AYŞE TAVUKÇUOĞLU, Kerime ÖRS, Arda DÜZGÜNEŞ, Şahinde DEMİRCİ

COMPATIBILITY ASSESSMENT OF EXTERIOR FINISH COATS FOR INSULATED WALLS

New approaches are emerging in contemporary wall construction as a result of improved understanding of building materials and their behaviour. Not so long ago, the accepted practice was to create impermeable exterior walls by using moisture-proof and vapour-proof layers in their sectional compositions. However, any failure, such as tiny cracks in any one of these impermeable layers, causes accumulation of entrapped moisture which could not escape by evaporation from the wall surface (Hughes, 1986; Massari and Massari, 1993; Richardson, 2001). This results in a decrease in the lifetime of building materials, visible defects on wall surfaces, such as discoloration, cracking, scaling and flaking on finish coats, and unhealthy interiors (Bochen et al., 2005). The concept of the "breathing wall", therefore, gained importance in the last few decades and external wall compositions, allowing the passage of water vapour back and forth through it, were started to be constructed. Along with this, energy efficient buildings and improvement of construction technology in this regard became a current issue in contemporary buildings. In addition to installing more efficient fuelburning equipment, the use of both thermal insulation layers and lightweight porous masonry blocks and/or panels for its walls proper, should be incorporated within the compositions of the building envelope. However, due to their high water absorption characteristics, light-weight porous masonry needs to be protected from rainwater by means of watertight protective coatings and/or by water repellents (Andolsun et al. 2006; Kuş, 2004). For these reasons, the exterior finishing systems consisting of under- and finish-coats, having low water permeability but high water vapour permeability properties are necessary. The matter which has not yet been foreseen, even overlooked, for multilayer constructions is "compatibility with neighbouring materials". The compatibility of finishing/complementing layers with the porous masonry, in fact, has vital importance for contributing to the long-term durability and thermal performance of masonry wall structures. However, the basic performance and compatibility properties of those layers, such as water vapour permeability, water impermeability, thermal resistance, dilatation, modulus of elasticity characteristics, are as yet not well known. Comprehensive studies are, therefore, needed to derive this information so that the performance expected of such systems in providing healthy interiors can be improved. Materials are considered to be compatible with each other if they have similar characteristics in terms of some physical, mechanical and compositional properties (Sasse and Snethlage, 1997; Fassina et al., 2002; Andolsun et al., 2005, 2006; Karoglou et al., 2007). The two important parameters of compatibility are water vapour permeability and modulus of elasticity (MoE):- o What is required of the finish coat is to permit water vapour transmission while resisting droplet penetration from rain or surface wash; in other words, being essentially watertight (Kuş, 2004; Harderup, 1996; Cerny, et al., 1996). It is also necessary to ensure continuity in this vapour transmission property throughout all the layers making up the wall section in order to avoid interstitial condensation. o The compatibility assessment of a layer with its neighbouring layers in terms of MoE is still under discussion. The MoE is defined as the ratio of stress to strain and indicates the deformation ability of a material under external forces (Timoshenko, 1970). According to studies discussing this subject, the MoE of coating layers should not exceed that of the underlying masonry (Caner, 2003; Fabbri and Grossi, 2000; Kovler and Frostig, 1998; Sasse and Sneathlage, 1997). This means that, any compatible layer should be expected to have MoE not higher than that of the base material which is in contact so as to prevent mechanical damage in any of the weaker intermediate layer(s). If not so done, failures-especially in the form of tiny cracks-are liable to develop on the fine coat and/or on sub-layers, which is often followed by flaking and scaling. Here, a number of proprietary exterior finish coats produced in Turkey were examined in order to determine their compatibility for insulated masonry walls with an emphasis on their water vapour permeability and modulus of elasticity characteristics (Örs, 2006) (1). It was expected to reveal not only their individual material properties, but also to develop awareness in architects, builders and manufacturers about the significance of compatibility in attaining an integrated building envelope.

PDF

___

AKKUZUGİL, E. (1997) A Study on Historical Plasters, Unpublished MSc Thesis, Department of Architecture, METU, Ankara.

AKYAZI, M. (1998) A Proposal for the Repair and Conservation of Haracoglu Konak in Bursa, Unpublished MSc. Thesis, Department of Architecture, METU, Ankara.

ANDOLSUN, S., TAVUKÇUOGLU, A., CANER-SALTIK, E.N. (2005) Evaluation of autoclaved aerated concrete (AAC) as a repair material for timber framed historical structures, Proceedings of Postgraduate Researchers of the Built and Natural Environment (PROBE), Glasgow, Scotland; 505-19.

ANDOLSUN, S., TAVUKÇUOGLU. A., CANER-SALTIK, E.N, DÜZGÜNEŞ, A. (2006) A study on the compatibility of contemporary neighbouring plasters with autoclaved aerated concrete (AAC), Proceedings of CIB PGRC 2006 on Built Environment and Information Technologies, eds., S. Andolsun, A. Temizsoy, M. Uçar, METU Faculty of Architecture Press, Ankara; 587-600.

ASTM D 2845-90, Standard Test Method for Laboratory Determination of Pulse Velocities and Ultrasonic Elastic Constants of Rock. (1990) The American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia.

ASTM E96-92, Water Vapour Transmission of Materials. (1992) The American Society for Testing and Materials; Philadelphia.

BOCHEN, J., GIL, S., SZWABOWSKI, J. (2005) Influence of Ageing Process on Porosity Changes of the External Plasters. Cement and Concrete Composites (27) 769-75.

CANER, E. (2003) Archaeometrical Investigation of Some Seljuk Plasters. Unpublished MSc Thesis, Department of Archaeometry, METU, Ankara.

CANER, E., AKOĞLU, G.K., CANER-SALTIK, E.N., DEMİRCİ, Ş., YAŞAR, T. (2006) Bazı Ortacağ çatı örtüsü sıvalarının hammadde özellikleri - Raw materials characteristics of Medieval plasters used for roof covering," Proceedings of the 21st International Symposium on Excavation, Research and Archeometry; Ministry of Culture and Tourism, Antalya, Turkey; 155-60.

CERNY, R., DRCHALOVA, J., HOSKOVA, S., TOMAN, J. (1996) Methods for evaluation of water-proofness quality and diffusion properties of coating materials. Construction and Building Materials 10(8) 547-52.

ÇOLAK, A. (2006) Physical and Mechanical Properties of Polymer-Plaster Composites, Materials Letters (60) 1977-1982.

DIN 52615, Determination of Water Vapour (Moisture) Permeability of Construction and Insulating Materials. (1987) Deutsches Institut für Normung, Berlin.

ESEN, S., TUNÇ, N., TELATAR, S., TAVUKÇUOĞLU, A., CANER-SALTIK, E.N., DEMİRCİ, S. (2004) Manisa Çukur Hamam'ın Onarımına Yönelik Malzeme Çalışmaları, Proceedings of 2nd National Congress and Exhibition on Building Materials, TMMOB Chamber of Architects - Istanbul Branch, İstanbul, Turkey; 494-505.

FABRI, B., GROSSI, A. (2000) On the use of Epoxy Resins as Filling Materials in Majolica Ware Restoration, Compatible Materials for the Protection of Cultural Heritage,eds., A. Moropoulou, G. Biscontin, R.J. Delgado, M. Erdik, I. Sintis, S. Zoppi, Technical Chamber of Greece; 37-43.

FASSINA, V., FAVARO, M., NACCARI, A., PIGO, M. (2002) Evaluation of Compatibility and Compatibility of a hydraulic lime-based plaster applied on brick wall masonry of historical buildings affected by rising damp phenomena. Journal of Cultural Heritage (3) 45-51.

HARDERUP, E. (1996) Estimation of Risk of High Moisture Conditions in an External Wall, Proceedings of the Durability of Building Materials and Components 7, vol.1, eds. C. Sjöström C., E & FN Spon, London; 160-9.

HELMS, H. (2006) Key terms in low-temperature insulation. Armacell - Technical Articles, Issue 4: Water vapour transmission, Armacell.

HUGHES, P. (1986) The Need For Old Buildings to "Breathe", SPAB News, Information Sheet 4. Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings, London.

Kaleterasit. www.kaleterasit.com.tr. Last accessed: May; 2012.

KAROGLOU, M., MOROPOULOU, A., KROKIDA, M.K., MAROULIS, Z.B. (2007) A powerful simulator for moisture transfer in buildings. Building and Environment (42) 902-12.

KOVLER K, FROSTIG Y. (1998) On the problem of cracking in plaster layers, Construction and Building Materials (12) 251-8.

KUS, H., NYGREN, K., NORBERG, P. (2004) In-use performance assessment of rendered autoclaved aerated concrete walls by longterm moisture monitoring. Building and Environment (39) 677-87.

MASSARI, G., MASSARI, M. (1993) Damp buildings, old and new. Rome: ICCROM.

ÖRS, K. (2006) An Investigation on Compatibility Properties of Exterior Finish Coats for Insulated Walls in Terms of Water Vapour Permeability and Modulus of Elasticity, Unpublished MSc Thesis, Graduate Program in Building Science, Department of Architecture, Middle East Technical University, Ankara, Turkey.

PFEIFER, G., RAMCKE, R., ACHTZIGER, J., ZILCH, K. (2001) Masonry Construction Manual. Birkhauser, Basel.

RICHARDSON, B.A. (2001) Defects and Deterioration in Buildings: A Practical Guide to the Science and Technology of Material Failure, Spon Press, New York.

RILEM (1980) Tentative Recommendations, in: Commission -- 25 - PEM, Recommended Test to Measure the Deterioration of Stone and to Assess the Effectiveness of Treatment Methods. Materials and Structures 13(73) 173-253.

SASSE, H.R., SNETHLAGE, R. (1997) Methods for the Evaluation of Stone Conservation Treatments., Proceedings of Saving our Architectural Heritage: The Conservation of Historic Stone Structures, eds. N.S. Baer, R. Snethlage, John Wiley and Sons, New York; 223-43.

TEUTONICO J.M. (1986) A Laboratory Manual for Architectural Conservators. ICCROM, Rome; 32-122.

TIMOSHENKO, S. (1970) Strength of Materials (Chapter 2), Analysis of Stress and Strain., Van Nostrand Reinhold Company, Holland.

TS 7847, Wall coating emulsions for exteriors-polymer based. (1990) Institute of Turkish Standards, Ankara

TS 825, Regulations for thermal insulation in buildings (2008) Institute of Turkish Standards, Ankara.

TS EN 1015-19, Methods of Tests for Mortar for Masonry-Part 19: Determination of Water Vapour Permeability of Hardened Rendering and Plastering Mortars (2000) Institute of Turkish Standards, Ankara.

TS EN 1015-2, Methods of test for Mortar for Masonry-Part 2: Bulk Sampling of Mortars and Preparation of Test Mortars (2000) Institute of Turkish Standards, Ankara.

TS prEN ISO 7783-2, Paints and Varnishes-Coating Materials and Coating Systems for Exterior Masonry-Part 2: Determination and Classification of Water-Vapour Transmission Rate (Permeability) (1999) Institute of Turkish Standards, Ankara.

TUNÇOKU, S.S., CANER-SALTIK, E.N. (2006) Opal-A rich additives used in ancient lime mortars. Cement and Concrete Research (36) 1886-93.

WILLIAMS M.F., WILLIAMS B.L. (1994) Exterior Insulation and Finish Systems: Current Practices and Future Considerations. The American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia.