Comparison of treatment results between surgical and conservative treatment of distal radius fractures in adults: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Objective: This meta-analysis study aims to determine the efficacy and safety of surgical and conservative treatments for distal radiusfractures (DRFs) in adults.Methods: Reports of randomized controlled trials were retrieved from the Web of Science, Pubmed, Google Scholar, EMBASE, CochraneLibrary, Medline, Ovid, and BIOSIS for studies that met the eligibility criteria. The search was limited to human subjects and had nolanguage limits. The search strategy was check by two independent reviewers. If there was any dispute, a third reviewer was consulted.Primary outcomes were: (1) the active wrist range of motion including flexion, extension, pronation, supination, radial, and ulnar deviation; (2) the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score; and (3) radiological outcomes including radial inclination andulnar variance. Secondary outcomes were the number of complications including non-infectious and infectious. Quality assessment wasperformed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool provided by the Cochrane Review Manager 5.3.Results: A total of 10 randomized controlled trials were included. The meta-analysis detected no statistically significant difference inpooled data for complications not included infection (MD 0.64, CI: 0.33 to 1.23, Z=1.34, p=0.18). Surgical treatment achieved a better rangeof motion (MD 3.76, CI: 1.58 to 5.95, Z=3.37, p=0.0007), DASH score (MD -6.57, CI: -9.08 to -4.06, Z=5.12, p

___

1. Körner D, Gonser CE, Bahrs C, Hemmann P. Change in paediatric upper extremity fracture incidences in German hospitals from 2002 to 2017: An epidemiological study. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2020; 140: 887-94.

2. Cummings SR, Melton LJ. Epidemiology and outcomes of osteoporotic fractures. Lancet 2002; 359; 1761-7.

3. Nguyen ND, Ahlborg HG, Center JR, Eisman JA, Nguyen TV. Residual lifetime risk of fractures in women and men. J Bone Miner Res 2007; 22: 781-8.

4. Lafontaine M, Hardy D, Delince P. Stability assessment of distal radius fractures. Injury 1989; 20: 208-10.

5. Armstrong KA, von Schroeder HP, Baxter NN, Zhong T, Huang A, McCabe SJ. Stable rates of operative treatment of distal radius fractures in Ontario, Canada: a population-based retrospective cohort study (2004-2013). Can J Surg 2019; 62: 386-92.

6. Trevisan C, Klumpp R, Nava V, Riccardi D, Recalcati W. Surgical versus conservative treatment of distal radius fractures in elderly. Aging Clin Exp Res 2013; 25 Suppl 1: S83-4.

7. Arora R, Lutz M, Deml C, Krappinger D, Haug L, Gabl M. A Prospective randomized trial comparing nonoperative treatment with volar locking plate fixation for displaced and unstable distal radial fractures in patients sixty-five years of age and older. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2011; 93: 2146-53.

8. Mattila VM, Huttunen TT, Sillanpää P, Niemi S, Pihlajamäki H, Kannus P. Significant change in the surgical treatment of distal radius fractures: A nationwide study between 1998 and 2008 in Finland. J Trauma 2011; 71: 939-43.

9. Wilcke MKT, Hammarberg H, Adolphson PY. Epidemiology and changed surgical treatment methods for fractures of the distal radius A registry analysis of 42,583 patients in Stockholm County, Sweden, 2004-2010. Acta Orthop 2013; 84: 292-6.

10. Mellstrand-Navarro C, Pettersson HJ, Tornqvist H, Ponzer S. The operative treatment of fractures of the distal radius is increasing results from a nationwide Swedish study. Bone Joint J 2014; 96-B: 963-9.

11. Schneppendahl J, Windolf J, Kaufmann RA. Distal Radius Fractures: Current Concepts. J Hand Surg Am 2012; 37: 1718-25.

12. Handoll HHG, Huntley JS, Madhok R. External fixation versus conservative treatment for distal radial fractures in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2007; (3): CD006194.

13. Hoaglin DC. Misunderstandings about Q and ‘Cochran’s Q test’ in meta-analysis. Stat Med 2016; 35: 485-95.

14. Gupta R, Raheja A, Modi U. Colles’ fracture: Management by percutaneous crossed-pin fixation versus plaster of Paris cast immobilization. Orthopedics 1999; 22: 680-2.

15. Rodriguez-Merchan EC. Plaster cast versus percutaneous pin fixation for comminuted fractures of the distal radius in patients between 46 and 65 years of age. J Orthop Trauma 1997; 11: 212-7.

16. Wong TC, Chiu Y, Tsang WL, Leung WY, Yam SK, Yeung SH. Casting versus percutaneous pinning for extra-articular fractures of the distal radius in an elderly Chinese population: a prospective randomised controlled trial. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2010; 35: 202-8.

17. Azzopardi T, Ehrendorfer S, Coulton T, Abela M. Unstable extra-articular fractures of the distal radius - A prospective, randomised study of immobilisation in a cast versus supplementary percutaneous pinning. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2005; 87: 837-40.

18. Howard PW, Stewart HD, Hind RE, Burke FD. External fixation or plaster for severely displaced comminuted Colles’ fractures? A prospective study of anatomical and functional results. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1989; 71: 68-73.

19. Bartl C, Stengel D, Bruckner T, Gebhard F, Group OS. The treatment of displaced intra-articular distal radius fractures in elderly patients. Dtsch Arztebl Int 2014; 111: 779-87.

20. Miller BS, Taylor B, Widmann RF, Bae DS, Snyder BD, Waters PM. Cast immobilization versus percutaneous pin fixation of displaced distal radius fractures in children: a prospective, randomized study. J Pediatr Orthop 2005; 25: 490-4.

21. Saving J, Wahlgren SS, Olsson K, et al. Nonoperative treatment compared with volar locking plate fixation for dorsally displaced distal radial fractures in the elderly a randomized controlled trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2019; 101: 961-9.

22. Sharma H, Khare GN, Singh S, Ramaswamy AG, Kumaraswamy V, Singh AK. Outcomes and complications of fractures of distal radius (AO type B and C): Volar plating versus nonoperative treatment. J Orthop Sci 2014; 19: 537-44.

23. Martinez-Mendez D, Lizaur-Utrilla A, de-Juan-Herrero J. Intra-articular distal radius fractures in elderly patients: a randomized prospective study of casting versus volar plating. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2018; 43: 142-7.

24. Chen Y, Chen X, Li Z, Yan H, Zhou F, Gao W. Safety and efficacy of operative versus nonsurgical management of distal radius fractures in elderly patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Hand Surg Am 2016; 41: 404-13.

25. Ju JH, Jin GZ, Li GX, Hu HY, Hou RX. Comparison of treatment outcomes between nonsurgical and surgical treatment of distal radius fracture in elderly: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Langenbecks Arch Surg 2015; 400: 767- 79.

26. Song J, Yu AX, Li ZH. Comparison of conservative and operative treatment for distal radius fracture: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Int J Clin Exp Med 2015; 8: 17023-35.

27. Yu GS, Lin YB, Le LS, Zhan MF, Jiang XX. Internal fixation vs conservative treatment for displaced distal radius fractures: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Ulus Travma Acil Cerrahi Derg 2016; 22: 233-41.

28. Navarro CM, Brolund A, Ekholm C, et al. Treatment of radius or ulna fractures in the elderly: A systematic review covering effectiveness, safety, economic aspects and current practice. PLoS One 2019; 14: e0214362.

29. Mulders MAM, Detering R, Rikli D, Rosenwasser MP, Goslings JC, Schep NWL. Association between radiological and patient-reported outcome in adults with a displaced distal radius fracture: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Hand Surg Am 2018; 43: 710-9.

30. Boydstun S, Nash L, Rayan GM. Distal Radius Fracture Fixation Devices and Their Radiographs. J Hand Surg Asian Pac Vol 2019; 24: 412-20.

31. Wang J, Lu Y, Cui Y, Wei X, Sun J. Is volar locking plate superior to external fixation for distal radius fractures? A comprehensive meta-analysis. Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc 2018; 52: 334-42.

32. Wollstein R, Harel H, Lavi I, Allon R, Michael D. Postoperative treatment of distal radius fractures using sensorimotor rehabilitation. J Wrist Surg 2019; 8: 2-9.

33. Pritchett JW. Does pinning cause distal radial growth plate arrest? Orthopedics 1994; 17: 550-2.

34. Huard S, Blanchet N, Leclerc G, et al. [Fractures of the distal radius in patients over 70 years old: Volar plates or K-wires?]. Chir Main 2010; 29: 236-41.

35. DeGeorge Jr BR, Houten HKV, Mwangi R, Sangaralingham LR, Larson AN, Kakar S. Outcomes and complications in the management of distal radial fractures in the elderly. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2020; 102: 37-44.

36. Egol KA, Walsh M, Romo-Cardoso S, Dorsky S, Paksima N. Distal radial fractures in the elderly: Operative compared with nonoperative treatment. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2010; 92: 1851-7.