DEVLETLERİN TANINMASINDA DÖNÜM NOKTALARI: BADİNTER KOMİSYONU VE KOSOVA'NIN TANINMASI

Bu makale Kosova'nın bağımsızlık ilanı ve Badinter Komisyonu çerçevesinde yeni devletlerin tanınmasına ilişkin uluslararası hukuktaki gelişmeleri incelemeyi amaçlamaktadır. Badinter Komisyonu Avrupa Topluluğu ve uluslararası toplumun yetkilendirdiği sınırlar içinde Yugoslavya'daki self-determinasyon, ayrılma ve egemenlik konularını çözümüne katkı sağladı. Kosova'nın tek taraflı ve ani bağımsızlık ilanı ise uluslararası toplumu ikiye böldü. Birçok Avrupa devleti Kosova'yı hemen tanıdı ve Kosova'nın bağımsızlık deklarasyonuna destek verdi. Bazı Avrupalı devletler ise Kosova Parlamentosunun eylemini uluslararası hukuka aykırı ve hukuk dışı bir eylem olarak niteledi. Bu makalede, bu iki durumun ortaya çıkardığı durumları incelenecektir

TURNING POINTS IN THE RECOGNITION OF STATES : BADINTER COMMISSION AND KOSOVO'S DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE

This article intends to examine the developments in international law in relation to the recognition of new states within the frame work of the Badinter Commission and Kosovo's declaration of independence. The self-determination in Yugoslavia authorized within the limits of Badinter Commission, European Community and the International Community has contributed to settling issues of sovereignty and secession. Kosovo's unilateral and immediate declaration of independence has divided the international community. Many European countries both recognized Kosovo and gave support to its independence declaration. However, some European countries denounced this action of Kosovo's parliament as unlawful and contrary to international law. In this article, the consequences stemmed from these two cases are to be examined

PDF

___

Benedict, Kingsbury, " Claims by Non- State Grups in International Law", Cornel International Law Journal, Vol.25,No.3,1992.
Bennett,Christopher, Yugoslavia's Bloody Collapse: Causes, Course and Consequences, NYU Press, New York, 1997.
Bing JIA, Bing, "The Independence of Kosovo: A Unique Caseof Secession?", Chinese Journal of International Law , Vol. 8, No1,2009.
Borgen,Christopher J.," Kosovo's Declaration of Independence: Self- Determination, Secession and Recognition", American Society of International Law: Asil Insight , 2008, http://slomanson.tjsl.edu/2.4_KosSecession.pdf tarihi 18.01.2009 ) ( Erişim
Brown, Bartram, Human Rights, Sovereignty, and the Final Status of Kosovo, Chicago-Kent Law Review,Vol.80,No.1,2005.
Calic ,Marie-Janine," Kosovo in the Twentieth Century: A Historical Account", Kosovo and The Challenge Of Humanitarian Intervention: Selective Indignation", Collective Action, and International iıtizenship, Eds.: Albrecht Schnabel & Ramesh Thakur, United Nations University Press, New York, Paris, Tokyo, 2000. Cassese, Antonio, Reappraisal,Cambridge University Press, New York, 1999. of Peoples: A Legal
Charney, Jonathan, "Self-determination: Chechnya, Kosovo, East Timor",Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, Vol.34,No 2,2001.
Daskalovski,Zhidas, " The Independence of Kosovo and the Consolidation of Macedonia--A Reason to Worry?", Journal of Contemporary European Studies, Vol. 16, No. 2, , 2008.
De Wet ,Erika, "The Governance of Kosovo: Securıty Council Resolution 1244 and The Establishment and Functionıng Of Eulex ", The Vol.103,No.1,2009. Journal Of Internatıonal Law,
Delahunty ,Robert J. and Perez, Antonio F., "The Kosovo Crisis: A Dostoievskian Dialogue on International Law, Statecraft, and Soulcraft", Vanderbilt Journal Of Transnational Law, Vol.42,No.1, 2009.
Dugard , John, "Secession: Is the Case of Yugoslavia a Precedent for Africa?" African Journal of International & Comparative Law, Vol. 5, No.1,1993.
Dugard John and Raic David, "The Role of Recognition in the Law and Practice of Secession", Secession: International Law Perspectives, ( Ed. )Marcelo Kohen, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,2006.
Erlanger, Steven," Yugoslavs Demand a Role in U.N. Kosovo Settlement", N.Y. TIMES, 22 Mayıs1999.
Grant,Thomas D., The Recognition of States: Law and Practice in Debate and Evolution, Westpost Press, London,1999.
Hill,Christopher, European Foreign Policy: Key Documents, Routledge, London, 2000.
Hilpold, Peter, "The Kosovo Case and International Law: Looking for Applicable Theories", Chinese Journal of International Law, Vol. 8, No.1,2009.
Islami, Iliriana, "the Insufficiency of International Legal Personality of Kosova as Attained Through The European Court of Human Rights: a Call for Statehood" , Chıcago-Kent Law Review, , Vol.80,No.1, 2005.
Klejda, Mulaj, "A recurrent tragedy: Ethnic Cleansing as a Tool of State Building in The Yugoslav Multinational Setting", Nationalities Papers, Vol. 34, No. 1, 2006.
Knop,Karen, Diversity and Self-Determination in International Law, Cambridge University, Cambridge, 2002.
Koktsidis, Pavlos-Ioannis, "A Success Story? Analysing Albanian Ethno- Natıonalist Extremism in the Balkans", East European Quarterly, Vol.XIII, No. 2,2008.
Krasner , Stephen D., Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy, , N.J. Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1999.
Kuci, Hajredin ,"The Legal and Political Grounds for, and the Influence of the Actual Situation on, the Demand of the Albanians of Kosovo Review,Vol.80,No.1,2005.
Independence", Chicago-Kent Law
Kut, Şule, Balkanlarda Kimlik ve Egemenlik, İstanbul Bilgi Üniversitesi Yayınları, İstanbul,2005.
Lukic ,Reneo and Lynch, Alen, Europe from the Balkans to the Urals: The Disintegration of Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union, A SIPRI Publication,1996.
Makinda ,Samuel M., 'Sovereignty and International Security: Challenges for the United Nations', Global Governance, Vol. 2,No.2, 1996.
Merriam, John J " Kosovo And The Law Of Humanitarian İntervention", Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law, Winter,Vol. 33, No.1,2001.
Mihaillovic, Srecko, " Kosovo: Between Co-Existence and Permenent Confilict, The Lessons of Yugoslavia, ( Ed. ) Meta Spencer, Hawort Press, NewYork,2000. Musgrave,Cf. Thomas, Self-Determination and National Minorities,Clarendon Pres, Oxford,1997.
Ouguergouz , Fatsah and Tehindrazanarivelo,Djacoba Liva" The Question of Secession in Africa", Secession: International Law Perspectives, ( Ed.)Marcelo Kohen ,Cambridge University Press, Cambridge ,2006.
Pellet, Alain, "Appendix: Opinions No. 1, 2 and 3 of the Arbitration Committee of the International Conference on Yugoslavia", EJIL, vol.3, no.1, 1992.
Pellet, Allan " The Opinions of the Badinter Arbitration Committee : A Second Breath for the Self-Determination of Peoples", EJIL, vol.3,no,.1,1992.
Perritt Henry H., Jr., "Resolving Claims When Countries Dİsİntegrate: the Challenge of Kosovo" , Chıcago-Kent Law Revıew, , Vol.80,No.1, 2005.
Quane, Cf. Helen, The United Nations and the Evolving Right to Self- Deterniination, Quarterly,Vol.47, No.3,1998. International & Comparative Law
Radan,Peter, The Break-up of Yugoslavia and International Law, Routledge, London and New York ,2002.
Ramcharan,B.G. ,The International Conference on The Former Yugoslavia, International, The Hague,London,Boston,1997. Papers, Vol.2, Kluwer Law
Rich, Roland, "Recognition of States: The Collapse of Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union",EJIL, Vol.4,No.1,1993.
Rüdiger Wolfrum," Kosovo: Some Thoughts on its Future Status", Multiculturalism and International LawEssays in Honour of Edward McWhinne, , ( Ed.) Sienho Yee/ Jacques-Ivan Morin , Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2009.
Sioussiouras, Petros," The Process of Recognition of The Newly Independent States of Former Yugoslavia by The European Community: The Case of The Former Socialist Republic of Macedonia", Journal of Political and Military Sociology, vol. 32, No.1,2004.
Talmon, Stefan " The Constitutive versus the Declaratory Theory of Recognition: Tertium non Datur? ", British Yearbook of International Law,Vol.75, 2004.
Terrett, Steve, The Dissolution of Yugoslavia and The Badinter Arbitration Commission, Ashgate Publishing, Aldershot and Burlington,2000.
Tolksdorf, Dominik, "Kosovo Precedent - Applıcable In Many Parts Of The World, But Not Dırectly In The South Caucasus", Caucasian Review Of International Afairs,Vol.3,No.1,2009.
Tomuschat ,C. .- Thouvenin ,M., The Fundamental Rules of the International Legal Order, Leiden, , Martinus Nijhoff Publishers,, 2005.
Trifunovska, Snezana M., Yugoslavia through Documents - From its Creation to its Dissolution, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden, 1994.
Waters,Timothy William" Contemplating CreatingAlternatives in the Balkans:Bosnia's Peoples, Democracy, and the Shape of Self-Determination", The Yale Journal of International Law,Vol. 29,No.2,2004. and
Weller, Marc "International Law and Chaos," Cambridge Law Journal, 1993,Vol.52,No.1, 1993.
Weller, Marc, "Kosovo's final status", International Affairs, Vol. 84,No.6 , 2008.
Zagar,Mitja ," Yugoslavia: What Went Wrong? Constituational Aspects of The Yugoslav Crisis From The Perspective of Ethnic Conflict", The Lessons of Yugoslavia, (Ed.) Meta Spencer, Hawort Pres, New York,2000.
BELGELER
S.C. Res. 1244, U.N. Doc. S/RES/1244 (10 Haziran 1999), http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N99/172/89/PDF /N9917289.pdf?OpenElement ( Erişim tarihi 15 Aralık 2009 )
1244 sayılı Karar için bz. http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N99/172/89/PDF /N9917289.pdf?OpenElement ( Erişim tarihi 15.12.2008 )
Kosova Geçici Anayasa Türkçe metni için bkz. http://www.unmikonline.org/pub/misc/FrameworkPocket_T UR.pdf ( Erişim tarihi 04.01.2009 )
Kosovanın Gelecekteki Statüsüne İlişkin BM Genel Sekreteri Özel Temsilcisi http://209.85.129.132/search?q=cache:Ko9EKm81PUgJ:ww w.unosek.org/docref/reportenglish.pdf+Report+of+the+Speci al+Envoy+of+the+Secretary- General+on+Kosovo%27s+Future+Status&cd=1&hl=tr&ct= clnk&gl=tr ( Erişim tarihi 04.01.2009 ) Raporu
UNMIK haber arşivi http://www.unmikonline.org/archives/news01_08.htm
Sömürge Altındaki Ülkelerin ve Halkların Bağımsızlığının Garanti Altına Alınmasına İlişkin Deklârasyon için bkz.
http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/RESOLUTION/GEN/NR0/152/88/IMG/NR0 15288.pdf?OpenElement ( Erişim tarihi 04.01.2009 )
Devletlerarası Dostluk İlişkilerin Geliştirtmesine İlişkin Deklârasyon için bkz
http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/RESOLUTION/GEN/NR0/348/90/IMG/NR0 34890.pdf?OpenElement ( Erişim tarihi 04.01.2009 )
Badinter Komisyonu Karaları http://www.la.wayne.edu/polisci/dubrovnik/readings/badinter .pdf ( Erişim tarihi 18.12 .2008 )
Elitre'nin BM üyelik kararı için bkz. http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N93/407/39/IM G/N9340739.pdf?OpenElement ( Erişim tarihi 05.01.2009 )
EC Bulletin 7/8,1991.
EPC Press Release 129/91, 16 December 1991
Declaration on the 'Guidelines on the Recognition of New States in Eastern Europe and in the Soviet Union, EJIL,Vol.4,No.1,1993.