Experiences of a journal club organized by students: A proposal for an evidence-based medicine format

To the editor,Journal clubs are defined as group discussions and criticalevaluations of articles. They can build the link between clinical practice and research data [1]. The three main objectives of a journal club are keeping up with the advances in the literature, learning and applying evidence-based medicine and discussing the clinical relevance of research data [2,3].There are significant data on postgraduate journal clubs, however, there is sparce information on undergraduate journal clubs. Two papers have focused on undergraduate journal clubs: one used the critique of articles as a method to teach anatomy [4] and the other used dialectical notes to increase student discussion and understanding of the literature of molecular biology [5].McDonough described undergradute journal clubs as “an excellent way to introduce students to primary literature, to develop their abilities in critical thinking and to practice interpreting experimental data” [5]. Since most of the published data were about postgraduate journal clubs, deriving a format for an undergraduate journal club poses a difficulty.A Student Scientific Research Club (SSRC) was founded in 2011, and has been an active journal club for 4 years at Marmara Medical School. After having four years of experience, in 2015, SSRC decided to have a meeting to discuss its own strong and weak points. A total of 24 people participated in the meeting.
Anahtar Kelimeler:

-

Experiences of a journal club organized by students: A proposal for an evidence-based medicine format

.Journal clubs are defined as group discussions and criticalevaluations of articles. They can build the link betweenclinical practice and research data [1]. The three mainobjectives of a journal club are keeping up with the advancesin the literature, learning and applying evidence-basedmedicine and discussing the clinical relevance of researchdata [2,3].There are significant data on postgraduate journal clubs,however, there is sparce information on undergraduatejournal clubs. Two papers have focused on undergraduatejournal clubs: one used the critique of articles as a methodto teach anatomy [4] and the other used dialectical notesto increase student discussion and understanding of theliterature of molecular biology [5].

___

  • McLeod P, Steinert Y, Boudreau D, Snell L, Wiseman J. Twelve tips for conducting a medical education journal club. Med Teach 2010;5:368-70. doi: 10.3109/01421590903513426
  • SVN Research Committee. Practical tips for starting a journal club. J Vasc Nurs 2009;1:18-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jvn.2008.12.002.
  • Linzer M. The journal club and medical education: over one hundred years of unrecorded history. Postgrad Med J 1987;740:475-8.
  • Havet E, Duparc F, Peltier J, Tobenas-Dujardin AC, Fréger P. The article critique as a problem based teaching methodfor medical students early in their training: a French example using anatomy. Surg Radiol Anat 2012;34:81-4. doi: 10.1007/s00276-011-0911-x.
  • McDonough V. Improving journal club: increasing student discussion and understanding of primary literature in molecular biology through the use of dialectical notes. Biochem Mol Biol Educ 2012;40:330-2. doi: 10.1002/bmb.20640.
  • Kallen AJ, Wilson CT, Russell MA, et al. Group writing of letters to the editor as the goal of journal club. JAMA 2006;9:1053-4.
Marmara Medical Journal-Cover
  • ISSN: 1019-1941
  • Yayın Aralığı: Yılda 3 Sayı
  • Başlangıç: 1988
  • Yayıncı: Marmara Üniversitesi
Sayıdaki Diğer Makaleler

Ankilozan spondilitli hastalarda komorbidite profilleri

Yeşim GARİP, Filiz ESER, Tuba GÜLER, Fulya DÖRTBAŞ, Ayşegül KILIÇARSLAN, HATİCE BODUR

Plazmada çok uzun zincirli yağ asidi düzeyleri normal olan bir X’e bağlı adrenolökodistrofi hastasında daha önce tanımlanmamış bir ABCD1 gen mutasyonu

Tanyel ZUBARİOGLU, Tanyel ZUBARIOGLU, Ertugrul KİYKİM, Mehmet CANSEVER, Mehmet Serif CANSEVER, Cigdem AKTUGLU ZEYBEK, Cigdem AKTUGLU ZEYBEK

Primer katastrofik antifosfolipid sendrom: 8 yaşında kız çocuk

Hatice Ezgi BARIŞ, Cisem LİMON AKSU, Irmak VURAL, EDA KEPENEKLİ KADAYİFCİ, Ahmet KOÇ, Ayça KIYKIM, Safa BARIŞ, Ahmet ÖZEN, Işıl BARLAN, Deniz YÜCELTEN, Özgür KASAPÇOPUR

Conservative management of a progressively growing rectus sheath hematoma presented in a patient with chronic renal failure: A case report

Ali BEKRAKI, Khalil HANNA, Mahmoud ABS

Bir çocukta hepatit A enfeksiyonuna ikincil gelişen hidropik safra kesesi

ABDULLAH BARIŞ AKCAN, Senem TUFAN DURSUN, Özgür DEMİRTAŞ, Zafer DÜZGÜN, Şiar DURSUN, MEDİHA AKCAN, Şevket Şenol AYHAN

Experiences of a journal club organized by students: A proposal for an evidence-based medicine format

Gökhan TAZEGÜL, Ozlem ALHAN, Çağrı KILIÇ, Mehmet GÜLPINAR

Ultrasound assessment of diaphragm thickness in COPD

Canan CİMŞİT, Melahat BEKİR, SAİT KARAKURT, Emel ERYÜKSEL

Molecular study of extended-spectrum beta-lactamase (TEM-1) gene in Escherichia Coli isolates collected from Ostad Alinasab Hospital in Tabriz Iran

Azizeh Shad DİZAJİ, Reza FATHI, Abolfazl Jafari SALES

Sıçanda stres ile uyarılan mide ülserinde simvastatin’in etkisi

Elif Bahadır, Elif BAHADIR, Muhammet Bulut, Beyza Kabayuka, Beyza KABAYUKA, Ece Söylem Şenkal, Abdullah Avlaç, Meral Yüksel, Feriha Ercan, İnci Alican, İnci ALİCAN

Tıp eğitiminde bir seçmeli program: İşitme Engelli Bireylerle İletişim ve Türk İşaret Dili

ÖZLEM MIDIK, FİGEN BAŞAR, Mehmet EMİRZEOĞLU, GAMZE ALAYLI, Gökhan SARISOY, Emre GÜNBEY, Murat YÜCE, ERDAL AĞAR