What is Really Wrong with Ontic Structural Realism? On the Possibility of Reading off Ontology from Cur-rent Fundamental Science

I argue that the central conflict between epistemic and ontic versions of structural realism concerns whether it is possible to read off ontology from current fundamental science. Even if we assume that structures are metaphysi-cally superior to objects, the possibility of reading off ontology from current fundamental science remains unjustified. I show that the conclusion as regards the reading off ontology in the ontic version is already assumed in one of the premises; hence the argument begs the question. As a result, the problem of ontological discontinuity implied in the pessimistic meta-induction argument remains intact in ontic structural realism.

PDF

___

Belousek, D. W. (2000a). Statistics, Symmetry, and the Conventionality of Indistinguishability in Quantum Mechanics. Foundations of Physics, 30, 1-34.

Belousek, D. W. (2000b). Statistics, Symmetry, and (In)distinguishability in Bohmian Mechanics. Foundations of Physics, 30, 53-164.

Bub, J. (2004). Why the Quantum? Studies in the History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 35, 241-266.

Bub, J. (2005). Quantum Mechanics is About Quantum Information. Foundations of Physics, 35(4), 541-560.

Clifton, R. & Bub, J. & Halvorson, H. (2003). Characterizing Quantum Theories in Terms of Information-Theoretic Constraints. Foundations of Physics, 33(11), 1561-1591.

Dennett, D. (1991). Real Patterns. Journal of Philosophy, 88, 27–51.

Esfeld, M. (2004). Quantum Entanglement and a Metaphysics of Relations. Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 35, 601-617.

Esfeld, M. (2013). Ontic Structural Realism and the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. European Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 3, 19-32.

Esfeld, M. & Lam, V. (2008). Moderate Structural Realism about Space-time. Synthese, 160, 27-46.

French, S. (1989). Identity and Individuality in Classical and Quantum Physics. Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 67, 432-446.

French, S. (1998). On the Withering away of Physical Objects. Interpreting Bodies: Classical and Quantum Objects in Modern Physics. (Ed. E. Castellani). Princeton: Princeton University Press, 93-113.

French, S. (2014). The Structure of the World: Metaphysics and Representation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

French, S. & Ladyman, J. (2003). Remodelling Structural Realism: Quantum Physics and the Metaphysics of Structure. Synthese, 136, 31-56.

French, S. & Redhead, M. (1988). Quantum Physics and the Identity of Indiscernibles. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 39, 233-246.

Ladyman, J. (1998). What is Structural Realism? Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science, 29, 409-424.

Ladyman, J. (2016). Are There Individuals in Physics, and if so, What are They? Individuals Across Sciences. (Ed. A. Guay). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ladyman, J. & Ross, D. (2007). Every Thing Must Go: Metaphysics Naturalized. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ladyman, J. & Ross, D. (2013). The World in the Data. Scientific Metaphysics. (Ed. D.

Ladyman, J. & Ross, D. (1984). Discussion: Realism Without the Real. Philosophy of Science, 51, 156-162.

Saunders, S. (2003a). Indiscernibles, General Covariance, and Other Symmetries. Revisiting the Foundations of Relativistic Physics: Festschrift in Honour of John Stachel. (Ed. A. Ashtekar, D. Howard, J. Renn, S. Sarkar & A. Shimony). Dordrecht: Kluwer.

Saunders, S. (2003b). Physics and Leibniz's Principles. Symmetries in Physics: Philosophical Reflections. (Ed. K. Brading & E. Castellani) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Saunders, S. (2006). Are Quantum Particles Objects? Analysis, 66, 52–63.

Stanford, K. & Humphreys, P. & Hawley, K. & Ladyman, J. & Ross, D. (2010). Protecting Rainforest Realism, Symposium. Metascience, 19, 161-85.

Van Fraassen, B. C. (1991). Quantum Mechanics: An Empiricist View. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Van Fraassen, B. C. (2006). Structure: Its Shadow and Substance. British Journal for The Philosophy of Science, 57, 275-307.

Worrall, J. (1989). Structural Realism: The Best of Both Worlds? Dialectica, 43, 99-124.