Circassian colonization in the danube Vilayet and social integration (preliminary notes)

1829’da sonuçlanan Edirne Anlaşması, Anapa’dan Poti’ye kadar olan kıyı kesimini ve Kuban vadisi ile Ahıska ve Ahılkelek bölgesi arasında kalan toprağı Rus hâkimiyetine vermekteydi. Sultanla yeni askeri çatışmalar bekleyen Rusya, Osmanlılarla Çerkezler arasındaki muhtemel işbirliğini önlemeye çalışmaktaydı. Rus ticaretinin, şehirlerinin ve karantina limanlarının güvenliğini sağlamak amacıyla Rus yetkililer, Çerkezlerin Rusya’nın iç bölgelerine yerleştirilmesini önermekteydi. Ancak, özel bir iskân komisyonu tarafından hazırlanan ilk gider hesapları böylesine büyük bir yer değiştirmenin imkânsız olduğunu açığa vurmaktaydı. Rusya’nın Kuzey Kafkasya’yı zaptetmesinin oldukça şüpheli olacağının bilinciyle, Prens Baryatinsky, Çerkezlerin Osmanlı Đmparatorluğu’na göçünü Rus itibarını daha az zedeleyici ve uzun yıllar süren çatışmayı kesin şekilde çözecek alternatif bir yol olarak addetmekteydi. Bu nedenle, 1858’in sonbaharından sonraki 16 yıl, göç, her iki taraf için de tek mantıklı tutumu oluşturmaktaydı. Bu çalışma, Tuna vilayetindeki Çerkes kolonileşmesinin, ekonomik bütünleşmesinin ve sosyalleşmesinin uzun sürecini ana hatlarıyla anlatmaktadır. Bu çalışmada devlet nizamnameleri, gazete notları, vergi kayıtları ile yerel ve merkezi düzeydeki Osmanlı idari birimlerinin yazışmaları gibi arşiv belgelerinden yararlanılmıştır. Bu çalışma, daha büyük bir insanlık krizini önlemeye ya da sınırlamaya yönelik Osmanlı çabaları vurgulanmaktadır. Bu çabalar, Sultanın tüm tebaası ve sonrasında, zaten daha önce kolonileştirilmiş olan Kırımlı göçmenler tarafından ayni ve nakdi olarak sağlanan ücretsiz yardımları içermektedir. Çalışma, kolonizasyon sürecine, Çerkezlerin değişen maddi statüsüne, tarımsal aktivitelerine ve eğitimine dikkat çekmektedir. Makale, Çerkezlerin yeni çevreye uyum sürecinin Osmanlı’nın aşırı bütçe harcamalarını önleme, vergi geliri paylarını idareli harcama ya da yapılmış olan yardımı çabucak telafi etmeye yönelik girişimleri nedeniyle yavaşladığı tezini ortaya atmaktadır.

Tuna Vilayeti’ndeki çerkes kolonizasyonu ve sosyal bütünleşme (başlangıç notları)

The Treaty of Edirne, concluded in 1829, placed in Russia’s hand the coastal area from Anapa to Poti, and the land between the Kuban valley and the region of Akhaltsikhе and Akhalkalaki. Expecting new military conflicts with the Sultan, Russia acted to preclude the eventual alliance between the Ottomans and the Circassians. In order to ensure the safety of the Russian trade, towns and quarantine ports, the Russian officials proposed the resettlement of the Circassians inside the Russian territory. However, the preliminary expenditure accounts prepared by a special Resettlement commission evinced as impossible the mass relocation. Conscious of the Russia’s highly contestable attempts to conquer the Northwest Caucasus, Prince Baryatinsky regarded the Circassian migration into the Ottoman Empire as an alternative less devastating for the Russian reputation and as a final solution to the year-long conflict. So, for the next 16 years, beginning in the autumn of 1858 onwards, the migration constituted the only reasonable attitude for both parties. My paper outlines the longer process of the Circassian colonization, economic integration and socialization in the Danube vilayet. It draws on archival sources such as state regulations, newspaper notes, tax registers and examples of the correspondence between the local, vilayet and central Ottoman government. The paper emphasizes the Ottoman efforts to avoid or to limit a mass humanitarian crisis, the free aid, in cash and kind, extended by all Sultan’s subjects and later by the already colonized Crimean refugees. It pays attention to the colonization process, the varying material status of the Circassians, their agricultural activity and education. It launches the suggestion that the Circassians’ adaptation to the new environment was slowed down by the Ottoman attempts to prevent excess budgetary expenditure, to economize a share of their tax revenues or quickly to recompense the offered state aid.

___

BLIEV, Mark, Cherkesiya i Cherkesy XIX veka. Kratkiy ocherk istorii [Circassia and Circassians in 19th Century. A Comprehensive History], Moscow 2011.

BOBROVNĐKOV, Vladimir, “Rossiyskie musulmany posle archivny revolyutzii: vzglyad s Kavkaza i iz Bolgarii” [Russian Muslims: Some notes on the Archives and Primary Sources in Caucasus and Bulgaria after 1989-1991], Ab Imperio, 4 (2008).

CHOCHĐEV, Georgi , “Some Aspects of Social Adaptation of the North Caucasian Immigrants in the Ottoman Empire in the Second Half of the XIXth Century”, downloaded from the web site: www.aheku.org/datas/users/1- g_chochiev_immigrants_applications.pdf.

CHOCHIEV, Georgi-Bekir Koç, “Some Notes on the Settlement of Northern Caucasians in Eastern Anatolia and Their Adaptation Problems (the Second Half of the XIXth Century – the Beginning of the XXth Century)”, Journal of Asian History, 40 (2006), 1.

DOREV, Pancho, Dokumenti za balgarskata istoriya [Archival Sources about Bulgarian History], vol. 3, Sofia 1940.

DRAGANOVA, Slavka, Bekovskoto selo v navecherieto na Osvobojdenieto (statistichesko izsledvane spored osmanski danachni registri) [The Villages in the kaza of Berkofča on the eve of Russo-Ottoman War of 1877/78 in the light of Ottoman tax registers], Sofia 1985.

DRAGANOVA, Slavka, Kolichestven analiz na ovcevadstvoto v balgarskite zemi pod osmanska vlast ot sredata na XIX vek do Osvobojdenieto [Sheep Breeding in the Danube Vilayet, 1860s-1870s], Sofia 1993.

EPIFANTZEV, Andrey, “Prichiny porajeniya adygov v Kavkazkoy voyne” [On the Reasons for the Circassians’ defeat in the Caucasian War], downloaded from the web site: www.apn.ru/publications/article21543.html.

EPIFANTZEV, Andrey, Kavkazskaya voyna, Genotzid, kotorogo ne bylo, Chast 4: Legendy i mify Kavkazskoy voyny [The Caucasian War and the Claims about Genocide. Part 4: Myths about the Caucasian War], downloaded from the web site: www.apn.ru/publications/article 22049.html.

FISHER, Alan, The Crimean Tatar, Hoover Press Publication, 1978.

HENZE, Paul, “Circassian Resistance to Russia”, The North Caucasus Barrier, Ed.: M. Benningen Broxup, London 1996.

HEYWOOD, C. J., “Medjidiyye”, Encyclopedia of Islam, , vol. 6, Leiden-Brill 2003.

IKONOMOV, Todor, Protokoli na Berlinskiya kongres [Protocols of the Congress of Berlin], Sofia 1885.

ISLA-OWEN, Sarah, The First “Circassian Exodus” to the Ottoman Empire (1858- 1867), and the Ottoman Response, Based on the Accounts of Contemporary British Observers, MA Near and Middle Studies, SOAS, London, 2007, downloaded from the web site: www.circassianworld.com/new/history/war- and-exile/1134-the-first-circassian-exodus.html.

KARPAT, Kemal, “Ottoman Urbanism: The Crimean Emigration to Dobruca and the Founding of Mecidiye, 1856-1878”, Studies on Ottoman Social and Political History, Selected Articles and Essays, Leiden-Brill 2002.

KARPAT, Kemal, “The Status of the Muslims under European Rule: The Eviction and Settlement of the Çerkes”, Studies on Ottoman Social and Political History, Selected Articles and Essays, Leiden-Brill 2002.

KING, Charles, The Ghost of Freedom: A History of the Caucasus, Oxford 2008.

KINYAPINA, Nina,-Mark Bliev, Vladimir Degoev, Kavkaz i Srednaya Aziya vo vneshney politike Rossii. Vtoraya polovina XVIII-80-e gody XIX v. [Russian Inner Affairs, Caucasus and Central Asia from the Second Half of 18th Century to 1880s], Moscow 1984.

KOLARZ, Walter, Russia and her Colonies, North Haven, 1967.

LACHEV, Mitko-Margarita Dobreva, “Uchebnoto delo v grad Lom i Lomsko prez 1874/1875 uchebna godina (spored neizvesten osmanski dokument)” [The schooling in the town of Lom and the kaza of Lom during 1874/1875 school year (in the light of an unpublished Ottoman source)], Studia in Honorem Professoris Verae Mutafčieva, Eds. E. Radušev, Z. Kostova, Sofia 2001.

LIVI, Massimo-Bacci, Population and Nutration. An essay on European demographic History, Cambridge 2008. Mehmed Süreyya, Sicill-i Osmani, C. 4, Istanbul 1996.

MĐTKOV, Todor-Georgi Telkiev, Tzarevictza. Rakovodstvo za krajochnicite po rastenievadstvo [Maize. A Manual for farmers], Sofia 1961.

MUCHĐNOV, Ventzislav, Migratzionna politika na Osmanskata imperiya v balgarskite zemi prez XIX vek (do 1878) [19th-century Ottoman Migration policy and the Bulgarian lands (until 1878)], Sofia 2013.

OVSYANYY, Nikolay, Sbornik materialov po grajdanskomu upravleniju i okkupatzii v Bolgarii v 1877-78-79 g.g., Vypusk 5 [Sources about the Russian Civil Government and Armed Control of Bulgaria in 1877-1879, Part 5], St. Peterburg 1906.

PARVEVA, Stefka, “Agrarian Land and Harvest in South-West Peloponnese in the Early 18th Century”, Village, Town and People in the Ottoman Balkans 16th – 19th Century, Istanbul 2009.

PENCHEV, Pencho-Hristo Krinchev, Elementarni i optimalni potrebnosti ot sredstva za hranitelni produkti [Minimal and optimal nutrition and its cash equivalent], Varna 1968.

PINSON, Marc, “Ottoman Colonization of the Circassians in Rumeli after the Crimean War”, Etudes Balkaniques, 8 (1972), 3.

RADUSHEV, Evgeni, Hristiyanstvo i islyam v Zapadnite Rodopi s dolinata na reka Mesta, XV – 30-te godini na XVIII vek, Chast 1 [Christianity and Islam in the Western Rhodope Mountain and the valley of Mesta river from 15th Century to 1730s Part 1], Sofia 2005.

ROGEN, Eugene, Frontiers of the State in the Late Ottoman Empire, Transjordan, 1850-1921, Cambridge 1999.

RONZIO, Robert, The Encyclopedia of Nutrition and Good Health, New York 2003.

ŞAŞMAZ, Musa, “Immigration and Settlement of Circassians in the Ottoman Empire on British Documents 1857-1864”, Ankara Üniversitesi Osmanlı Tarihi Araştırma ve Uygulama Merkezi Dergisi, sayı 9, Ankara 1998.

SAYDAM, Abdullah, Kırım ve Kafkas Göçleri (1856-1876), Ankara 1997.

SOMEL, Selçuk Akşin, The Modernization of Public Education in the Ottoman Empire 1839-1908, Leiden-Brill 2001.

VOLKOVA, Nataliya, Etnicheskiy sostav naseleniya Severnogo Kavkaza v XVIII – nachale XX veka [Ethnic variety in the Northwest Caucasus from 18th Century to the beginning of 20th Century], Moscow, 1974.

YILDIZ, Berat, Emigrations from the Russian Empire to the Ottoman Empire: An Analysis in the Light of the New Archival Materials, MA at the Department of International Relations Bilkent University, Ankara 2006.