Checklists in Neurosurgery to Decrease Preventable Medical Errors: A Review

Neurosurgery represents a zero tolerance environment for medical errors, especially preventable ones like all types of wrong site surgery, complications due to the incorrect positioning of patients for neurosurgical in-terventions and complications due to failure of the de-vices required for the specific procedure.Following the excellent and encouraging results of the safety checklists in intensive care medicine and in oth-er surgical areas, the checklist was naturally introduced in neurosurgery. To date, the reported world experience with neurosurgical checklists is limited to 15 series with fewer than 20,000 cases in various neurosurgical areas.The purpose of this review was to study the reported neurosurgical checklists according to the following pa-rameters: year of publication; country of origin; area ofneurosurgery;typeofneurosurgicalprocedure-elective or emergency; person in charge of the check-list completion; participants involved in completion; whether they prevented incorrect site surgery; whether they prevented complications due to incorrect posi-tioning of the patients for neurosurgical interventions; whether they prevented complications due to failure of the devices required for the specific procedure; their specific aims; educational preparation and training; the time needed for checklist completion; study duration and phases; number of cases included; barriers to im-plementation; efforts to implementation; team appre-ciation; and safety outcomes.Based on this analysis, it could be concluded that neu-rosurgical checklists represent an efficient, reliable, cost-effective and time-saving tool for increasing pa-tient safety and elevating the neurosurgeons' self-con-fidence. Every neurosurgical department must develop its own neurosurgical checklist or adopt and modify an existing one according to its specific features and needs in an attempt to establish or develop its safety culture. The world, continental, regional and national neurosurgical societies could promote safety checklists and their benefits.

PDF

___

Grober ED, Bohnen JM. Defining medical error. Can J Surg 2005;48:39-44.
Devine J, Chutkan N, Norvell DC, Dettori JR. Avoiding wrong site surgery: a systematic review. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 2010;35(Suppl 9):S28-36.
Kamel I, Barnette R. Positioning patients for spine surgery: Avoiding uncommon position-related complications. World J Orthop 2014;5:425-43.
Cohen FL, Mendelsohn D, Bernstein M. Wrong-site cranioto- my: analysis of 35 cases and systems for prevention. J Neuro- surg 2010;113:461-73.
McConnell DJ, Fargen KM, Mocco J. Surgical checklists: A de- tailed review of their emergence, development, and relevance to neurosurgical practice. Surg Neurol Int 2012;3:2.
North American Spine Society. Sign, mark and X-ray (SMaX): Prevent wrong-site surgery. Available at: https://wwwspineorg/ Pages/ResearchClinicalCare/PatientSafety/SignMarkXrayaspx. 2001.
Connolly PJ, Kilpatrick M, Jaggi JL, Church E, Baltuch GH. Feasibility of an operational standardized checklist for move- ment disorder surgery. A pilot study. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 2009;87:94-100.
Lyons MK. Eight-year experience with a neurosurgical check- list. Am J Med Qual 2010;25:285-8.
Taussky P, Lanzino G, Cloft H, Kallmes D. A checklist in the event of aneurysm perforation during coiling. AJNR Am J Neu- roradiol 2010;31:E59.
Matsumae M, Nakajima Y, Morikawa E, Nishiyama J, Atsumi H, Tominaga J, et al. Improving patient safety in the intra-opera- tive MRI suite using an on-duty safety nurse, safety manual and checklist. Acta Neurochir Suppl 2011;109:219-22.
Da Silva-Freitas R, Martin-Laez R, Madrazo-Leal CB, Villena- Martin M, Valduvieco-Juaristi I, Martinez-Agueros JA, et al. [Establishment of a modified surgical safety checklist for the neurosurgical patient: Initial experience in 400 cases]. Neuro- cirugia (Astur) 2012;23:60-9.
Kramer DR, Halpern CH, Connolly PJ, Jaggi JL, Baltuch GH. Error reduction with routine checklist use during deep brain stimulation surgery. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 2012;90:255-9.
McLaughlin N, Winograd D, Chung HR, Van de Wiele B, Mar- tin NA. University of California, Los Angeles, surgical time-out process: evolution, challenges, and future perspective. Neuro- surg Focus 2012;33:E5.
Oszvald A, Vatter H, Byhahn C, Seifert V, Guresir E. "Team time-out" and surgical safety-experiences in 12,390 neurosurgi- cal patients. Neurosurg Focus 2012;33:E6.
Rahmathulla G, Recinos PF, Traul DE, Avitsian R, Yunak M, Harper NT, et al. Surgical briefings, checklists, and the creation of an environment of safety in the neurosurgical intraoperative mag- netic resonance imaging suite. Neurosurg Focus 2012;33:E12.
Ziewacz JE, Berven SH, Mummaneni VP, Tu TH, Akinbo OC, Lyon R, et al. The design, development, and implementation of a checklist for intraoperative neuromonitoring changes. Neuro- surg Focus 2012;33:E11.
Chen M. A checklist for cerebral aneurysm embolization com- plications. J Neurointerv Surg 2013;5:20-7.
Fargen KM, Velat GJ, Lawson MF, Firment CS, Mocco J, Hoh BL. Enhanced staff communication and reduced near-miss er- rors with a neurointerventional procedural checklist. J Neuroin- terv Surg 2013;5:497-500.
Lepanluoma M, Takala R, Kotkansalo A, Rahi M, Ikonen TS. Surgical safety checklist is associated with improved operating room safety culture, reduced wound complications, and un- planned readmissions in a pilot study in neurosurgery. Scand J Surg 2014;103:66-72.