Balon çerçeveyi yeniden kurmak : Arkitektonik tarihinde bir çalışma

Reconsatructing the balloon frame : A study in the history of architectionics

Bu yazıda birbirlerine yakın iki sav koşut olarak geliştirilmeye çalışılıyor. Birincisi, ahşap çatkı düzeninde, yoğunlukla kuzey Amerika’da yaygın olarak kullanılan “balon” çerçevenin ortaya çıkması kimi yazarların göstermeye çalıştıkları ya da savundukları gibi bir kişinin yoktan var ettiği bir yapı türü olamaz. Balon çerçevenin yaratıcısı olarak sözü edilen kişi(ler) katkıda bulunmuş olabilir, ancak bu biçimlendirme sürecini tek başlarına oluşturmadılar. Tek yaratıcı savını destekleyen belgeler ne yeterli ne de tutarlı. İkincisi, özellikle çatkı gibi çok değişik etmenlere bağımlı bir teknolojik etkinlik ve biçimlendirme sürecinin yaşadığı yeniliklerde kişisel başarılardan çok, zaman içinde gelişen süreklilik ve ortak katkılar söz konusu olabilir. Böylesine bir oluşum ancak uzun bir sürecin sonucunda, bir gelişmenin ürünü olarak ortaya çıkabilir.

___

  • ADDY, S.O. (1910, 1898) The Evolution of the English House, 3rd ed., Swan Sonnenschein, London.
  • ANDREAS, A.T. (1884) History of Chicago from the Earliest Period to the Present Time, A.T. Andreas, Chicago.
  • BALCOMBE, G. (1985) History of Building: Styles, Methods and Materials, Batsford Academic and Educational, London.
  • BARLEY, M. (1986) Houses and History, Faber and Faber, London.
  • BARLOW, P. (1837) A Treatise on The Strength of Timber and Cast Iron, Malleable Iron and Other Materials, 3rd ed., J. Weale, London.
  • BARNETT, H.G. (1953) Innovation: The Basis of Cultural Change, McGraw- Hill, New York.
  • BASALLA, G. (1988) The Evolution of Technology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
  • BENEDETTI, C. and V. BACIGALUPI (1991) Legno architettura: Il futuro della tradizione, Edizioni Kappa, Roma.
  • BENJAMIN, A. (1835, 1830) The Architect or Practical House Carpenter, 4th ed. B. B. Mussey, Boston.
  • BLASER, W. (1980) Wood houses: Form in rural architecture, Wepf and Co.,Basel.
  • BOLLES, A.S. (1881, 1878) Industrial history of the United States, 3rd ed. H. Bill Publishing Co., Norwich, CT.
  • BRUNSKILL, R.W. (1978, 1971) Illustrated handbook of vernacular architecture, 2nd ed. Faber and Faber, London.
  • BUCHANAN, P.E. (1976) The Eighteenth-century frame houses of Tidewater Virginia, in Building early America: Contributions toward the history of a great industry, ed. C.E. Peterson, Chilton Book Co., Radnor, PA; 54-73.
  • CARSON, C. et al. (1988) Impermanent architecture in the southern American colonies, in Material life in America, 1600-1860, ed. R.B. St. George, Northeastern University Press, Boston; 113-58.
  • CHARLES, F.W.B. (1967) Medieval cruck building and its derivatives (Society for Medieval Archaeology), Monograph Series No 2.
  • CHARLTON, T.M. (1982) A history of theory of structures in the nineteenth century, Cambridge U. P., Cambridge.
  • CHILDE, V.G. (1944) Archaeology in the U.S.S.R., The Anglo-Soviet Journal 5; 40-4.
  • CHILDE, V.G. (1949) Neolithic house-types in temperate Europe, Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society (110) 77-86.
  • COMITE INTERNATIONAL D’HISTORIE DE L’ART (1997) Holzbaukunst, Saur, Munchen.
  • CONDIT, C.W. (1957) Book Review: Engineering in History and History of American Technology, Isis, 48 (4) 484-7.
  • CONDIT, C.W. (1960) American building art: The nineteenth century, Oxford University Press, New York.
  • CORDINGLEY, R.A. (1961) British Historical Roof-Types and their Members: A Classification, Transactions of the Ancient Monuments Society NS 9: 73-129.
  • CROSSLEY, F.H. (1951), Timber Building in England: From Early Times to the End of the Seventeenth Century, Batsford, London.
  • DAVEY, N. (1961) A History of Building Materials, Phoenix House, London.
  • ELLIOTT, C.D. (1992) Technics and Architecture: The Development of Materials and Systems for Building, MIT, Cambridge, MA.
  • FAIRBAIRN, W. (1854) On the Application of Cast and Wrought Iron to Building Purposes, J. Wiley, New York.
  • FIELD, W. (1942) A Reexamination into the Invention of the Balloon Frame, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, v: 2, n: 4; 3-29.
  • FOLEY, M.M. (1980) The American house, Harper and Row, New York.
  • FRUTH, B. and G. HOHMANN (1996) Nest Building Behavior in the Great Apes: The Great Leap Forward?, in Great Ape Societies, eds. W. C. McGrew, L. F. Marchant and T. Nishida, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge; 225-40.
  • GIEDION, S. (1967, 1941) Space, Time and Architecture: The Growth of a New Tradition, 5th ed. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
  • GILFILLAN, S.C. (1970, 1935) The Sociology of Invention, MIT, Cambridge,MA.
  • GLASSIE, H. (1975) Folk Housing in Middle Virginia: Structural Analysis of Historic, University of Tennessee Press, Knoxville.
  • HABAKKUK, H.J. (1962) American and British Technology in the Nineteenth Century: The Search for Labour-Saving Inventions, Cambridge University Press, London.
  • HAMILTON, S.B. (1952) The Historical Development of Structural Theory, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, 1, Part III; 374-419.
  • HARRIS, R. (1979, 1977) Discovering Timber-Framed Buildings, 2nd ed., Shire Publications, Aylesbury.
  • HARRIS, R. (1989) The Grammar of Carpentry, Vernacular Architecture, 20;1-8.
  • HATFIELD, R.G. (1850, 1844) The American house-carpenter, 4th ed. Wiley and Halsted, New York.
  • HEWETT, C.A. (1969) The development of carpentry, 1200-1700: An Essex study, David and Charles, Newton Abbot.
  • HODGKINSON, E. (1824) On the transverse strain and strength of materials, Memoirs of the Literary and Philosophical Society of Manchester, 4, S; 2: 225-88.
  • HOTCHKISS, G.W. (1894) Industrial Chicago: The lumber interests, Goodspeed Publication Co., Chicago.
  • HUBKA, T. (1986) Just folks designing: Vernacular designers and the generation of form, in Common Places: Readings in American Vernacular Architecture, eds. D. Upton and J.M. Vlach, University of Georgia Press, Athens, GA; 426-32.
  • HUNTER, L.C. (1973) The heroic theory of invention, in Technology and Social Change in America, ed. E.T. Layton, Harper and Row, New York; 25-46.
  • Industrial Chicago: The Building Interests (1891) v: 2, Goodspeed Publishing, Chicago.
  • INNOCENT, C.F. (1971, 1916) Development of English building construction, David and Charles Reprints, Cambridge.
  • ISHAM, N.M. and A.F. BROWN, (1895) Early Rhode Island houses: An historical and architectural study Preston and Rounds, Providence, RI.
  • ISHAM, N.M. and A.F. BROWN, (1965, 1900) Early Connecticut houses: An historical and architectural study, Dover Publications, New York.
  • JACKSON, A.W. (1912) The half-timber house: Its origin, design, modern plan, and construction, McBride, Nast and Co., New York.
  • JENSEN, R. (1971) Board and batten siding and the balloon frame: Their incompatibility in the nineteenth century, Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, v: 30, n: 1; 40-50.
  • KNIFFEN, F.B. and H. GLASSIE, (1986) Building in wood in the eastern United States: A time-place perspective, in Common places: Readings in American vernacular architecture, eds. D. Upton and J.M. Vlach, University of Georgia Press, Athens, GA; 159-81.
  • MOSELEY, H. (1843) The mechanical principles of engineering and architecture, Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans, London.
  • MOXON, J. (1703, 1677) Mechanick exercises, or the doctrine of handy-works applied to the arts of smithing, joinery, carpentry, turning, bricklayery, 3rd ed., D. Midwinter and T. Leigh, London.
  • MULLER-BECK, H. (1972) Prehistoric Swiss lake dwellers, Old world archaeology: Foundations of civilization, (Readings from Scientific American), San Francisco; 226-32.
  • NELSON, L.H. (1968) Nail chronology, History News, v: 23, n:11, Technical leaflet 48; 203-213.
  • OLIVER, B. (1929) The Cottages of England: A review of their types and features from the 16th to the 18th centuries, Batsford Ltd., London.
  • PETERS, T.F. (1996) Building the Nineteenth Century, MIT, Cambridge, MA.
  • PIERCE, B.L. (1937) A History of Chicago, 3 vols, The beginning of a city-1673- 1848, v: 1, A. A. Knopf, New York.
  • POWELL, A.H. (1952, 1920) Country Building and Handicraft in Ancient Cottages and Farmhouses, Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings, London.
  • PRICE, F. (1759, 1733) The British Carpenter: Or, a treatise on carpentry, 4th ed., A. Palladio, J. Jones and C. Wren, London.
  • ROBINSON, S. (1846) A cheap farm-house, The American Agriculturist, 6;57-8.
  • ROBINSON, S. (1847) A cheap farm-house, The American Agriculturist, 7;216-8.
  • ROSENBERG, N. (1975) America’s rise to woodworking leadership, in America’s wooden age: Aspects of its early technology, ed. B. Hindle, Sleepy Hallow Restorations, Tarrytown, NY; 37-62.
  • ST. GEORGE, R.B. (1986) ‘Set thine house in order’: The domestication of the yeomanry in Seventeenth-century New England, in Common places: Readings in American vernacular architecture, eds. D. Upton and J.M. Vlach, University of Georgia Press, Athens, GA; 336-64.
  • SALZMAN, L.F. (1952) Building in England down to 1540, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  • SCHON, D. (1963) Invention and the evolution of ideas, Associated Book Publishers, London.
  • SMITH, J.T. (1965) Timber-framed building in England: Its development and regional differences, The Archaeological Journal 122; 133-58.
  • SMITH, J.T. (1970) The evolution of the English peasant house to the late seventeenth century: The evidence of buildings, The Journal of the British Archaeological Association 3rd Series 33: 122-47.
  • SMITH, J.T. (1992) English Houses 1200-1800: The Hertfordshire Evidence, HMSO, London.
  • SPRAGUE, P.E. (1983) Chicago Balloon Frame, in The Technology of Historic American Buildings: Studies of The Materials, Craft Processes, and The Mechanization of Building Construction, ed. H.W. Jandl, Foundation for Preservation Technology, Washington, DC; 35-62.
  • STEA, D. and M. TURAN, (1993) Placemaking: Production of built environment in two cultures, Avebury, Aldershot.
  • TREDGOLD, (1837, 1820) T. Elementary principles of carpentry, 2nd ed., E. L. Carey and A. Hart, Philadelphia.
  • UPTON, D. (1981) Traditional timber framing, in Material culture of the wooden age, ed. B. Hindle , Sleepy Hallow Press, Tarrytown, NY; 35-93.
  • USHER, A.P. (1962, 1929) A history of mechanical inventions, (Revised ed.), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
  • VAN OSDEL, J.M. (1883) History of Chicago architecture, The Inland Architect and Builder, v. 1, n. 2: 17; v. 1, n. 3: 36; v. 1, n. 4: 50; v.1, n.5:64; v. 1, n. 6: 78-80; v. 2, n. 1: 89.
  • WEST, T. (1971) The timber-frame house in England, Architectural Book Pub. Co., New York.
  • WESTERGAARD, H.M. (1930) “One hundred fifty years advance in structural analysis,” Transactions of the American Society of Civil Engineers (94) 226-46.
  • WHEELER, G. (1855) Homes for people in suburb and country, C. Scribner,New York.
  • WILLIAMS, T.I. (1987) The history of invention, Facts on File, New York.
  • WOODWARD, G.E. (1859-1861) Balloon frames, The Country Gentleman, (1859) v.14, n.20: 313-314; v.14, n.24: 387; (1860) v.15, n.14: 226; v.16,n.1: 18; v.16, n.8: 130; v.16, n.13: 210; v.16, n.17: 274; v.16, n.18: 290; v.16, n.17: 274; v.16, n.21: 338; v.16, n.23: 370; (1861) v.17, n.2: 35; v.17, n.6: 99; v.17, n.15: 242-243; v.17, n.23: 370.
  • WOODWARD, G.E. (1865) Country homes G. E. and F. W. Woodward, New York.
  • WOODWARD, G.E. (1867) Cottages and Farm Houses, G. E. Woodward and Co., New York.