STABILITY ANALYSES FOR INTERPRETING GENOTYPE BY ENVIRONMENT INTERACTION OF SELECTED ORIENTAL TOBACCO LANDRACES
Advanced pure lines, which are in different genetic and vegetative characteristics determined in a breeding
program initiated in 2013, were included to the yield tests in the region before registration. Chemical and
morphological variability and stability of 13 advanced pure tobacco lines and 2 standard varieties were
determined in two different locations. The experimental layout was random blocks with three replications and
the experiment was carried out in 2016 and 2017. Plant height values ranged from 85.25 to 156.71 cm, the
number of leaves from 22.43 to 41.71 leaf plant-1
, leaf width ranged from 9.35 to 11.52 cm, leaf length from
17.36 to 21.89 cm, yield from 1371.9 to 1756.7 kg ha-1
, quality grade index from 67.33 to 81.58%, nicotine
content from 1.02 to 1.98% and glucose content from 3.33 to 9.33%. The lines 16, 21, 26 and 45 were identified
as strong variety candidates suitable for the region based on all the parameters and the statistical conditions
examined. The use of biplots that the environments were distributed on axes, enabled to make location-based
variety recommendations. The biplot graph based on environment and genotype interaction was used in the
recommedations of tobacco variety for each location.
___
- Acquaah, G. 2007. Principles of Plant Genetics and Breeding.
West Sussex: Blackwell Publishing 6, 88.
- Ahmed, S., F. Mohammad, Q. Ahmed and M.A.U. Khan. 2014.
Assessing genetic variation for morpho-agronomic traits of
some native and exotic fcv tobacco genotypes in Pakistan.
American-Eurasian J. Agric. Environ. Sci. 14(5): 428-433.
- Aksu, S. and G.M. Elmas. 1993. Tobacco Chemistry and
Technology. Istanbul; Istanbul University Forestry Faculty
Publications.
- Atanassov, P., C. Borries, M. Zaharieva and P. Monneveux.
2001. Hordein polymorphism and variation of
agromorphological traits in a collection of naked barley.
Genet Resour Crop Evol. 48: 353-60.
- Aytac, B. 2016. Determination of Nail tobacco line performance
in different locations in Bafra. MSc Thesis, University of
Ondokuz Mayis, Samsun, Turkey.
- Bruck, H., C. Jureit, M. Hermann, A. Schulz and B.
Sattelmacher. 2008. Effect of water and nitrogen supply on
water use efficiency and carbon isotope discrimination in
Edible Canna (Canna edulis Ker-Gawler). Plant Biology
3(4): 326-334.
- Butorac, J., J. Beljo and J. Gunjaca. 2004. Study of inheritance
of some agronomic and morphological traits in burley
tobacco by graphic analysis of diallel cross. Plant, Soil and
Environment 50(4): 162-167.
- Celen, A.E., S. Ekren, V. Koparan and E. Ilker. 2016. The
effects of different planting methods on tobacco quality yield
and yield parameters. Proceeding of the Coresta Congress,
Agronomy&Leaf Integrity and Phytopathology&Genetics;
October 9-13; Berlin/Germany.
- Crossa, J., P.N. Fox, W.H. Pfeiffer, S. Rajaram and H.G. Gauch.
1991. AMMI adjustment for statistical analysis of an
international wheat yield trial. Theo. Applied Genet. 81: 27-
37.
- Caliskan, O. 2006. Effects of different seedling production
methods on yield and some quality components in tobacco
(Nicotiana tabaccum L.), thyme (Origanum onites L.) and
lemon balm (Melissa officinalis L.). Phd Thesis, University
of Ondokuz Mayis, Samsun, Turkey.
- Camas, N. 1998. The analysis of the inheritence ability of the
some quantitative characters using line x tester method in
tobacco. Phd Thesis, University of Ondokuz Mayis, Samsun,
Turkey.
Camas, N., E. Esendal, S. Aytac and A.K. Ayan. 1997.
Determination of the inheritance of some traits according to
single sequence analysis method in breeding of hybrid
variety in tobacco. Proceeding in Turkey II. Field Crops
Congres; September 22-25; Samsun, Turkey. 212-216.
- Camas, N., O. Caliskan, M.S. Odabas and A.K. Ayan. 2009. The
effects of organic originated fertilizer doses on yield and
quality of Esendal tobacco cultivar. Proceeding of the
Turkey VIII. Field Crops Congress; October 19-22; Hatay,
Turkey. p. 251-255.
- Dehghani, H., A. Ebadi and A. Yousefi. 2006. Bioplot analysis
of genotype by environment interaction for barley yield in
Iran. Agron. J. 98: 388-393.
- Dyulgerski, Y. and D. Dimanov. 2012. Study on heterozis
behaviour related to the leaves size by the tobacco of burley
variety group. Acta Agriculturae Serbica 34(17): 75-82.
- Eberhart, S.A. and W.A. Russell. 1966. Stability parameters for
comparing varieties. Crop Sci. 6(1): 36-40.
- Ekren, S. and E. Ilker. 2017. The influence of clipping
application on yield and some yield parameters of Aegean
types tobaccos. Turk J Field Crops 22(2): 218-226.
- Erdemci, I. 2018. Investigation of genotype x environment
interaction in chickpea genotypes using AMMI and GGE
biplot analysis. Turk J Field Crops 23(1): 20-26.
- Esendal, E., A.K. Ayan, S. Aytac and N. Camas. 1997. Analysis
of some characteristics of tobacco lines collected from Bafra
population. Proceedings of the Turkey II. Field Crops
Congress; September 22-25; Samsun, Turkey. p. 611-613.
- Esendal, E., A.K. Ayan, S. Aytac and N. Camas. 2001. Analysis
of some characteristics of tobacco lines collected from Bafra
population. Proceedings of the Turkey IV. Field Crops
Congress; September 17-21; Tekirdag, Turkey. 267-272.
- Esendal, E., A.K. Ayan, S. Aytac, N. Camas and O. Caliskan.
(2007). Analysis of properties of some tobacco lines from
Bafra; Proceedings of the Turkey VII. Field Crops Congress;
June 25-27; Erzurum, Turkey. p. 414-420.
- Eser, M. 1994. A comparative study in respect of anatomy,
morphology and mineral material content on the Bafra
Örencik type of Nicotiana tabacum L. (Solonaceae) growing
on plateau and slope area. Phd Thesis, University of
Ondokuz Mayis, Samsun, Turkey.
- Finlay, K.W and G.N. Wilkinson. 1963. The analysis of adaption
in a plant breeding programme. Aust. Journal Agric. Res.
14(6): 742-754.
- Francis, T.R and L.W. Kannenberg. 1978. Yield stability studies
in short season maize. i: a descriptive method for grouping
genotypes. Can. J. Plant Sci. 58(4): 1029-1034.
- Gauch, H.G. 1988. Model selection and validation for yield trials
with interaction. Biometr. 44(3): 705-715.
- Gauch, H.G. 1992. Statistical analysis of regional yield trials:
AMMI analysis of factorial designs. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
- Karpat, H. 1989. Studies on taxonomic characteristics of
Samsun-Bafra tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) cultivars. Phd
Thesis, University of Ondokuz Mayis, Samsun, Turkey.
- Keser, M., N. Bolat, F. Altay, M.T. Cetinel, N. Colak and A.L.
Sever. 1999. Use of some stability parameters in variety
development studies. Cereals symposium, June 8-11, pp. 64-
69, Konya, Turkey.
- Kinay, A. 2014. Yield and quality properties in some oriental
tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) hybrids. Phd Thesis,
University of Tokat Gaziosmanpasa, Samsun, Turkey.
- Kinay, A. 2018. Effects of cadmium on nicotine, reducing sugar
and phenolic contents of Basma tobacco variety. Fresenius
Environmetal Bulletin 27(12A): 9195-9202.
- Korubin-Aleksoska, A., J. Miceska and G. Aleksoski. 2014.
Plant breeding for creation of late-maturing oriental tobacco
genotypes. Тутун/Tobacco 64(1-6): 5-11.
- Kurt, D. 2019. Genotype x environment interactions of Basma
type tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) lines selected for
superior characteristics. Phd Thesis, University of Ondokuz
Mayis, Samsun, Turkey.
- Leffingwell, J.C. 2001. Chemical constituents of tobacco leaf
and differences among tobacco types.
http://www.leffingwell.com/download/tobacco_chemistry.pd
f. (Access Dec. 5 2019).
- Manjunatha, T., IS. Bisht, K.V. Bhat and B.P. Singh. 2007.
Genetic diversity in barley (Hordeum vulgare L. ssp.
vulgare) landraces from Uttaranchal Himalaya of India.
Genet. Resour. Crop Ev. 54: 55-65.
- Mohammadi, M., R. Karimizadeh, N. Sabaghnia and M.K.
Shefazadeh. 2012. Genotype x environment interaction and
yield stablity analysis of new improved bread what
genotypes. Turk J Field Crops 17(1): 67-73.
- Mumtaz, A., D. Hussain, M. Saeed, M. Arshad and M.I. Yousaf.
2019. Stability and adaptability of sorghum hybrids
elucidated with genotype-environment interaction biplots.
Turk J Field Crops 24(2): 155-163.
- Odabasoglu, M. 1994. Tobacco Chemistry. Samsun: Ondokuz
Mayıs University Science Faculty Publications.
- Peksuslu, A., C.O. Sabanci, R. Kucukozden and S. Sekin. 2002.
Genotype x environment interactions and heritabilities of
some important agronomic traits in tobacco. Proceeding of
the II. Balkan Scientific Conference Quality and Efficiency
of the Tobacco Production, Treatment and Processing;
September; Plovdiv, Bulgaria.
- Peksuslu, A., I. Yilmaz, A. Inal and H. Kartal. 2012. Tobacco
Genotypes of Turkey. Journal of Aegean Agricultural
Research Institute, Anadolu 22(2): 82-90.
- Ramusino, M.C., B.S. Dattilo, A. Lucibello and S.G. Rossi.
1994. Determination of 25 low molecular weight
carbohydrates in tobacco by high performance ion
chromatography. Beiträge zur Tabakforschung
International/Contributions to Tobacco Research 16(2): 77-
84.
- Roemer, E., M.K. Schorp, J.J. Piadé, J.I. Seeman, D.E. Leyden
and H.J. Haussmann. 2012. Scientific assessment of the use
of sugars as cigarette tobacco ingredients: a review of
published and other publicly available studies. Critical
Reviews Toxicology 42(3): 244-278.
- Romagosa, I and P.N. Fox. 1993. Genotype x environment
interaction and adaptation. London: Hayward, M.D.,
Bosemark, N.O., Romagosa, I. (Eds.). Plant Breeding:
Principles and Prospects; p. 373-390.
- Sabanci, C.O. 1997. Methods used in stability analysis and
stability parameters. Journal of Aegean Agricultural
Research Institute, Anadolu 7(1): 75-90.
- Sadeghi, S.M., H. Samizadeh, E. Amiri and M. Ashouri. 2011.
Additive main effects and multiplicative interactions (ammi)
analysis of dry leaf yield in tobacco hybrids across
environments. African Journal of Biotechnology 10(21):
4358-4364.
- Sayar, M.S., A.E. Anlarsal and M. Basbag. 2013. Genotypeenvironment interactions and stability analysis for dry-matter
yield and seed yield in hungarian vetch (Vicia pannonica
Crantz.). Turk J Field Crops 18(2): 238-246.
- Sekin, S. 1979. Researches on some analysis methods in
tobacco: chemical composition of Aegean tobacco and
changes during fermentation. Associate professor thesis. Ege
University, Izmir, Turkey.
- Senbayram, M., S. Ekren and S. Sekin. 2005. Effects of
ecological conditions and nutrients on oriental tobacco
quality. Proceeding of the Workshop on Tobacco Farming
and Problems in the Aegean Region; December 21; Izmir,
Turkey.
- Teich, A.H. 1983. Genotype-environment interaction variances
in yield of winter wheat. Cereal Research Communication.
11(1): 15-20.
- Topal, M and N. Yildiz. 2011. Examination of relationship
among parametric and nonparametric stability estimation
methods used in determintion of genotype×environment
interaction. Anadolu J Agr Sci. 26(1): 10-23.
- Usturali, A., R. Apti, H. Otan, G. Yazan and H. Sengul. 1998.
Selection studies on Sarıbağlar subpopulation in the Aegean
tobacco region. Journal of Aegean Agricultural Research
Institute, Anadolu 8(1): 1-15.
- Westcoff, B. 1987. A method of assessing the yield stability of
crops. J. Agric. Sci. 108(2): 267-274.
- Wu, Z., W.W. Weeks and R.C. Long. 1992. Contribution of
neutral volatiles to flavor intensity of tobacco during
smoking. J. Agric. Food. Chem. 40(10): 1917-1921.
- Xia, B., M. Feng, G. Xu, J. Xu, S. Li, X. Chen, L. Ding and Y.
Zhou. 2014. Investigation of the chemical compositions in
tobacco of different origins and maturities at harvest by GCMS and HPLC-PDA-QTOF-MS. Journal of Agricultural and
Food Chemistry 62: 4979-4987.
- Yan, W., P.L. Cornelius, J. Crossa and L.A. Hunt. 2001. Two
types of GGE biplots for analyzing multi-environment trial
data. Crop Sci. 41(3): 656-663.
- Yazan, G. and A.S. Gencer. 2001. Determination of polyphenol
compounds in Aegean region tobacco and investigation of
their effects on smoke condensate. Proceedings of the
Turkey IV. Field Crops Congress; September 17-21;
Tekirdag, Turkey.
- Zakova, M. and M. Benkova. 2006. Characterization of spring
barley accessions based on multivariate analysis. Commun.
Biom. Crop Sci. 1(2): 124-34.
- Zeba, N. and M. Isbat. 2011. Multivariate analysis for yield and
yield contributing traits in F0 and F1 generations in tobacco.
Journal of Experimental Bioscience 2(1): 101-106.
- Zencirci, N., V. Eser and I. Baran. 1990. An approach to
comparison of some stability statistics. Ankara: Field Crops
Central Research Institue Publications.
- Zorba, T. 2008. A study on determination of tobacco cultivars
and lines, best suited for Black Sea region and their expertise
data. MSc Thesis, University of Ondokuz Mayıs, Samsun,
Turkey.