Irak ve Suriye krizlerinin karşılaştırmalı analizi: Nedenler, gelişmeler, sonuçlar ve Türkiye üzerine etkileri

Irak ve Suriye’de yaşanan olayların nedenleri ve gelişimi birbirinden oldukça farklıdır. Ancak her iki ülkedeki gelişmeler Türkiye’nin güvenliğini doğrudan etkilemesi yönü ile benzerlikler taşımaktadır. Irak’ta yirmi yıldır ve Suriye’de yaklaşık iki yıldır yaşanan gelişmeler Türkiye’nin yaşamsal çıkarlarını doğrudan etkilemektedir. Bu nedenle ABD’nin Birinci ve İkinci Irak Harekâtı ile Arap Baharı kapsamında Suriye’de cereyan eden olayların Türkiye’nin çıkarları açısından karşılaştırmalı bir analizi yapılacaktır. Bu analiz; olguların ortaya çıkış süreci, gelişmelere katkıda bulunan iç ve dış faktörler, Türkiye’nin bölgedeki gelişmelerden etkilenme biçimi şeklinde olacaktır.

A comparative analysis of the Iraq and Syria crisis: Causes, developments, results and the effects on Turkey

The causes and development of events occurred in Iraq and Syria, are quite different from each other. However, the progresses in both countries are similar in aspect of affecting Turkey’s security. The developments in Iraq for twenty years and for nearly two years in Syria have a direct impact on Turkey's vital interests. For this reason, a comparative analysis of the United States’ first and second Operations in Iraq and the events that took place in Syria in context of Arab Spring will be conducted in terms of the Turkey's interests. This analysis includes the process of emergence of cases, internal and external factors that contribute to the developments, and the way of Turkey’s beıng affected by the developments in the region.

PDF

___

ALTUNIŞIK Meliha; “Arap Dünyasında Neler Oluyor?” ODTÜLÜ Dergisi Sayı 47, 2011, s Dergisi, 92-97.
ANDERSON James H., “After the Fall: What’s Next for Assad and Syria?”, World Affairs 1 Affairs, Nov 20011, pp.16-22.
ARI Tayyar Uluslararası İlişkiler ve Dış Politika Alfa Yayınları, İstanbul 2004. Politika,
AYOOB Mohammed, “The Arab Spring: Its Geostrategic Significance”, Middle East Policy Policy, Vol. 19, No. 3, Fall 2012.
BIGGAR Nigel, “The Invasion of Iraq: What Are the Morals of the Story?” International Interna Affairs, Affairs Vol.87, No.1, 2011, pp.29–37.
BISHKU Michael B., “Turkish-Syrian Relations:A Checkered History”, Middle East Policy Policy, Vol. 19, No. 3, Fall 2012, pp.36-53.
BOZTEMUR Recep, “Orta Doğu Devrimlerinin Değişen Doğası”, ODTÜLÜ Dergisi Sayı 47, Dergisi, 2011, ss. 97-103.
BRZEZINSKI Zbigniew, İkinci Şans Çev. Yelda Türedi, İnkılap Yayınevi, İstanbul, 2008. Şans,
CEBECI Erol and ÜSTÜN, Kadir, “The Syrian Quagmire: What’s Holding Turkey Back?”, Insight Turkey, Vol. 14, No.2, 2012, pp. 13-21.
CORDESMAN Anthony H. ve diğerleri “Arab Uprisings and U.S. Policy: What Is the American National Interest?”, Middle East Policy Vol.17, No.2, Summer 2011, pp. 1- Policy, 28.
-----, “American Strategic, Tactic, and Other Mistakes in Iraq: A litany of Errors”, Center for Studies, Strategic and International Studies 19 Eylül 2006.
-----, “How Soon Is Safe? Iraqi Forces Development and Condition-Based US Withdrawal” Rapor, Center for Strategic& International Studies 11 Sep 2008. Studies,
ÇAĞRI Erhan, “Broader Middle East and North Africa Initiative and Beyond”, Perceptions Perceptions, Autumn 2005, pp.153-170.
ÇAKMAK Haydar, “Devrilen Diktatörler ve Kutsal İktidar”, Yeni Çağ Gazetesi, 21 Mart Gazetesi 2011.
ERTUĞRUL Ümit, Irak Türkleri ve Türkiye Kerkük Vakfı, İstanbul 2006. Türkiye,
FELDMAN Noah, What We Owe Iraq: War and the Ethics of Nation Building, Princeton University Press, 2004.
GALBRAITH Peter W., “The Mess,” New York Review of Books Cilt. 53, Sayı 4, March 9, Books, 2006.
-----, Irak’ın Sonu Ulus Devletlerin Sonu mu ?, Çev: Mehmet Murat İnceyan, Doğan Kitap, İstanbul 2007.
GITLIN Todd, “Do Less Harm, The Lesser Evil of Non-Intervention”, World Affair Summer Affair, 2008, pp.35-47
GORDON Michael R. and TRAINOR Bernard E., Kobra II: The Inside Story of the Invasion and Occupation of Iraq. New York, Knopf, 2006.
HAZRAN Yusri, “The Arab Revolutions: A Preliminary Reading”, Middle East Policy Vol. Policy, 19, No. 3, Fall 2012. Century,
HUNTINGTON Samuel, The Third Wave Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century University of Oklahoma Press, 1992.
ISMAIL Salwa, “The Syrian Uprising: Imagining and Performing the Nation”, Studies in Stud Ethnicity and Nationalism: Vol. 11, No. 3, 2011, pp.538-549.
-----, “Changing Social Structure, Shifting Alliances and Authoritarianism in Syria”, in: Fred Lawson (ed.), Demystifying Syria London: Saqi Press, 2009, p. 13-28. Syria,
KESLER Glenn, “Fix This Middle Eastern Mess”, The Washington Quarterly Autumn 2008, Quarterly, pp. 135–142.
KHALIDI Rashid, “Iraq and American Empire”, New Political Science Volume 28, Number Science, 1, March 2006, pp, 125-134
KHLAIFAT Riyad and BASHAYREH Ali, “ European , “Consequences of US Intervention”, European Journal of Social Sciences, Volume 16, Number 3, 2010, pp. 327-338.
KREPINEVICH Jr. Andrew F., “How to Win in Iraq”, Foreign Affair, Eylül/Ekim 2005.
LESCH David W., “The Evolution of Bashar al-Asad”, Middle East Policy, Vol. 17, No. 2, al- The Summer 2010, pp.70-81.
LISA Anderson, “Demystifying the Arab Spring”. Foreign Affairs, May/Jun 2011, Vol. 90, Affairs No. 3.
MURRAY Williamson ve Scales Robert H., Iraq War: A Military History, United States 2003.
ÖNIŞ Ziya, “Turkey and the Arab Spring:Between Ethics and Self-Interest”, Insight Turkey Turkey, Vol.14, No.3, 2012, pp. 45-63.
ÖZDAĞ Ümit, Telafer; Bir Türkmen Kentinin ABD Ordusu ve Pemergelere Karşı Direnişi Direnişi, Fark Yayınevi, Ankara 2008.
PACKER George, The Assassins’ Gate: America in Iraq. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2005.
PILLAR Paul R., “Intelligence, Policy, and the War in Iraq,” Foreign Affairs, March/April Affairs 2006.
POLK William R., Irak’ı Anlamak Çeviri, NTV yayınları, 1.Baskı, Şubat 2007. Anlamak,
RENDA Kadri Kaan, “Turkey’s Neighborhood Policy: An Emerging Complex Interdependence,” Insight Turkey Vol. 13, No. 1, 2011, pp. 89-108. Turkey,
RICKS Thomas E., Fiyasko; Amerika’nın Irak’taki Askeri Serüveni, Çev., Deniz Başkaya, Doğan Kitap, Istanbul, 2008.
HEYDARIAN Richard Javad, “Arab Spring, Turkish Summer?,” Foreign Policy in Focus 16 Focus, May 2011, http://www.fpif.org/articles/arab_spring_turkish_summer, (ET:12.11. 2012)
SANDERS Ben and SMITH, Merrill, “The Iraqi Refugee Disaster”, World Policy Journal Fall Journal, 2007, pp.23-28.
SCHWARTZ Michael; “Why Immediate Withdrawal Makes Sense”, Nation Institute 22 Nation Institute, September 2005.
SHARP Jeremy M., The Broader Middle East and North Africa Initiative: An Overview, CRS Report for Congress, February 15, 2005, CRS Web, p.2.
STEEL Ronald, “An Iraq Syndrome?”, Survival Vol. 49, No. 1, Spring 2007, ss. 153–162. Survival,
TARAS Ray, “The (Il)Logic of Intervention in Iraq: Sectarianism, Civil War, and the U.S. Game Plan”, International Journal on World Peace Vol. 23, No. 4, December 2006, Peace, pp.33-60.
TELHAMI Shibley, “Egypt,Tunisia and Iran” Digest of Middle East Studies, Vol. 20, No.1-3, Studies Spring 2011.
ULUĞBAY Hikmet, İmparatorluktan Cumhuriyete Petroplitik, Aytaç Yayınevi, Ankara, 2003,
ZAKARIA Fareed, “The Future of American Power; How America Can Survive, the Rise of the Rest”, Foreign Affairs May/June 2008.
Raporlar
Baker-Hamilton Raporu; http://www.usip.org usip.org/isg/iraq_study_group_report/report/1206/ usip.org index.html, (ET: 5.5.2009).
International Crisis Group; Failed Responsibility: Iraqi Refugees in Syria, Jordan and Lebanon, Middle East Report, N°77, 10 July 2008.
International Crisis Group; Iraq after the Surge I: The New Sunni Landscape, Middle East Report N°74, 30 April 2008.
International Crisis Group; Oil for Soil: Toward a Grand Bargain on Iraq and the Kurds, Middle East Report N°80, 28 October 2008.
International Crisis Group; Iraq’s Civil War, the Sadrists and the Surge, Middle East Report N°72, 7 February 2008.
International Crisis Group; Turkey and Iraqi Kurds: Conflict or Cooperation?, Middle East Report N°81, 13 November 2008.
SÖNMEZ Köksal, “Irak’ın Kuzeyindeki Muhtemel Gelişmelerin Türkiye’ye Etkileri”, BİLGESAM Rapor No.6. Tarih Makas Değiştirirken Kuzey Afrika ve Ortadoğu’da Değişim Arzusu, USAK, 2011. USAK
ORSAM, Suriye’de Değişimin Ortaya Çıkardığı Toplum: Suriye Türkmenleri Ortadoğu Türkmenleri, Türkmenleri Araştırmaları Merkezi, Rapor No: 14 Kasım 2011.
Elektronik Kaynaklar
CATHERINE Lutz, “US and Coalition Casualties in Iraq and Afghanistan”, Watson Institute, Brown University, http://costsofwar.org costsofwar.org/sites/default/files/articles/10/attachments/ costsofwar.org Lutz%20US%20and%20Coalition%20Casualties.pdf, (ET:17.9. 2012).
ERKMEN Serhat “İşgalin Beşinci Yılında Irak’ta Temel Gelişmeler”, serkmen@asam.org.tr, İşgalin Gelişmeler (ET:17.9. 2012).
EROLOĞLU Abbas, “Arap Baharına Farklı Bakış”, http//www.bilgesam.org bilgesam.org.tr, (ET:15 bilgesam.org 6.2011).
EROL Mehmet Seyfi, “ “Derin Mekanizmalar, Çirkin Tezgahlar, Değişmeyen Oyun”, http:// usgam.com/tr/index.php?l=844&cid=1264&bolge=14, (ET:17.9.2012).
www.usgam.com usgam.com
http://www.washingtonpost washingtonpost.com/wp- washingtonpost dyn/content/article/2008/03/07/AR2008030702846.html, (ET: 19.11.2012).
ÖZEV Muharrem Hilmi, “Ortadoğu’daki Dönüşümün Tarihi Süreçteki Yeri ve Anlamı”, http://www.tasamafrika.org tasamafrika.org/tr/haberler/388-ortadoudaki-doenueuemuen-tarihi- tasamafrika.org suerecteki-yeri-ve-anlam-.html, (ET:16.6.2011).
SALT Jeremy, “Turkey’s Syrian Misadventure”, http://www.globalresearch globalresearch.ca/turkeys- globalresearch syrian-misadventure/, (ET:16.9. 2012).
The Iraqi Displacement Crisis, 3 Mart 2008, http://www.refugeesinternational refugeesinternational.org/ refugeesinternational content/article/detail/9679, (ET:10.5.2009).
TURAN Kürşad, “Tersine Dönmüş İki Seviyeli Bir Oyun Olarak Suriye Krizi” http:// www.orsam orsam.org.tr/tr/yazigoster.aspx?ID=3884, (ET:14.9.2012).