Facets Of TrustSupervısor Trust And Subordınate Trust) And Leader-Member Exchange Relatıonshıp In Two Manufacturıng Organızatıons PhD Thesise p.1-117
  • Adaman, F.,Çarkoğlu, A., Şenatalar, B., (2002). Household View on the Causes of Corruption in Turkey and Suggested Preventi ve Measures, TESEV, İstanbul, , s.34,37
  • Armstrong-Stassen, M. (1998). Downsizing the Federal Government: A Longitudinal Study of Managers' Reactions. Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 15:4, s.310-321.
  • Barney J.B., Hansen M.H.(1994).Trustworthiness as a Source of Competitive Advantage in Strategic Management Journal, v 15, 175-190
  • Börü,D.,İslamoğlu,G. Birsel,M.(2007).Güven: Bir Anket Geliştirme Çalışması. Öneri Der. 27.49-59.
  • Blau, P. (1964). Exchange And Power İn Social Life", New York: Wiley. 361-362
  • Cohen, A. (2005). Dual Commitment to the Organization and the Union: A Multi-Dimensional Approach Relations Industrielles; Summer 2005; 60, 3; ABI/INFORM Complete pg. 432
  • Çubukçu,K.,Tarakçıoğlu,S .(2010). Örgütsel Güven ve Bağlılık İlişkisinin Otelcilik ve Turizm Meslek Lisesi Öğretmenleri Üzerinde İncelenmesi İşletme Araştırmaları Dergisi 2/4 57-78
  • Demirbilek, T. (2008). İkili Bağlılık: İşletmeye ve Sendikaya Bağlılığın Belirleyicileri ve Sonuçları Ankara sanayi odası yayınları ASO Büyüteç s.70-74
  • Daboval,J.,Comish,R.,Swindle,B. GASTER,W.(1994). Trust Inventory for Small Businesses, Small Bisinesses Symposium www.sbaer.uca.edu/research/ssbia/1994/pdf/04.pdf p,1-9
  • Doğan, K.C.(2015). Yeni Kamu Yönetimi Ve Etik Anlayışının Türk Kamu Yönetiminde Kurumsallaşması: Kamu Görevlileri Etik Kurulu Örneği Turkish Studies International Periodical for the Languages, Literature and History of Turkish or Turkic Volume 10/10
  • Summer 2015, p. 381-402 DOI Number: http://dx.doi.org/10.7827/TurkishStudies.8321 ISSN: 1308-2140, Ankara-Turkey
  • Dünya Değerler Araştırması (Wvs) www.bahcesehir.edu.tr/habergoster/index/hid/664 U.T. 15.09.2015
  • Ferres, N. ve Travaglione, T. (2003). The Development and Validation of the Workplace Trust Survey (WTS): Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Methodologies. Erisim: 25.01.2013./desin.uamc.org/apros/papers/029.pdf
  • Gottlıeb, B.Err,W.A.(1950).An experiment in industrial harmony. Personnel Psychology,445
  • Gilbert, J. A. and Tang, T. (1998). An Examination of Organizational Trust Antecedents" Public Personnel Management, 27(3): 321-338.
  • Guido, Möllering, Bachmann, Reinhard, Lee, Soo Hee .(2004).Introduction, Understanding Organizational Trust-Foundations, Constellations, and Issues of Operati onalisation, Journal of Managerial Psyghology, Vol. 19, No. 6,pp. 556-570, , s. 557
  • Gürbüz, S.(2006). Örgütsel vatandaşlık davranışı ile duygusal bağlılık davranışı arasındaki ilişkilerin belirlenmesine yönelik bir araştırma. Ekonomik ve Sosyal Araştırmalar Dergisi, 3(1),48-75.
  • Halis, M. Gökgöz,G.S.yaşar,Ö. (2007). Örgütsel Güvenin Belirleyici Faktörleri Ve Bankacılık Sektöründe Bir Uygulama, Manas Üniversite Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, Sayı:17 s.1-217
  • Hardy,C.lane,C.bachmann,R.(1998).Distinguishing Trust and Powerin Inter organizational Relations: Formsand Façades of Trust. In (eds.), Trust within and between Organizations: Conceptual Issues and Emprical Applications. Oxford University Press. ss. 64-87.
  • Lazarıc, N.(2003). Trust Building Inside The Epistemic Community: An InvestigationWith An Empirical Study. In B. Nooteboom, F.Six.Trust Process in Organizations: Empirical Studies of Determinants And The Process Of Trust Development. E. Elgar Publishing. U.S.A.,ss. 147-167.
  • Matthai, J. M. (1989). Employee Perceptions Of Trust, Satisfaction and Commitment, As Predictors of Turnover Intentions in a Mental Health Setting, s.52.
  • Mcknight, D. H.,cummings, L. L., chervany, N. L.(1998). Initialtrustformation in new organizational relationships. The Academy of Management Review, p.23,
  • Nooteboom, B.(2002). Trust: Forms, Foundations, Functions, Failures And Figures.
  • Cheltenham:EdwardElgarPub.http://books.google.com.tr/books?id=sGVKr1XiHyIC&print sec=frontcover Neves,P.,caetano,A. (2006). Social Exchange Processes in Organizational Change: The Role of Trustand Control. Journal of Change Management. 6.4, 351-364
  • Papadopoulou, Panagiota, ANDREOU, Andreas, DRAKOULİS, Martakos (2001). Trustand Relationship Building in Electronic Commerge, Internet Research: Electronic Networking Applications AndPolicy, Volume 11, Number 4, pp. 322- 332, s. 323
  • Pekcan, A. (2010). Yöneticiye Güvenin Yenilikçi Örgütsel Vatandaslık Davranısı İle İliskisinde Örgüte Güvenin Etkisi, Doktora tezi- YÖK Tez Merkezi s.1-214
  • Perry,R.W.,mankin,L.D. (2007). Organizational Trust, Trust in The Chief Executive and Work Satiisfaction Public Personnal Management. 36.2,165-179.
  • Purcell, T.V.(1954). Dual Commitment to Company and Union in Sweden: An Examination of Predictors and Taxonomic Split MethodsEconomic and Industrial DemocracyNovember :531-564
  • Renzl, B.(2008).TrustIn Management and Knowledge Sharing: TheMediating Effects Of Fearand Knowledge Documentation The International Journal Of Management Science Omega, Volume 36, Issue 2, April, Pages 206-220.
  • Reed, c. S.,Young, w., Mchugh, p., p. (1994). A Comparativelook at Dual Commitment: an International Study Human Relations 47. P.10
  • Stagner,R.(1954).Dual allegiance as a problem in modern society.Personnel Psychology,7, 41-47
  • Seymen, O.A, Kılıç, T,(2012) - Çıkar Çatışması İçindeki İki Ayrı Örgüte Bağlı Olmanın (İşyeri ve Sendika) İşgörenlerin Güven Düzeyine ve Sendika Üyeliği Kararına Etkisi: Turizm Sektörü Örneği- Gümüşhane Üniversitesi III. Turizmde İnsan Kaynakları Gelişimi Semp. 10-11 Mayıs Antalya.
  • Sydow, Jörg (1998). Understandingthe Costitution of Interorganizational Trust". In C.Lane, &R.Bachmann (eds.), Trust within and between Organizations: Conceptual Issuesand Emprical Applications. Oxford UniversityPress. ss. 31-62. London.
  • Sheppard, B. H.,Sherman, D. M. (1998).The grammars of trust:A model and generaimplications (Special topic forum on trust in and between organizations).Acad. of Manag. Rev. 23(3), 422-437.
  • Surface, Carol A. (1995). Organizational and union commitment patterns among blue collar workers: job characteristics and instrumentality as predictors.http://books.google.com.tr/books/ about/Organizational_andunioncommitmentpatt.html?id=QMlDOAAACAAJ&redir_esc=y p.1-192
  • Sıtkın, B. S.,Stıckel,D (1996). "The Dynamics of Distrust in an Era of Quality". In R. M. Kramer, & T. R. Tyler (eds.), Trust in Organizations: Frontiers Of Theory And Research. Thousand Oaks.
  • Şimşek, Savaş ve Taşçı, Alptekin (2004). "Örgütlerde "Güven" Konsepti Ve Emniyet Örgütü'nde Güven Modellerinin Değerlendirilmesi". Polis Dergisi, S:34
  • Tschannen-M., M.,Hoy, W. K. (1998).Trust İn Schools: A Conceptual And Empirical Analysis, Journal Of Educational Administration, 36, 4, s.334-352.
  • Tan, H.H. ve Tan,C.S.F.(2000). Toward The Differentiation Of Trust IN Supervisor And Trust İn Organization. Generic, Socialand General Psychology Monoghraph. 126.2
  • Urhan, B. (2005). Türkiye'de Sendikal Örgütlenmede Yaşanan Güven Ve Dayanışma Sorunları, Çalışma ve Toplu dergisi, 2005/1 57-88, www.calismatoplum.org/sayi4/makale2.pdf
  • Whitener, E.M.,Brodt, S.E., Korsgaard, M.A.Werner, J.M. (1998). Managers as initiators of trust: an exchange relationship frameworkfor understanding managerial trustworthy behavior, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 23, pp. 513-30.
  • Yorgun,S.(2005).Küreselleşme Sürecinde Türk Sendikacılığında Yeni Yönelişler Ve Alternatif Öneriler, Çalışma ve Toplum.s.137-162
  • Young, L. ve K. Daniel.(2003). "Affectualtrust in the workplace". Int. J. of Human Resource Management, 14:1, February, ss.139-155.
  • Yıldırım,N., Eriçok,B (2015). Okul Yöneticilerinin Duygusal Zekâ Ve Yönetsel Yeterlilik Düzeyleri Arasındaki İlişki: Nevşehir İli Örneği, International Periodical for the Languages, Literature and History of Turkish or Turkic Volume 10/11 Summer 2015, p. 567-592 DOI Number: http://dx.doi.org/10.7827/TurkishStudies.8461 ISSN: 1308-2140, ANKARA-TURKEY
  • Yılmaz, K. (2009). Özel Dershane Öğretmenlerinin Örgütsel Güven Düzeyleri İle Örgütsel Vatandaşlık Davranışları Arasındaki İlişki Kuram ve Uygulamada Eğitim Yönetimi, Cilt 15, Sayı 59, s: 471-490