Does Mode of Foreign Entry Affect Profitability Dynamics? An Evidence from the Turkish Banking Sector

This paper analyzes the effect of foreign entry on the profitability of the Turkish banks by panel estimation models. The dependent variable is net return on assets and net return on equity, which are used interchangeably to measure profitability. The independent variables are composed of bank-specific variables as well as host-country and global factors. In the benchmark model, the effect of foreign entry is captured by dummy variables that classify banks according to their foreign share content, whereas in the alternative model, the estimations are conducted sepera- tely for each mode of foreign entry category. Additionally, the analysis is repeated individually for the periods before and after the global crisis. Estimation results suggest that the significance of the explanatory variables changes depending on the foreign share content. Also, bank-specific variables and global factors are more important, while host-country factors are less important after the global crisis. For future work, other explanatory variables may be added to capture features peculiar to mode of foreign entry. Furthermore, certain variables may be included to seize developments in parent banks’ countries, which might affect subsidiary banks. Finally, other bank-specific variables like measures on administrative structure may be useful in estimations.

Yabancı Girişi Kârlılık Dinamiklerini Etkiliyor mu? Türk Bankacılık Sektöründen Kanıt

Bu çalışmada yabancı girişinin Türk bankalarının kârlılığı üzerindeki etkileri panel tahmin modelleriyle incelenmektedir. Kârlılığı ölçmek üzere bağımlı değişken olarak varlık getirisi ve özsermaye getirisinin dönüşümlü kullanıldığı çalışmada, açıklayıcı değişkenler bankaya özgü değişkenler ile evsahibi ülke ve küresel ekonomiye ilişkin etkenlerden oluşmaktadır. Baz modelde yabancı payının etkisi kukla değişkenlerle kontrol edilmekte, alternatif modelde ise regresyonlar bankaların yabancı payı kategorisi ayırımına göre tahmin edilmektedir. Ek olarak, analiz küresel kriz öncesi ve sonrası dönemler için tekrarlanmaktadır. Tahmin sonuçları açıklayıcı değişkenlerin anlamlılığının bankaların yabancı payına göre değiştiğini göstermektedir. Ayrıca, küresel kriz sonrasında bankaya özgü değişkenler ve küresel etkenlerin daha anlamlı, ev sahibi ülke etkenlerinin ise daha az anlamlı olduğu görülmektedir. İleriki dönemde yapılacak çalışmalarda, modele yabancı payını yansıtacak açıklayıcı değişkenlerin eklenmesi önerilmektedir. Buna ek olarak, bağlı bankaları etkileyen ev sahibi ülkelerdeki gelişmeleri yansıtacak değişkenlerin de çalışmaya dahil edilmesi gerektiği düşünülmektedir. Son olarak, tahminlere bankaların idari yapısına ilişkin değişkenlerin ilave edilmesinin faydalı olacağı değerlendirilmektedir.


1. Adrian, T. and H.S. Shin, 2010, Liquidity and Leverage, Journal of Financial Intermediation, 19(3): 418-437.

2. Akçay, O.C., 2003, The Turkish Banking Sector Two Years after the Crisis: A Snapshot of the Sector and Current Risks, Turkish Studies, 4(2): 169-187.

3. Akın, A. and N. Bayyurt, 2016, Mode of Entry and the Performance of Foreign Banks: Evidence from Turkish Banking Industry, Eurasian Journal of Business and Economics, 9(17): 153-164.

4. Akter, R. and J. Roy, 2017, The Impacts of Non-Performing Loan on Profitability: An Empirical Study on Banking Sector of Dhaka Stock Exchange, International Journal of Economics and Finance, 9(3): 126-132.

5. Alp, H. and S. Elekdağ, 2011, The Role of Monetary Policy in Turkey during the Global Financial Crisis, IMF Working Paper No. 11/150.

6. Alper, C.E. and Z. Öniş, 2004, The Turkish Banking System and the IMF in the Age of Capital Account Liberalization, New Perspectives on Turkey, 30(1): 25-55.

7. Alper, C.E., M.H. Berument and N.K. Malatyalı, 2001a, The Impact of the Disinflation Program on the Structure of the Turkish Banking Sector, Russian and East European Finance and Trade, 37(6): 76-89.

8. , 2001b, The Disinflation Program and the Structure of the Turkish Banking Sector, Boğaziçi Journal, 15(2): 25-33.

9. Altavilla, C., M. Boucinha, J.L. Peydró, 2017, Monetary Policy and Bank Profitability in a Low Interest Rate Environment, European Central Bank Working Paper Series No. 2105.

10. Andrews, A.M., 2005, State-Owned Banks, Stability, Privatization, and Growth Practical Policy Decisions in a World without Empirical Proof, IMF Working Paper No. 05/10.

11. Angbazo, L., 1997, Commercial Bank Net Interest Margins, Default Risk, Interest-Rate Risk, and Off-Balance Sheet Banking, Journal of Banking & Finance, 21(1), 55-87.

12. Aras, O.N., 2010, Effects of the Global Economic Crisis on Turkish Banking Sector, International Journal of Economics and Finance Studies, 2(1): 113- 120.

13. Athanasoglou, P., S. Brissimis and M. Delis, 2008, Bank-Specific, Industry-Specific and Macroeconomic Determinants of Bank Profitability, Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, 18 (2): 121-136.

14. Aysan, A.F. and S.P. Ceyhan, 2008, What Determines the Banking Sector Performance in Globalized Financial Markets? The Case of Turkey, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 387 (7): 1593-1602.

15. Barajas, A., S. Roberto and S. Natalia, 2000, The Impact of Liberalization and Foreign Investment in Colombia’s Financial Sector, Journal of Development Economics, 63(1): 157-196.

16. BCBS, 2016, Regulatory Consistency Assessment Programme (RCAP): Assessment of Basel III Risk-Based Capital Regulations-Turkey, Bank for International Settlements, March.

17. BRSA, 2006, Regulation on the Procedures and Principles for Determination of Qualifications of Loans and Other Receivables by Banks and Provisions to be Set Aside, available at

18. Beck, T., R. Cull and J. Afeikhena, 2005, Bank Privatization and Performance: Empirical Evidence from Nigeria, Journal of Banking & Finance, 29(8-9): 2355-2379.

19. Ben Naceur, S., 2003, The Determinants of the Tunisian Banking Industry Profitability: Panel Evidence, Unpublished paper.

20. Berger, A.N., 1995, The Relationship between Capital and Earnings in Banking, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 27(2), 432-456.

21. Berger, A.N., I. Hassan and M. Zhou, 2009, Bank Ownership and Efficiency in China: What Will Happen in the World’s Largest Nation, Journal of Banking & Finance, 33(1): 113-130.

22. Bikker, J.A. and H. Hu, 2002, Cyclical Patterns in Profits, Provisioning and Lending of Banks and Procyclicality of the New Basel Capital Requirements, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review, 55(221): 143-175.

23. Bikker, J.A. and T.M. Vervliet, 2018, Bank Profitability and Risk-Taking under Low Interest Rates, International Journal of Finance Economics, 23(1): 3-18.

24. Bonin, J.P., I. Hasan and P. Wachtel, 2005, Bank Performance, Efficiency and Ownership in Transition Countries, Journal of Banking & Finance, 29(1): 31- 53.

25. Boubakri, N., J.C. Cosset and O. Guedhami, 2005, Liberalization, Corporate Governance and the Performance of Privatized Firms in Developing Countries, Journal of Corporate Finance, 11(5): 767-790.

26. Bourke, P., 1989, Concentration and Other Determinants of Bank Profitability in Europe, North America and Australia, Journal of Banking & Finance, 13(1): 65-79.

27. Bordeleau, E. and C. Graham, 2010, The Impact of Liquidity on Bank Profitability, Bank of Canada Working Paper No. 2010-38.

28. Borio, C., L. Gambacorta and B. Hofmann, 2015, The Influence of Monetary Policy on Bank Profitability, BIS Working Papers No. 514.

29. Bruno, V. and H.S. Shin, 2015, Cross-Border Banking and Global Liquidity, Review of Economic Studies, 82(2): 535-564.

30. Buch, C.M., 2002, Is Foreign Control a Panacea? – On Governance and Restructuring of Commercial Banks in Transition Economies, in A. Winkler (ed.), Banking and Monetary Policy in Eastern Europe, Palgrave, Basingstoke, UK.

31. Bumin, M., 2007, The Determinants of Foreign Bank Entry to the Turkish Banking Sector, Banks and Bank Systems, 2(4): 84-92.

32. Cetorelli, N. and L.S. Goldberg, 2012, Banking Globalization and Monetary Transmission, The Journal of Finance, 67(5): 1811-1843.

33. Chamberlain, S., J.S. Howe and H. Popper, 1997, The Exchange Rate Exposure of U.S. and Japanese Banking Institutions, Journal of Banking & Finance, 21(6): 871-892.

34. Chang, R. and A. Velasco, 2001, Monetary Policy in a Dollarized Economy Where Balance Sheets Matter, Journal of Development Economics, 66(2):

35. Chen, K. and C. Pan, 2012, An Empirical Study of Credit Risk Efficiency of Banking Industry in Taiwan, Web Journal of Chinese Management Review, 15(1): 1-16.

36. Cheng, G. and D. Mevis, 2019, What Happened to Profitability? Shocks, Challenges and Perspectives for Euro Area Banks, The European Journal of Finance, 29(1): 54-78.

37. Choi, J.J., E. Elyasiani and K. Kopecky, 1992, The Sensitivity of Bank Stock Returns to Market, Interest Rate and Exchange Rate Risks, Journal of Banking & Finance, 16(5): 983-1004.

38. Claessens, S., A. Demirgüç-Kunt and H. Huizinga, 2001, How Does Foreign Entry Affect Domestic Banking Markets?, Journal of Banking & Finance, 25(5): 891-911.

39. Clarke, G.R.G., R. Cull and M.S. Martinez Peria, 2001, Does Foreign Bank Penetration Reduce Access to Credit in Developing Countries? Evidence from Asking Borrowers, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 2716.

40. Cooper, M.J., W.E. Jackson and G.A. Patterson, 2003, Evidence of Predictability in the Cross-Section of Bank Stock Returns, Journal of Banking & Finance, 27(5): 817-850.

41. De Haas, R. and I. Naaborg, 2005a, Does Foreign Bank Entry Reduce Small Firms' Access to Credit? Evidence from European Transition Economies, De Nederlandsche Bank Working Paper No. 50.

42. , 2005b, Internal Capital Markets in Multinational Banks: Implications for European Transition Countries, De Nederlandsche Bank Working Paper No. 51.

43. , 2006, Foreign Banks in Transition Countries: To Whom Do They Lend and How Are They Financed?, Financial Markets, Institutions & Instruments, 15(4): 159-199.

44. De Haas, R. and I. van Lelyveld, 2006, Foreign Banks and Credit Stability in Central and Eastern Europe. A Panel Data Analysis, Journal of Banking & Finance, 30(7): 1927-1952.

45. , 2010, Internal Capital Markets and Lending by Multinational Bank Subsidiaries, Journal of Financial Intermediation, 19(1): 1-25.

46. , 2014, Multinational Banks and the Global Financial Crisis: Weathering the Perfect Storm?, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 46(s1): 333-364.

47. Demirgüç-Kunt, A. and E. Detragiache, 1998, Financial Liberalization and Financial Fragility, IMF Working Paper No. 98/83.

48. Demirgüç-Kunt, A., R. Levine and H.G. Min, 1998, Opening to Foreign Banks: Issues of Stability, Efficiency and Growth, in A. Meltzer (ed.), The Implications of. Globalization of World Financial Market, Bank of Korea, Seoul, Korea.

49. Demirgüç-Kunt, A. and H. Huizinga, 1999, Determinants of Commercial Bank Interest Margins and Profitability: Some International Evidence, World Bank Economic Review, 13(2): 379-408.

50. Denizer, C., 2000, Foreign Entry in Turkey's Banking Sector, 1980-97, World Bank Policy Research Working Papers No. 2462.

51. Dietrich, A. and G. Wanzenried, 2011, Determinants of Bank Profitability before and during the Crisis: Evidence from Switzerland, Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions & Money, 21(3): 307-327.

52. Drakos, K., 2002, The Efficiency of the Banking Sector in Central and Eastern Europe, Russian and East European Finance and Trade, 38(2): 31-43.

53. Duca, J.V. and M.M. McLaughlin, 1990, Developments Affecting the Profitability of Commercial Banks, Federal Reserve Bulletin, 76(7): 477-499.

54. ECB, 2010, Beyond ROE – How to Measure Bank Performance, Appendix to the Report on EU Banking Structures.

55. Ekinci, A., 2016, The Effect of Credit and Market Risk on Bank Performance: Evidence from Turkey, International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 6(2): 427-434.

56. Erdem, Ş., 2010, Turkish Banking System in the Face of the Global Crisis, International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 3(4): 351-362.

57. Flamini, V., C. McDonald and L. Schumacher, 2009, The Determinants of Commercial Bank Profitability in Sub-Saharan Africa, IMF Working Paper No. 09/15.

58. Forbes, K. J. and F.E. Warnock, 2012, Capital Flow Waves: Surges, Stops, Flight, and Retrenchment, Journal of International Economics, 88(2): 235- 251.

59. Fratzscher, M., 2012, Capital Flows, Push versus Pull Factors and the Global Financial Crisis, Journal of International Economics, 88(2): 341-356.

60. Fries, S. and A. Taci, 2005, Cost Efficiency of Banks in Transition: Evidence from 289 Banks in 15 Post-Communist Countries, Journal of Banking & Finance, 29(1): 55-81.

61. Fungáčová, Z. and T. Poghosyan, 2011, Determinants of Bank Interest Margins in Russia: Does Bank Ownership Matter?, Economic Systems, 35(4): 481- 495.

62. Ganioğlu, A. and V. Us, 2014, The Structure of the Turkish Banking Sector before and after the Global Crisis, CBRT Working Paper No. 14/29.

63. García-Herrero, A., S. Gavilá and D. Santabárbara, 2009, What Explains the Low Profitability of Chinese Banks?, Journal of Banking & Finance, 33 (11): 2080-2092.

64. Genay, H. and R. Podjasek, 2014, What is the Impact of a Low Interest Rate Environment on Bank Profitability?, Chicago Fed Letter No. 324

65. Giannetti, M. and S. Ongena, 2005, Financial Integration and Entrepreneurial Activity: Evidence from Foreign Bank Entry in Emerging Markets, European Central Bank Working Paper Series No. 498.

66. Goddard, J., P. Molyneux and J.O.S. Wilson, 2004, Dynamics of Growth and Profitability in Banking, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 36(6): 1069- 1090.

67. Golin, J., 2001, The Bank Credit Analysis Handbook: A Guide for Analysts, Bankers and Investors, Wiley, New York, NY, USA.

68. Gorton, G. and A. Winton, 1998, Banking in Transition Economies: Does Efficiency Require Instability?, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 30(3): 621-650.

69. Guru, B., J. Staunton and B. Balashanmugam, 2002, Determinants of Commercial Bank Profitability in Malaysia, Paper presented at the 12th Annual Australian Finance and Banking Conference, Sydney, Australia, 16-17 December 2002.

70. Hanson, J. and R. Rocha, 1986, High Interest Rates, Spreads and the Cost of Intermediation: Two Studies, The World Bank Industry and Finance Series No. 18.

71. Hasan, I. and K. Marton, 2003, Development and Efficiency of the Banking Sector in a Transitional Economy: Hungarian Experience, Journal of Banking & Finance, 27(12): 2249-2271.

72. Hausman, J.A., 1978, Specification Tests in Econometrics, Econometrica, 46(6): 1251-1271.

73. Havrylchyk, O. and E.M. Jurzyk, 2011, Profitability of Foreign Banks in Central and Eastern Europe, Economics of Transition, 19(3): 443-472.

74. He, L.T., A. Fayman and K.M. Casey, 2014, Bank Profitability: The Impact of Foreign Currency Fluctuations, Journal of Applied Business and Economics, 16(2): 98-104.

75. Heffernan, S., 1996, Modern Banking in Theory and Practice, Wiley, Chichester, England. 76. Hsiao, C., 2003, Analysis of Panel Data, Cambridge University Press, New York, NY, USA.

77. 78. vix-index.



81. Huang, R. and L. Ratnovsky, 2011, The Dark Side of Bank Wholesale Funding, Journal of Financial Intermediation, 20(2): 248-263.

82. Jeon, Y., S.M. Miller and P.A. Natke, 2006, Do Foreign Bank Operations Provide a Stabilizing Influence in Korea?, The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 46(1): 82-109.

83. Kohlscheen, E., A. Murcia and J. Contreras, 2018, Determinants of Bank Profitability in Emerging Markets, BIS Working Papers No. 686.

84. Kolapo, T.F., R.K. Ayeni and M.O. Oke, 2012, Credit Risk and Commercial Banks’ Performance in Nigeria: A Panel Model Approach, Australian Journal of Business and Management Research, 2(02): 31-38.

85. Kosmidou, K., 2008, The Determinants of Banks' Profits in Greece during the Period of EU Financial Integration, Managerial Finance, 34(3): 146-159.

86. Košak, M. and M. Čok, 2008, Ownership Structure and Profitability of the Banking Sector: The Evidence from the SEE Region, Proceedings of Rijeka Faculty of Economics, Journal of Economics and Business, 26(1): 93-122.

87. Köse, A., 2009, Foreign Bank Presence and Domestic Bank Performance in Turkish Banking System, Yönetim, 20(63): 8-24.

88. Kutan, A., E. Rengifo and E. Özsöz, 2010, Evaluating the Effects of Deposit Dollarization in Bank Profitability, Fordham University Discussion Paper No. 07.

89. Kutan, A., E. Özsöz and E. Rengifo, 2012, Cross-Sectional Determinants of Bank Performance under Deposit Dollarization in Emerging Markets, Emerging Markets Review, 13(4): 478-492.

90. Lensink, R. and N. Hermes, 2004, The Impact of Foreign Bank Entry on Domestic Banks: Does Economic Development Matter?, Journal of Banking & Finance, 28(3): 553-568.

91. Levine, R., 1996, Foreign Banks, Financial Development and Economic Growth, in C.E. Barfield (ed.), International Financial Markets: Harmonization versus Competition, AEI Press, Washington, DC, USA.

92. Lin, X. and Y. Zhang, 2009, Bank Ownership Reform and Bank Performance in China, Journal of Banking & Finance, 33(1): 20-29.

93. Martinez Peria, M.S. and A. Mody, 2004, How Foreign Participation and Market Concentration Impact Bank Spreads: Evidence from Latin America, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 36(3): 511-537.

94. Martinho, R., J. Oliveria and V. Oliveria, 2017, Bank Profitability and Macroeconomic Factors, Banco de Portugal Financial Stability Papers No. 5.

95. Metin-Özcan, K. and N.S. Kafalı, 2007, The Structure of the Turkish Banking Sector after the 2000-2001 Crisis: An Empirical Investigation, Economic Research Forum Working Paper No. 07/09.

96. Molyneux, P. and J. Thornton, 1992, Determinants of European Bank Profitability: A Note, Journal of Banking & Finance, 16(6): 1173-1178.

97. Nakane, M. and D. Weintraub, 2005, Bank Privatization and Productivity: Evidence for Brazil, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper Series No. 3666.

98. Ongena, S., A. Popov and G.F. Udell, 2013, “When the Cat’s away the Mice Will Play”: Does Regulation at Home Affect Bank Risk-Raking Abroad?, Journal of Financial Economics, 108(3): 727-750.

99. Pasiouras, F. and K. Kosmidou, 2007, Factors Influencing the Profitability of Domestic and Foreign Commercial Banks in the European Union, Research in International Business and Finance, 21(2): 222-237.

100.Poghosyan, T. and J. Borovicka, 2007, Banking Efficiency in Emerging Economies: The Impact of Ownership Endogeneity and EU Accession, CERGE-EI Discussion Paper No. 189.

101.Poudel, R.P.S., 2012, The Impact of Credit Risk Management on Financial Performance of Commercial Banks in Nepal, International Journal of Arts and Commerce, 1(5):9-15.

102.Reinhardt, D. and S.J. Riddiough, 2015, The Two Faces of Cross-Border Banking Flows, IMF Economic Review, 63(4): 751-791.

103.Rhoades, S.A., 1985, Market Share as a Source of Market Power: Implications and Some Evidence, Journal of Economics and Business, 37(4): 343- 363.

104.Schnabl, P., 2012, The International Transmission of Bank Liquidity Shocks: Evidence from an Emerging Market, The Journal of Finance, 67(3): 897-932.

105.Sengupta, R., 2007, Foreign Entry and Bank Competition, Journal of Financial Economics, 84(2): 502-528.

106.Smirlock, M., 1985, Evidence on the (Non)relationship between Concentration and Profitability in Banking, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, 17(1): 69-83.

107.Steinherr, A., A. Tükel and M. Üçer, 2004, The Turkish Banking Sector: Challenges and Outlook in Transition to EU Membership, Centre for European Policy Studies EU-Turkey Working Papers No. 4.

108.Stiroh, K. and A. Rumble, 2006, The Dark Side of Diversification: The Case of US Financial Holding Companies, Journal of Banking & Finance, 30(8): 2131-2161.

109.Sturm, J.E. and B. Williams, 2008, Characteristics Determining the Efficiency of Foreign Banks in Australia, Journal of Banking & Finance, 32(11): 2346- 2360.

110.Terrell, H., 1986, The Role of Foreign Banks in Domestic Banking Markets, in H.S. Cheng (ed.), Financial policy and reform in Pacific Basin countries, Lexington Books, Lexington, MA, USA.

111.Unite, A.A. and M.J. Sullivan, 2003, The Effect of Foreign Entry and Ownership Structure on the Philippine Domestic Banking Market, Journal of Banking & Finance, 27(12): 2323-2345.

112.Us, V., 2015a, Banking Sector Performance in Turkey before and after the Global Crisis, İktisat İşletme ve Finans, 30(353): 45-74.

113. , 2015b, The Turkish Banking Sector before and after the Global Crisis: An Ownership Breakdown, CBT Research Notes in Economics No. 15/02.

114. , 2015c, Do Banks Respond Asymmetrically to the Global Crisis? Evidence from Turkey, Journal of BRSA Banking and Financial Markets, 9(2): 9-44.

115.Uygur, E., 2010, The Global Crisis and the Turkish Economy, Third World Network Global Economy Series No. 21.

116.Van Rijckeghem, C., 1999, The Political Economy of Inflation: Are Turkish Banks Potential Losers From Stabilization?, Istanbul Stock Exchange Review, 3(10): 1-16.

117.Williams, B., 1997, Positive Theories of Multinational Banking: Eclectic Theo-ry versus Internalisation Theory, Journal of Economic Surveys, 11(1): 71-106.

118. , 1998a, A Pooled Study of the Profits and Size of Foreign Banks in Australia, Journal of Multinational Financial Management, 8(2-3): 211-231.

119. , 1998b, Factors Affecting the Performance of Foreign-Owned Banks in Australia: A Cross-Sectional Study, Journal of Banking & Finance, 22(2): 197-219.

120. , 2003, Domestic and International Determinants of Bank Profits: Foreign Banks in Australia, Journal of Banking & Finance, 27(6): 1185-1210.

121.Williams, J. and N. Nguyen, 2005, Financial Liberalisation, Crisis, and Restructuring: A Comparative Study of Bank Performance and Bank Governance in South East Asia, Journal of Banking & Finance, 29(8-9): 2119-2154.

122.Yörükoğlu, M. and H. Atasoy, 2010, The Effects of the Global Financial Crisis on the Turkish Financial Sector, BIS Papers No. 54.

Kaynak Göster