YAKLAŞTIRMALI NİSPİ TEMSİL SİSTEMLERİNİN BİR ÖRNEKLİ KARŞILAŞTIRMAYA DAYALI ANAYASAL ÇOĞULCULUK ANALİZİ

Bu çalışmada dünyada en yaygın olan yaklaştırmalı nispi temsil sistemlerinin altısı ele alınmıştır. Bu altı sistem, her birinde farklı sonuç verecek kurgusal bir oy dağılımına uygulanmış ve sayısal sonuçları üzerinden sistemler arasındaki farklılıklar tespit edilmiştir. Özellikle hangisinin daha çoğulcu hangisinin daha çoğunlukçu olduğu üzerinde durulmuştur.

Anahtar Kelimeler:

Nispi Temsil, D’Hondt, En Yüksek Artık, En Kuvvetli Ortalama, Çoğulculuk

CONSTITUTIONAL PLURALISTIC ANALYSIS OF APPROXIMATE PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATIONAL SYSTEMS BASED ON A SINGLE SAMPLE COMPARISON

In this study, six of the most common approximate proportional representation systems in the world are discussed. These six systems were applied to a fictional vote distribution that would give different results in each electoral system, and the differences between the electoral systems are determined based on their numerical results. In particular, it was emphasized which one is more pluralistic and which one is more majoritarian.

Keywords:

Proportional Representation, D, Highest Residual, Strongest Average, Pluralism,

PDF

___

Achen CH and Bartels LM, Democracy for Realists (Princeton University Press 2017).
Alkin S, 'Underrepresentative democracy: Why Turkey should abandon Europe's highest electoral threshold', (2011) Wash. U. Global Stud. L. Rev. 10 347, 369.
Badie B, 'Electoral Systems' iç. Bertrand Badie and others (edr), International Encyclopedia of Political Science (Sage Publications Inc. 2011) 749, 756.
Golder M, 'Democratic Electoral Systems Around the World, 1946–2000', (2005) 24 (1) Electoral Studies 103, 121.
Herron ES and others, 'Terminology and Basic Rules of Electoral Systems' iç Erik S. Herron and others (edr), The Oxford Handbook of Electoral Systems (OxfordUniversity Press 2018).
Lijphart A, 'Majority Rule Versus Democracy in Deeply Divided Societies', (1977) Politikon: South African Journal of Political Studies 4 (2), 113, 126.
McCulloch A, Power-Sharing and Political Stability in Deeply Divided Societies, (Routledge 2014).
Özbudun E, Türk Anayasa Hukuku, (8. bası, Yetkin Yayınları 2004).
Pactet P, Institutions Politique Droit constitutionel (16. Ed., Armand Colin/Masson 1997).
Potthoff RF, 'Is Hare (aka IRV and RCV) Better But Not Best?', (2023) 22 (1) Election Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy 1, 26.
Weinstock DM, 'Democracy and Disagreement', (1997) 91 (3) American Political Science Review 724, 725.