Reliability of assessment methods for scapular dyskinesis in asymptomatic subjects: A systematic review

Objective: The aim of this systematic review was to evaluate the available published evidence on the intra- and inter-rater reliabilities of assessment methods used for identifying and measuring scapular dyskinesis (SD) in asymptomatic subjects.Methods: A systematic electronic literature search was performed in PubMed, Physiotherapy Evidence Database, Scopus, and the Cochrane Library, and studies on the intra- and inter-rater reliabilities of physical examination tests used for identifying SD in asymptomatic people were identified. Methodological quality of the studies meeting the inclusion criteria was assessed using the Quality Appraisal of Reliability Studies (QAREL) checklist by two reviewers. The overall level of evidence of this systematic review was determined by the Modified Cochrane Back Pain Criteria based on previous research which was modified for reliability studies of the shoulder complex.Results: The literature search generated 388 results, and only 14 articles met the inclusion criteria. In these studies, reliabilities of two qualitative and five quantitative methods for the assessment of SD were analyzed. The QAREL checklist revealed that 12 studies had moderate risk of bias and 2 had high risk of bias. Additionally, none of the studies were of high quality. On the basis of the Modified Cochrane Back Pain Criteria, the overall level of evidence was moderate. Most of the studies including quantitative measurement methods found good to excellent inter- and intra-rater reliability values. Most of the studies including qualitative methods found low-to-moderate intra- and inter-rater reliability values.Conclusion: Considering the available published evidence, there is lack of high-quality studies evaluating the inter- and intra-rater reliabilities of qualitative or quantitative methods used for the assessment of SD. There are no qualitative methods with high reliability that are fit for clinical applications. Some quantitative methods with higher reliability are present, but clinicians should be aware of the methodological flaws that studies evaluating these methods suffer from.Level of Evidence: Level II, Diagnostic study

___

1. Postacchini R, Carbone S. Scapular dyskinesis: Diagnosis and treatment. OA Musculoskeletal Medicine 2013; 1: 20. [Crossref]

2. Kibler WB, Sciascia A. Current concepts: scapular dyskinesis. Br J Sports Med 2010; 44: 300-5. [Crossref]

3. Kibler WB, Ludewig PM, McClure PW, Michener LA, Bak K, Sciascia AD. Clinical implications of scapular dyskinesis in shoulder injury: The 2013 consensus statement from the ‘scapular summit’. Br J Sports Med 2013; 47: 877-85. [Crossref]

4. Hickey D, Solvig V, Cavalheri V, Harrold M, McKenna L. Scapular dyskinesis increases the risk of future shoulder pain by 43% in asymptomatic athletes: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med 2018; 52: 102-10. [Crossref]

5. Burn MB, McCulloch PC, Lintner DM, Liberman SR, Harris JD. Prevalence of Scapular Dyskinesis in Overhead and Nonoverhead Athletes:A Systematic Review. Orthop J Sports Med 2016; 4: doi: 10.1177/2325967115627608. [Crossref]

6. Kim SG. Correlation between Scapular Asymmetry and Differences in Left and Right Side Activity of Muscles Adjacent to the Scapula. Osong Public Health Res Perspect 2017; 8: 255-9. [Crossref]

7. Karagiannakis D, Athanasopoulos S, Mandalidis D. Scapular muscles’ activity in female volleyball players with scapular asymmetry in the resting position. J Bodyw Mov Ther 2018; 22: 580-5. [Crossref]

8. Timmons MK, Thigpen CA, Seitz AL, Karduna AR, Arnold BL, Michener LA. Scapular kinematics and subacromial-impingement syndrome: A meta-analysis. J Sport Rehabil 2012; 21: 354-70. [Crossref]

9. Moskal B, Leydens J. Scoring Rubric Development: Validity and Reliability 2000.

10. Rajasekar S, Bangera RK, Sekaran P. Inter-rater and intra-rater reliability of a movement control test in shoulder. J Body Mov Ther 2017; 21: 739-42. [Crossref]

11. Lange T, Struyf F, Schmitt J, Lutzner J, Kopkow C. The reliability of physical examination tests for the clinical assessment of scapular dyskinesis in subjects with shoulder complaints: A systematic review. Phys Ther Sport 2017; 26: 64- 89. [Crossref]

12. Struyf F, Nijs J, Mottram S, Roussel N, Cools A, Meeusen R. Clinical assessment of the scapula: A review of the literature. Br J Sports Med 2014; 48: 883- 90. [Crossref]

13. Attia AM. Bias in RCTs: Confounders, selection bias and allocation concealment 2005. 258-60 p.

14. Hawkins R. Online Bibliographic Search Strategy Development. Online 1982; 6: 12-9.

15. Lucas NP, Macaskill P, Irwig L, Bogduk N. The development of a quality appraisal tool for studies of diagnostic reliability (QAREL). J Clin Epidemiol 2010; 63: 854-61. [Crossref]

16. Konieczka C, Gibson C, Russett L, et al. What is the reliability of clinical measurement tests for humeral head position? A systematic review. J Hand Ther 2017; 30: 420-31. [Crossref]

17. Fleiss JL. Design and Analysis of Clinical Experiments (Wiley Classics Library). J Am Stat Assoc 1999; 94: 138. [Crossref]

18. Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 1977; 33: 159-74. [Crossref]

19. da Costa BR, Armijo-Olivo S, Gadotti I, Warren S, Reid DC, Magee DJ. Reliability of scapular positioning measurement procedure using the palpation meter (PALM). Physiotherapy 2010; 96: 59-67. [Crossref]

20. De Groef A, Van Kampen M, Vervloesem N, et al. Inter-rater reliability of shoulder measurements in middle-aged women. Physiotherapy 2017; 103: 222-30. [Crossref]

21. Du WY, Huang TS, Hsu KC, Lin JJ. Measurement of scapular medial border and inferior angle prominence using a novel scapulometer: A reliability and validity study. Musculoskelet Sci Pract 2017; 32: 120-6. [Crossref]

22. Ellenbecker TS, Kibler WB, Bailie DS, Caplinger R, Davies GJ, Riemann BL. Reliability of scapular classification in examination of professional baseball players. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2012; 470: 1540-4. [Crossref]

23. Hong J, Barnes MJ, Leddon CE, Van Ryssegem G, Alamar B. Reliability of the sitting hand press-up test for identifying and quantifying the level of scapular medial border posterior displacement in overhead athletes. Int J Sports Phys Ther 2011; 6: 306-11.

24. Madsen PH, Bak K, Jensen S, Welter U. Training induces scapular dyskinesis in pain-free competitive swimmers: A reliability and observational study. Clin J Sport Med 2011; 21: 109-13. [Crossref]

25. O’Connor S, McCaffrey N, Whyte E, Moran K. The Development and Reliability of a Simple Field-Based Screening Tool to Assess for Scapular Dyskinesis. J Sport Rehabil 2016; 25: 2015-0054. [Crossref]

26. Pontin JC, Stadniky SP, Suehara PT, Costa TR, Chamlian TR. Static evaluation of scapular positioning in healthy individuals. Acta Ortop Bras 2013; 21: 208-12. [Crossref]

27. Rossi DM, Pedroni CR, Martins J, de Oliveira AS. Intrarater and interrater reliability of three classifications for scapular dyskinesis in athletes. PLoS One 2017; 12: doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0181518. eCollection 2017. [Crossref]

28. Shadmehr A, Azarsa MH, Jalaie S. Inter- and intrarater reliability of modified lateral scapular slide test in healthy athletic men. Biomed Res Int 2014; 2014: 384149. [Crossref]

29. Struyf F, Nijs J, De Coninck K, Giunta M, Mottram S, Meeusen R. Clinical assessment of scapular positioning in musicians: an intertester reliability study. J Athl Train 2009; 44: 519-26. [Crossref]

30. Tucker WS, Ingram RL. Reliability and validity of measuring scapular upward rotation using an electrical inclinometer. J Electromyogr Kinesiol 2012; 22: 419-23. [Crossref]

31. Gibson MH, Goebel GV, Jordan TM, Kegerreis S, Worrell TW. A reliability study of measurement techniques to determine static scapular position. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 1995; 21: 100-6. [Crossref]

32. Plafcan DM, Turczany PJ, Guenin BA, Kegerreis S, Worrell TW. An objective measurement technique for posterior scapular displacement. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 1997; 25: 336-41. [Crossref]

33. van Tulder MW, Koes BW, Bouter LM. Conservative treatment of acute and chronic nonspecific low back pain. A systematic review of randomized controlled trials of the most common interventions. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 1997; 22: 2128-56. [Crossref]

34. Uhl TL, Kibler WB, Gecewich B, Tripp BL. Evaluation of clinical assessment methods for scapular dyskinesis. Arthroscopy 2009; 25: 1240-8. [Crossref]

35. Laenen A, Alonso A, Molenberghs G, Vangeneugden T. Accounting for the rater’s memory eect in reliability estimation 2019.

36. Wassinger CA, Williams DA, Milosavljevic S, Hegedus EJ. Clinical reliability and diagnostic accuracy of visual scapulohumeral movement evaluation in detecting patients with shoulder impairment. Int J Sports Phys Ther 2015; 10: 456-63.

37. Kibler WB, Uhl TL, Maddux JW, Brooks PV, Zeller B, McMullen J. Qualitative clinical evaluation of scapular dysfunction: A reliability study. J Shoulder Elbow Surg 2002; 11: 550-6. [Crossref]

38. Beck TW. The importance of a priori sample size estimation in strength and conditioning research. J Strength Cond Res 2013; 27: 2323-37. [Crossref]

39. Shoukri MM, Asyali MH, Donner A. Sample size requirements for the design of reliability study: review and new results. Stat Methods Med Res 2004; 13: 251-71. [Crossref]

40. Ortega FB, Artero EG, Ruiz JR, et al. Reliability of health-related physical fitness tests in European adolescents. The HELENA Study. Int J Obes 2008; 3: 49-57. [Crossref]

41. Giavarina D. Understanding Bland Altman analysis. Biochem Med 2015; 25: 141-51. [Crossref]

42. Huijbregts PA. Spinal motion palpation: A review of reliability studies. J Man Manip Ther 2002; 10: 24-39. [Crossref]

43. Jonsson A, Rasmussen-Barr E. Intra- and inter-rater reliability of movement and palpation tests in patients with neck pain: A systematic review. Physiother Theory Pract 2018; 34: 165-80. [Crossref]

44. Ellenbecker TS, Kibler WB, Bailie DS, Caplinger R, Davies GJ, Riemann BL. Reliability of scapular classification in examination of professional baseball players. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2012; 470 : 1540-4. [Crossref]

45. Host HH. Scapular taping in the treatment of anterior shoulder impingement. Phys Ther 1995; 75: 803-12. [Crossref]

46. Borstad JD, Ludewig PM. The effect of long versus short pectoralis minor resting length on scapular kinematics in healthy individuals. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2005; 35: 227-38. [Crossref]

47. Fitzpatrick R, Davey C, Buxton MJ, Jones DR. Evaluating patient-based outcome measures for use in clinical trials. Health Technol Assess 1998; 2. [Crossref]