Joly LAURE, Soudani NAFİSSA, Schiffers BRUNO, Toumi KHAOULA, Abbes ABDELKERİM, Glida-Gnidez HABİBA

Pesticide Use in Market Gardening and Perceived Risk of Consumers Exposed to Pesticide Residues

Pesticides are commonly applied in market gardening to improve productivity and pest control. Pesticide residues could be persistent in vegetables and generate a potential health hazard for consumers. This study has been carried out in Tunisia to assess the perceived risk of consumers exposed to pesticide residues remaining in vegetables. Two surveys with different questionnaires were conducted among 30 market gardeners and 50 households located in the Djebeniana delegation (Sfax governorate, Tunisia) in order to analyze the phytosanitary practices of farmers on the one hand, and to better understand the attitude related to vegetable consumption and awareness on pesticide residues, on the other hand. The results revealed that various phytosanitary products have been used by market gardeners (43 commercial products containing 39 different active substances (AS)). Among these AS, abamectin and methomyl are considered as highly hazardous according the WHO classification. According to the behavior of pesticides in plants, more than half of the AS. (54%) are systemic and can be absorbed by the plant and moved around in its tissues. Furthermore, the majority of the surveyed farmers had never undergone agricultural training, which is a real handicap with respect to good phytosanitary practices. After applying pesticides, the pre-harvest interval was regularly not respected by almost half of the interviewed market gardeners. In addition, the study showed that all consumers washed their vegetables before consumption, but more than half of the respondents (54%) wash their vegetables for less than a minute (simply passing them under running water). In the light of these results, it appears that consumers may be exposed to pesticide residues from vegetables on the Tunisian market, with potential effects on their health.

PDF

___

Ahouangninou C, Boko S, Logbo J, Komlan F, Martin T, Fayomi B. 2019. Analyse des déterminants des pratiques phytosanitaires des producteurs maraîchers au sud du Bénin. Afrique SCIENCE, 15(5):252–265.
Anifandis G, Amiridis G, Dafopoulos K, Daponte A, Dovolou E, Gavriil E, Gorgogietas V, Kachpani E, Mamuris Z, Messini C, et al. 2017. The In Vitro Impact of the Herbicide Roundup on Human Sperm Motility and Sperm Mitochondria. Toxics, 6(1):2.
Bahrouni H. 2010. Caractérisation de l’efficacité technique des systèmes de pulvérisation et des pertes de pesticides appliqués aux cultures basses dans les régions méditerranéennes : cas de la Tunisie. Thèse de Doctorat. Montpellier SupAgro et INAT de l’université de Carthage, Tunisie. P122
Bonnechère A, Hanot V, Bragard C, Bedoret T, van Loco J. 2012b. Effect of household and industrial processing on the levels of pesticide residues and degradation products in melons. Food Additives and Contaminants: Part A, 29(7):1058–1066.
Bonnechere A, Hanot V, Jolie R, Hendrickx M, Bragard C, Bedoret T, Loco JV. 2012a. Processing Factors of Several Pesticides and Degradation Products in Carrots by Household and Industrial Processing. Journal of Food Research, 1(3):68.
Bonnechère A, Hanot V, Jolie R, Hendrickx M, Bragard C, Bedoret T, Van Loco J. 2012c. Effect of household and industrial processing on levels of five pesticide residues and two degradation products in spinach. Food Control, 25(1):397–406.
Brouwer M, Huss A, van der Mark M, Nijssen PCG, Mulleners WM, Sas AMG, van Laar T, de Snoo GR, Kromhout H, Vermeulen RCH. 2017. Environmental exposure to pesticides and the risk of Parkinson’s disease in the Netherlands. Environment International, 107:100–110.
Chavarri MJ, Herrera A, Arino A. 2005. The decrease in pesticides in fruit and vegetables during commercial processing. International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 40(2):205–211.
Chebbi H, Pellissier J, Khechimi W, Rolland J. 2019. Rapport de synthèse sur l’agriculture en Tunisie. CIHEAM-IAMM. Available from: https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal- 02137636. [Accessed 2021 Jun 20].
Chourasiya S, Khillare PS, Jyethi DS. 2015. Health risk assessment of organochlorine pesticide exposure through dietary intake of vegetables grown in the periurban sites of Delhi, India. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 22(8):5793–5806.
Chung SW. 2018. How effective are common household preparations on removing pesticide residues from fruit and vegetables? A review. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 98(8):2857–2870.
Claeys WL, Schmit J-F, Bragard C, Maghuin-Rogister G, Pussemier L, Schiffers B. 2011. Exposure of several Belgian consumer groups to pesticide residues through fresh fruit and vegetable consumption. Food Control, 22(3-4):508–516.
Darko G, Akoto O. 2008. Dietary intake of organophosphorus pesticide residues through vegetables from Kumasi, Ghana. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 46(12):3703–3706.
Elgueta S, Moyano S, Sepúlveda P, Quiroz C, Correa A. 2017. Pesticide residues in leafy vegetables and human health risk assessment in North Central agricultural areas of Chile. Food Additives and Contaminants: Part B: Surveillance Communications,10(2):105–112.
EU Pesticides database. 2021. European Union Pesticides database. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/food/ plant/pesticides/eu-pesticides[Accessed 2021 Dec 13]. European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). 2021. Overview of the MRL review progress under Article 12 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005. Available from : https://www.efsa.europa.eu/ sites/default/files/pesticides-MRL-review-progressreport. pdf
Farha W, Abd El-Aty AM, Rahman MdM, Jeong JH, Shin H-C, Wang J, Shin SS, Shim J-H. 2017. Analytical approach, dissipation pattern and risk assessment of pesticide residue in green leafy vegetables: A comprehensive review. Biomedical Chromatography, 32(1):e4134.
Fenoll J, Hellín P, Martínez CM, Flores P. 2007. Pesticide Residue Analysis of Vegetables by Gas Chromatography with Electron-Capture Detection. Journal of AOAC INTERNATIONAL, 90(1):263–270.
GIL (Groupement Interprofessionnel des Légumes). 2015. Filières légumes. Ministère de l’Agriculture, des Ressources Hydrauliques et de la Pêche. Tunisie.
Hendriadi A, Sulistiyorini S, Devilana MR. 2021. Pesticides Residues in Fresh Food of Plant Origin: Case Study in Indonesia. AGRIVITA Journal of Agricultural Science, 43(2).
Institut National de la Statistique(INS). 2014. Recensement Général de la Population et de l’Habitat. Recensement Général de la Population et de l’Habitat. Available from: http://ins.tn/sites/default/files/publication/pdf/RGPH%20201 4-V1_0.pdf. [Accessed 2021 Nov 22]
Institut National de la Statistique(INS). 2018. Enquête Nationale sur le Budget, la Consommation et le Niveau de vie des ménages 2015 : Volume B. Available from : http://ins.tn/sites/default/files/publication/pdf/consommation -2015%20V2.pdf. [Accessed 2021 Nov 22].
Jacobsen RE, Fantke P, Trapp S. 2015. Analysing half-lives for pesticide dissipation in plants. SAR and QSAR in Environmental Research, 26(4):325–342.
Kaushik G, Satya S, Naik SN. 2009. Food processing a tool to pesticide residue dissipation – A review. Food Research International, 42 (1):26–40.
Keikotlhaile B, Spanoghe P. 2011. Pesticide residues in fruits and vegetables. Pesticides—formulations, effects, fat, e:243–252.
Khaldi R, Dhehibi B, Rached Z, Dharaief M. 2009. La consommation de la pomme de terre et des légumes frais en Tunisie : un diagnostic contrasté et des effets prix et dépenses alimentaires différenciés par milieu d’habitat. New Medit., 8:14–22.
Kim B, Baek M-S, Lee Y, Paik JK, Chang M-I, Rhee G-S, Ko S. 2016. Estimation of Apple Intake for the Exposure Assessment of Residual Chemicals Using Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey Database. Clinical Nutrition Research, 5(2):96.
Krol WJ, Arsenault TL, Pylypiw, HM, Incorvia Mattina MJ. 2000. Reduction of Pesticide Residues on Produce by Rinsing. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 48(10):4666–4670.
Kumari D, John S. 2019. Health risk assessment of pesticide residues in fruits and vegetables from farms and markets of Western Indian Himalayan region. Chemosphere, 224:162– 167.
Lee MG, Jung D. 2009. Processing factors and removal ratios of select pesticides in hot pepper leaves by a successive process of washing, blanching, and drying. Food Science and Biotechnology, 18(5):1078–82.
Leili M, Pirmoghani A, Samadi MT, Shokoohi R, Roshanaei G, Poormohammadi A. 2016. Determination of pesticides residues in cucumbers grown in greenhouse and the effect of some procedures on their residues. Iranian journal of public health, 45(11):1481.
Lewis K, Tzilivakis J. 2017. Development of a Data Set of Pesticide Dissipation Rates in/on Various Plant Matrices for the Pesticide Properties Database (PPDB). Data, 2(3):28.
Li Y, Zhang C, Yin Y, Cui F, Cai J, Chen Z, Jin Y, Robson M, Li M, Ren Y, et al. 2014. Neurological Effects of Pesticide Use among Farmers in China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 11(4):3995–4006.
Łozowicka B, Kaczyński P, Mojsak P, Rusiłowska J, Beknazarova Z, Ilyasova G, Absatarova D. 2020. Systemic and non-systemic pesticides in apples from Kazakhstan and their impact on human health. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis, 90:103494.
Lu M-X, Jiang WW, Wang J-L, Jian Q, Shen Y, Liu X-J, Yu XY. 2014. Persistence and Dissipation of Chlorpyrifos in Brassica Chinensis, Lettuce, Celery, Asparagus Lettuce, Eggplant, and Pepper in a Greenhouse. Zhang Y, editor. PLoS ONE, 9(6):e100556.
Malhat F, Loutfy NM, Ahmed MT. 2016. Dissipation pattern and risk assessment of the synthetic pyrethroid Lambdacyhalothrin applied on tomatoes under dryland conditions, a case study. International Journal of Food Contamination, 3(1):1–7.
Mamane A, Baldi I, Tessier J-F, Raherison C, Bouvier G. 2015. Occupational exposure to pesticides and respiratory health. European Respiratory Review, 24(136):306–319.
Mehmood Y, Arshad M, Kaechele H, Mahmood N, Kong R. 2020. Pesticide residues, health risks, and vegetable farmers’ risk perceptions in Punjab, Pakistan. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal, 27(3):846–864.
Mostafalou S, Abdollahi M. 2013. Pesticides and human chronic diseases: Evidences, mechanisms, and perspectives. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology, 268(2):157–177.
Nougadère A, Sirot V, Kadar A, Fastier A, Truchot E, Vergnet C, Hommet F, Baylé J, Gros P, Leblanc J-C. 2012. Total diet study on pesticide residues in France: Levels in food as consumed and chronic dietary risk to consumers. Environment International, 45:135–150.
Ong KC, Cash JN, Zabik MJ, Siddiq M, Jones AL. 1996. Chlorine and ozone washes for pesticide removal from apples and processed apple sauce. Food Chemistry, 55(2):153–160.
Park DW, Kim KG, Choi EA, Kang GR, Kim TS, Yang YS, Moon SJ, Ha DR, Kim ES, Cho BS. 2016. Pesticide residues in leafy vegetables, stalk and stem vegetables from South Korea: a long-term study on safety and health risk assessment. Food Additives and Contaminants: Part A, 33(1):105–118.
PPDB - Pesticides Properties DataBase. 2021. Available from: http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/aeru/ppdb/. [Accessed 2021 Nov 22].
Pugliese P, Moltó JC, Damiani P, Marín R, Cossignani L, Mañes J. 2004. Gas chromatographic evaluation of pesticide residue contents in nectarines after non-toxic washing treatments. Journal of Chromatography A, 1050(2):185–191.
Ramadan MFA, Abdel-Hamid MMA, Altorgoman MMF, AlGaramah HA, Alawi MA, Shati AA, Shweeta HA, Awwad NS. 2020. Evaluation of Pesticide Residues in Vegetables from the Asir Region, Saudi Arabia. Molecules, 25(1):205. Ramezani MK, Shahriari D. 2014. Dissipation behaviour, processing factors and risk assessment for metalaxyl in greenhouse-grown cucumber. Pest Management Science, 71(4):579–583.
Rasmusssen RR, Poulsen ME, Hansen HCB. 2003. Distribution of multiple pesticide residues in apple segments after home processing. Food Additives and Contaminants, 20(11):1044–1063.
Rawn DFK, Quade SC, Sun W-F, Fouguet A, Bélanger A, Smith M. 2008. Captan residue reduction in apples as a result of rinsing and peeling. Food Chemistry, 109(4):790–796.
Ríos-González A, Jansen K, Javier Sánchez-Pérez H. 2013. Pesticide risk perceptions and the differences between farmers and extensionists: Towards a knowledge-in-context model. Environmental Research, 124:43–53.
Sabarwal A, Kumar K, Singh RP. 2018. Hazardous effects of chemical pesticides on human health-Cancer and other associated disorders. Environmental toxicology and pharmacology, 63:103–114.
Satpathy G, Tyagi YK, Gupta RK. 2012. Removal of Organophosphorus (OP) Pesticide Residues from Vegetables Using Washing Solutions and Boiling. Journal of Agricultural Science, 4(2):69–78.
Sinha SN, Rao MVV, Vasudev K. 2012. Distribution of pesticides in different commonly used vegetables from Hyderabad, India. Food Research International, 45(1):161– 169.
Son D, Somda I, Legreve A, Schiffers B. 2017. Pratiques phytosanitaires des producteurs de tomates du Burkina Faso et risques pour la santé et l’environnement. Cahiers Agricultures, 26(2):25005.
Soudani N, Belhamra M, Toumi K. 2020. Pesticide use and risk perceptions for human health and the environment: a case study of Algerian farmers. PONTE International Scientific Researches Journal, 76(5).
Thongprakaisang S, Thiantanawat A, Rangkadilok N, Suriyo T, Satayavivad J. 2013. Glyphosate induces human breast cancer cells growth via estrogen receptors. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 59:129–136.
Tomer V. 2013. Vegetable Processing At Household Level: Effective Tool Against Pesticide Residue Exposure. IOSR Journal of Environmental Science, Toxicology And Food Technology, 6(2):43–53.
Toumi K, Joly L, Tarchoun N, Souabni L, Bouaziz M, Vleminckx C, Schiffers B. 2018. Risk assessment of Tunisian consumers and farm workers exposed to residues after pesticide application in chili peppers and tomatoes. Tunisian Journal of Plant Protection, 13(1):127–143.
Toumi K, Joly L, Vleminckx C, Schiffers B. 2019a. Exposure of workers to pesticide residues during re-entry activities: A review. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal, 25(8):2193–2215.
Upadhayay J, Rana M, Juyal V, Bisht S, Joshi R. 2020. Impact of Pesticide Exposure and Associated Health Effects. Pesticides in Crop Production : Physiological and Biochemical Action : 69–88.
Naré WA R, Savadogo P, Gnankambary Z, Nacro H, Sedogo M. 2015. Analyzing Risks Related to the Use of Pesticides in Vegetable Gardens in Burkina Faso. Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, 4(4):165–172.
Yang T, Doherty J, Zhao B, Kinchla AJ, Clark JM, He L. 2017. Effectiveness of Commercial and Homemade Washing Agents in Removing Pesticide Residues on and in Apples. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 65(44):9744– 9752.
Zohair A. 2001. Behaviour of some organophosphorus and organochlorine pesticides in potatoes during soaking in different solutions. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 39(7):751–755.