Dini ve Mistik Tecrübelerin Güvenilirliği Açısından Analojiler: Duyu Tecrübesi Analojisinden Duygu Tecrübesi Analojisine Geçiş
Dini ve mistik tecrübelerin güvenilirliği ve geçerliliği söz konusu ol-- duğunda duyu tecrübesi analojisi olumlu ya da olumsuz perspektifle önce-- likli olarak ele alınmaktadır. Bununla birlikte duyu verileri dini ve mistik tecrübelerin gerçekliğine tamamen nüfuz etmekte yetersiz kalmaktadır. Bu nedenle duyusal ilişkinin yanı sıra duygusal ilişkinin de temsil edilmesi önem arz etmektedir. Bu makalede duyu tecrübesi analojisine ek olarak duygu tecrübesi analojisi önerilmiştir. Duyu tecrübesi analojisi algı, ittifak ve evrensellik temalarıyla, duygu tecrübesi analojisi ise duygu, ittifak ve ortaklık temalarıyla ele alınmıştır. Netice olarak her iki analojinin birlikte işlevselliği farkındalık modeliyle desteklenmiştir.
Analogies in relation to the Reliability of Religious and Mystical Experiences: Transition from the Analogy of Sense Experience to the Analogy of Emotion Experience
When the reliability and the validity of religious and mystical experi— ences are discussed, the analogy of sense experience is considered on preferential basis with positive and negative perspectives. However sense data is inadequate to understand the real meaning of religious and mystical experiences. Therefore it is necessary to represent emotional relation as well as sensual relation. In this article the analogy of emotion experience is proposed in addition to the analogy of sense experience. The analogy of sense experience is dealt with the theme of perception, unanimity, uni— versality and the analogy of emotion experience is dealt with the theme of affection, unanimity and commonality. As consequence, the synergy of both sense and emotion analogy is supported by the model of awareness.
___
- Adam, Martin A.: “A Post—Kantian Perspective on Recent Debates About Mystical Experience”, Journal of the American Academy of Religion, Vol. 70, No: 4, 2002, ss. 801-817.
- Alston, William P.: Perceiving God: The Epistemology of Religious Experience, Cornell University Press, Ithaca and London 1991.
- Attfield, D.G.: “The Argument From Religious Experience”, Religious Studies, Vol.11, No: 3, Cambridge University Press 1975, ss. 335-343.
- Broad, C. D.: Religion, Philosophy and Psychical Research, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London 1953.
- Borchert, Bruno: Myticism: Its History and Challenge, Samuel Weiser, Inc., York Beach, Maine 1994.
- Cabiri, Muhammed Abid: Arap—İslam Kültürünün Akıl Yapısı, Çev. Burhan Köroğlu, Hasan Kacak, Ekrem Demirli, Kitabevi Yay., İstanbul 1999.
- Clifford, W. K.: “The Ethics of Belief ’, Contemporary Review, NO: 29, 1876, ss. 289—309.
- Davis, Caroline Frank: The Evidential Force of Religious Experience, The Clarendon Press, Oxford 1989.
- Ertürk, Ramazan: Sufi Tecrübenin Epistemolojisi: Çağdaş Bir Yaklaşım, Fecr Yay., Ankara 2004.
- Happold, F. C.: Mysticism: Study and an Anthology, Penguin Books, London 1990.
- Hick, John: Arguments for The Existence of God, Herder and Herder, New York 1971.
- Işık, Aydın: Din ve Estetik, Felsefî Bir İnceleme, Ötüken Yayınları, lstanbul 2013.
- James, William: The Varieties of Religious Experience; study in Human Nature, Collins, London 1971.
- James, William: “The Will to Believe”, The Will to Believe and Other Essays in Popular Philosophy, Dover Publications, Inc., NeW York 1956.
- Martin, C. B.: “Seeing God”, Philosophy of Religion: Selected Readings, Ed. William Rowe, William J. Wainwright, Brace ovanovich Publishers, 1989, Orlando ss. 335-353.
- Miles, T. R.: Religious Experience, The Macmillian Press, London and Basingstoke 1972.
- Nieto, Jose C.: Religious Experience and Mysticism: Otherness As Experience of Transcendence, University of Press of America, Lanham, New York, Oxford 1997.
- Poole, Cecile A.: Mysticism: The Ultimate Experience, Supreme Grand Lodge of Amore, California 1982.
- Reçber, Mehmet Sait: Tanrı’yı Bilmenin İmkanı ve Mahiyeti, Ankara, Kitabiyat, 2004.
- Schleiermacher, Friedrich: 0n Religion: Speeches to its Cultured Despisers, Çev. Richard Crouter, Cambridge University, Cambridge 1996.
- Schoen, Edward L.: “Perceiving an Imperceptible God”, Relgious Studies, vol:34, 1998, ss. 433—455.
- Smart, Ninian: The Yogi and The Devotee, The Interplay Between The Upanishads and Catholic Theology, George Allen Unwin Ltd., London 1968.
- Stace, Walter T.: Mysticism and Philosophy, Jeremy P. Tarcher, Inc., Los Angeles 1987.
- Stace, Walter T.: The Teachings of The Mystics, The New American Library, New York 1960.
- Swinburne, Richard: The Existence of God, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1991.
- Trueblood, D. Elton: The Trustworthiness of Religious Experience, George Allen Unw1n Ltd., London 1939.
- Tüzer, Abdüllatif: Dini Tecrübe ve Mistisizm: Felsefi Bir Yaklaşım, Dergah Yayınları, İstanbul 2006.
- Underhill, Evelyn: Mysticism: The Nature and Development ofSpiritual Consciousness, Oneworld, Oxford 2002.
- Wainwright, William .: “Mysticism and Sense Perception”, Religious Studies, Vol. 9, No: 3, 1973, ss. 257—278.
- Wilson, John: Language and Christian Belief, London 1958.
- Yaran, Cafer Sadık: “Lale Delili: Estetikten Etiğe ve Metaüziğe” Din BilimleriAkaa'emik Araştırma Dergisi, IX, 2009, Sayı: 2, ss. 23-36.
- Yüce, Fatma: Dini ve Mistik Tecriibede Evrensel Öz, Elis Yayınları, Ankara 2016.
- ISSN: 1301-0875
- Yayın Aralığı: 2
- Başlangıç: 1990
- Yayıncı: TUFED Adına Prof. Dr. Murtaza KORLAELÇİ