Persistence, Inertia, Adaptation and Life Cycle: Applying Urban Morphological Ideas to Conceptualise Sustainable City-Centre Change

Consideration of the speed and scale of change of urban forms has a longhistory in urban morphological thought. Buildings and forms that persistin the urban landscape through inertia or, more positively, deliberatedecisions to retain them create character and – a more recent argument– contribute to sustainability not least in their embedded energy. Thispaper explores issues of the persistence and adaptation of some urbanforms, focusing on the central business district of Birmingham, UK. Muchof this is now protected as a conservation area, and some of its formshave persisted for centuries. Yet there have been periods of rapidchange, and we examine the extent of change following Second WorldWar bomb damage. This allows discussion of the dynamics of change andthe agents and agencies responsible for producing new urban forms or retaining existing ones; and this informs exploration of the potentialcontribution of longevity of form to sustainability. The rapid recycling ofsome structures, after only a couple of decades, may be veryunsustainable – impracticable and unaffordable – in an urban context.

PDF

___

Adams, D. (2011). Everyday experiences of the modern city: remembering the post‐war reconstruction of Birmingham. Planning Perspectives, 26(2), 237-260.
Adams, D. & Larkham, P. J. (2019). The Everyday Experiences of Reconstruction and Regeneration: From Vision to Reality in Birmingham and Coventry: Routledge.
Aïtcin, P. C. & Minders, S. (2011). Sustainability of Concrete. Abdingdon, Spon.
Allen, C. & Blandy, S. (2004). Fables of the reconstruction: Innerurban regeneration, city centre living and the reinvention of urban space. Paper presented at the international conference of the International Sociological Association, Research Committee.
Barber, A. & Hall, S. (2008). Birmingham: whose urban renaissance? Regeneration as a response to economic restructuring. Policy Studies, 29(3), 281-292.
Batty, M. (2007). The creative destruction of cities. Environment & Planning B, 24, 2-5.
BBC (British Broadcasting Corporation) (2008). Bullring ‘UK’s ugliest building. BBC News 14 October. http://bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7668994.stm.(accessed.6/9/ 2019).
Benton-Short, L., Keeley, M. & Rowland, J. (2019). Green infrastructure, green space, and sustainable urbanism: geography’s important role. Urban Geography, 40(3), 330- 351.
Birmingham City Council (1989). The Highbury Initiative City Challenge Symposium. Birmingham: City Council.
Birmingham City Council (2017) Birmingham Plan 2031. Birmingham: City Council.
Bryson, J. (2003) Reshaping and reinvesnting the city of Birmingham: planning for enterprise and the information society. In A. MacLaren (ed.) Making Space: Property Development and Urban Planning London: Arnold.
Calder, B. (2016). Raw concrete: the beauty of brutalism: Random House.
Clawley, A. (2011). John Madin. RIBA Publications.
Clawley, A. (2015). Library Story. Birmingham: author.
Clement, A. (2018). Brutalism: post-war British architecture: The Crowood Press.
Conzen, M.R.G. (1962). The plan analysis of an English city centre. In K. Norborg (ed.) Proceedings of the I.G.U. Symposium in Urban Geography, Lund, 1960. Lund Studies in Geography. Lund: Royal University of Lund, Department of Geography.
Dale, P. (2009). Experts cast doubt on Birmingham Central Library ‘concrete cancer’ claims. Birmingham Post 16 June. https://www.thefreelibrary.com/ (accessed 6/9/2019).
Edensor, T. (2019). The haunting presence of commemorative statues. Ephemera, 19(1), 53-76.
Flynn, N. & Taylor, A. (1986). Inside the rust belt: an analysis of the decline of the West Midlands economy. 1: International and national economic conditions. Environment & Planning A, 18(7), 865-900.
Foster, A. (2005). Birmingham (Buildings of Britain: Pevsner Architectural Guides). New Haven: Yale University Press.
Glendinning, M. (2013). The Conservation Movement. Abingdon: Routledge.
Gold, J. R. (2007). The practice of modernism: modern architects and Urban Transformation, 1954–1972: Routledge.
Graham, B., Ashworth, G. & Tunbridge, J. (2000). A Geography of Heritage. London: Edward Arnold.
Hall, T. & Hubbard, P. (2014). Birmingham needs you/you need Birmingham: Cities as Actors, Actors in Cities. In M. Conzen & P.J. Larkham (eds), Shapers of Urban Form: Explorations in Morphological Agency (pp. 285-300). Abingdon: Routledge.
Harwood, E. (2015). Space, Hope, and Brutalism: English Architecture, 1945-1975. London: Yale University Press.
Hopkins, O. (2017). Lost Futures: The Disappearing Architecture of Post-war Britain. London: Royal Academy of Arts.
Kynaston, D. (2015). A crushing case for brutalism — with the people left out. The Spectator, 10 October, https://www. spectator.co.uk/2015/10/big-is-beautiful-a-crushing-cas e-for-brutalism-with-the-people-left-out/ (accessed 19/9/2019).
Larkham, P.J. (1996). Conservation and the City. London: Routledge.
Larkham, P.J. (1999). Tensions in managing the suburbs: conservation versus change. Area, 31 (4), 359-371.
Larkham, P.J. (2016). Replanning post-war Birmingham. Architectura, 46(1), 2-26.
Larkham, P.J. & Adams, D. (2016). The un-necessary monument? The origins, impact and potential conservation of Birmingham Central Library. Transactions of the Ancient Monuments Society, 60, 94-127.
Lees, L. (2003). Visions of ‘urban renaissance’: the Urban Task Force report and the Urban White Paper. In R. Imrie & M. Raco (eds) Urban Renaissance? New Labour, Community and Urban Policy. Bristol: Policy Press.
Loftman, P. & Nevin, B. (2003). Prestige projects, city centre restructuring and social exclusion: taking the long-term. view. In M. Miles & T. Hall (eds) Urban Futures. London: Routledge.
Madin, J. (2009). Cutting the cultural and civic heart out of Birmingham. Birmingham Post, 9 October., http://www.BirminghamPost.net/comment (accessed 6/9/2019).
Manzoni, H.J. (1968). The Development of Town Planning in Birmingham. Unpublished notes from the History of Birmingham Seminar no. 2, School of History, University of Birmingham, copy in Birmingham Library, Local Studies, LP56.4.
Martin, G. H. (1968). The town as palimpsest. In H. J. Dyos (ed.), The Study of Urban History. London: Edward Arnold.
Mecanoo architecten (2014). A People’s Palace: the Library of Birmingham. Berlin: Aedes Architecture Forum.
Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government (2018). Revised National Planning Policy Framework. London: Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government
O’Neill, R.V., DeAngelis, D.L., Wade, J.B., Allen, T.F.H. & Allen G.E. (1986). A Hierarchical Concept of Ecosystems. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Parker, D. & Long, P. (2004). 'The mistakes of the past'? Visual narratives of urban decline and regeneration. Visual Culture in Britain, 5(1), 37-58.
Plymouth City Council (2019). Press release on new conservation area. http://plymouthnewsroom.co.uk/council-agreesnew-city-centre-conservation-area/(accessed 6/9/2019).
Sirman, B. (2018). Concrete Changes: Architecture, Politics, and the Design of Boston City Hall. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press.
Sutcliffe, A.R. (1967-9). Transcripts of Interviews with Prominent Birmingham People 1967-9. Unpublished typescript, copy in Birmingham Library, Local Studies, LF71.
Sutcliffe, A., & Smith, R. (1974). Birmingham 1939-1970/ (History of Birmingham Volume III): Oxford University Press.
Thomas, A., Lombardi, R., Hunt, D. & Gaterell, M. (2009). Estimating carbon dioxide emissions for aggregate use. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, 162, 135- 144.
Tibbalds, Colbourne, Karski, Williams (1990). Birmingham Urban Design Strategy: City Centre Design Strategy. Birmingham: City Council.
Urban Task Force (1999). Towards an Urban Renaissance. London: Department for Environment, Transport and the Regions.
van Nes, A. (2001) Road building and urban change. In Proceedings of the 3rd International Space Syntax Symposium. Atlanta.
While, A. (2006). Modernism vs urban renaissance: Negotiating post-war heritage in English city centres. Urban Studies, 43(13), 2399-2420.
While, A. (2007). The state and the controversial demands of cultural built heritage: the origins and evolution of postwar listing in England. Environment & Planning B, 34, 645- 663.
While, A., & Short, M. (2011). Place narratives and heritage management: the modernist legacy in Manchester. Area, 43(1), 4-13.