A comparison of the effects of mirror therapy and phantom exercises on phantom limb pain
A comparison of the effects of mirror therapy and phantom exercises on phantom limb pain
Background/aim: Although mirror therapy (MT) and phantom exercises (PE) have been shown to reduce pain, the efficacy of thesemethods in terms of pain, quality of life (QoL), and psychological status (PS) has not been investigated and compared to date. The aimof this study was to determine whether there is any difference between MT and PE in the treatment of phantom limb pain (PLP).Materials and methods: Forty unilateral transtibial amputees (aged 18–45 years) participated in this study. The subjects were randomlydivided into ‘MT group’ and ‘PE group’. QoL was assessed using Short-Form 36 (SF-36), psychological status using the Beck depressioninventory (BDI), and pain intensity using a visual analog scale (VAS), before and at the end of the program, and on the 3rd and 6thmonths thereafter.Results: All assessments for all parameters improved significantly in both groups (P < 0.05). Comparison of the two groups revealed asignificant difference in changes for VAS and BDI in all measurements, and in pre- and posttreatment scores for all SF-36 parameters(except for Role-Emotional) in favor of the MT group (P < 0.05).Conclusion: While pain intensity decreased and QoL and PS improved in both the MT and PE groups, these improvements were greaterin the MT group.
___
- 1. Ephraim PL, Wegener ST, MacKenzie EJ, Dillingham TR, Pezzin
LE. Phantom pain, residual limb pain, and back pain in amputees:
results of a national survey. Archives of physical medicine and
rehabilitation 2005; 86: 1910-1919.
- 2. Flor H. Phantom-limb pain: characteristics, causes, and
treatment. The Lancet Neurology 2002; 1: 182-189.
- 3. Bosmans JC, Suurmeijer TP, Hulsink M, van der Schans CP,
Geertzen JH, Dijkstra PU. Amputation, phantom pain and
subjective well-being: a qualitative study. International Journal
of Rehabilitation Research 2007; 30: 1-8.
- 4. MacLachlan M, McDonald D, Waloch J. Mirror treatment
of lower limb phantom pain: a case study. Disability and
rehabilitation 2004; 26: 901-904.
- 5. Weinstein SM. Phantom limb pain and related disorders.
Neurologic clinics 1998; 16: 919-935.
- 6. Ramachandran VS, Hirstein W. The perception of phantom
limbs. The DO Hebb lecture. Brain 1998; 121: 1603-1630.
- 7. Nikolajsen L, Finnerup NB, Kramp S, Vimtrup A-S, Keller J,
Jensen TS. A randomized study of the effects of gabapentin on
postamputation pain. The Journal of the American Society of
Anesthesiologists 2006; 105: 1008-1015.
- 8. Houghton A, Nicholls G, Houghton A, Saadah E, McColl L.
Phantom pain: natural history and association with rehabilitation.
Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England 1994; 76: 22.
- 9. Jones L, Davidson J. The long-term outcome of upper limb
amputees treated at a rehabilitation centre in Sydney, Australia.
Disability and rehabilitation 1995; 17: 437-442.
- 10. Pohjolainen T. A clinical evaluation of stumps in lower limb
amputees. Prosthetics and orthotics international 1991; 15: 178-
184.
- 11. Montoya P, Larbig W, Grulke N, Flor H, Taub E, Birbaumer N.
The relationship of phantom limb pain to other phantom limb
phenomena in upper extremity amputees. Pain 1997; 72: 87-93.
- 12. Wilkins KL, McGrath PJ, Finley GA, Katz J. Phantom limb
sensations and phantom limb pain in child and adolescent
amputees. Pain 1998; 78: 7-12.
- 13. Kooijman CM, Dijkstra PU, Geertzen JH, Elzinga A, van der
Schans CP. Phantom pain and phantom sensations in upper
limb amputees: an epidemiological study. Pain 2000; 87: 33-41.
- 14. Darnall BD, Li H. Home-based self-delivered mirror therapy
for phantom pain: a pilot study. Journal of rehabilitation
medicine 2012; 44: 254-260.
- 15. Foell J, Bekrater-Bodmann R, Flor H, Cole J. Phantom limb
pain after lower limb trauma: origins and treatments. The
international journal of lower extremity wounds 2011; 10: 224-
235.
- 16. Hanling SR, Wallace SC, Hollenbeck KJ, Belnap BD, Tulis MR.
Preamputation mirror therapy may prevent development of
phantom limb pain: a case series. Anesthesia & Analgesia 2010;
110: 611-614.
- 17. Hsu E, Cohen SP. Postamputation pain: epidemiology,
mechanisms, and treatment. J Pain Res 2013; 6: 121-136.
- 18. McCormick Z, Chang‐Chien G, Marshall B, Huang M, Harden
RN. Phantom limb pain: a systematic neuroanatomical‐based
review of pharmacologic treatment. Pain Medicine 2014; 15:
292-305.
- 19. Ramachandran VS, Rogers-Ramachandran D. Synaesthesia in
phantom limbs induced with mirrors. Proceedings of the Royal
Society of London B: Biological Sciences 1996; 263: 377-386.
- 20. Weeks SR, Anderson-Barnes VC, Tsao JW. Phantom limb pain:
theories and therapies. The neurologist 2010; 16: 277-286.
- 21. Chan BL, Witt R, Charrow AP, Magee A, Howard R, Pasquina
PF, Heilman KM, Tsao JW. Mirror therapy for phantom limb
pain. New England Journal of Medicine 2007; 357: 2206-2207.
- 22. Cacchio A, De Blasis E, De Blasis V, Santilli V, Spacca G. Mirror
therapy in complex regional pain syndrome type 1 of the upper
limb in stroke patients. Neurorehabilitation and neural repair
2009.
- 23. Foell J, Bekrater‐Bodmann R, Diers M, Flor H. Mirror therapy
for phantom limb pain: brain changes and the role of body
representation. European journal of pain 2014; 18: 729-739.
- 24. Ülger Ö, Topuz S, Bayramlar K, Şener G, Erbahçeci F.
Effectiveness of phantom exercises for phantom limb pain: a
pilot study. Journal of rehabilitation medicine 2009; 41: 582-
584.
- 25. MacIver K, Lloyd D, Kelly S, Roberts N, Nurmikko T. Phantom
limb pain, cortical reorganization and the therapeutic effect of
mental imagery. Brain 2008; 131: 2181-2191.
- 26. Whyte AS and Niven CA. Variation in phantom limb
pain: results of a diary study. Journal of pain and symptom
management 2001; 22: 947-953.
- 27. van der Schans CP, Geertzen JH, Schoppen T, Dijkstra PU.
Phantom pain and health-related quality of life in lower limb
amputees. Journal of pain and symptom management 2002; 24:
429-436.
- 28. Kocyigit H, Aydemir O, Ölmez N, Memis A. Reliability and
validity of the Turkish version of Short-Form-36 (SF-36).
Turkish J Drugs Therap 1999; 12: 102-106.
- 29. Geisser ME, Roth RS, Robinson ME. Assessing depression
among persons with chronic pain using the Center for
Epidemiological Studies-Depression Scale and the Beck
Depression Inventory: a comparative analysis. The Clinical
journal of pain 1997; 13: 163-170.
- 30. Hisli N. Beck Depresyon Envanteri’nin geçerliği üzerine bir
çalışma. Psikoloji Dergisi 1998; 6:118-126 (In Turkish).
- 31. Ramachandran VS. Behavioral and magnetoencephalographic
correlates of plasticity in the adult human brain. Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of
America 1993; 90: 10413.
- 32. Barbin J, Seetha V, Casillas JM, Paysant J, Pérennou D. The
effects of mirror therapy on pain and motor control of phantom
limb in amputees: a systematic review. Annal of Physical and
Rehabilitation Medicine 2016; 59: 270-275.
- 33. Darnall BD. Self-delivered home-based mirror therapy for lower
limb phantom pain. American journal of physical medicine &
rehabilitation/Association of Academic Physiatrists 2009; 88:
78.
- 34. Ramachandran VS, Brang D, McGeoch PD. Size reduction
using mirror visual feedback (MVF) reduces phantom pain.
Neurocase 2009; 15: 357-360.
- 35. Moseley GL. Graded motor imagery for pathologic pain: a
randomized controlled trial. Neurology 2006; 67: 2129-2134.
- 36. Brodie EE, Whyte A, Waller B. Increased motor control of a
phantom leg in humans results from the visual feedback of a
virtual leg. Neuroscience letters 2003; 341: 167-169.
- 37. Brodie EE, Whyte A, Niven CA. Analgesia through the looking‐
glass? A randomized controlled trial investigating the effect of
viewing a ‘virtual’limb upon phantom limb pain, sensation and
movement. European Journal of Pain 2007; 11: 428-436.
- 38. Brunelli S, Morone G, Iosa M, Ciotti C, De Giorgi R, Foti C,
Traballesi M. Efficacy of progressive muscle relaxation, mental
imagery, and phantom exercise training on phantom limb: a
randomized controlled trial. Archives of physical medicine and
rehabilitation 2015; 96: 181-187.
- 39. Sinha R, van den Heuvel WJ, Arokiasamy P. Factors affecting
quality of life in lower limb amputees. Prosthetics and orthotics
international 2011; 35: 90-96.
- 40. McCartney C, Charles D, Cooper G, Chambers W, Smith
W. Pain and disability following lower limb amputation-a
quantitative and qualitative study. Pain Clinic 1999; 11: 293-
300.
- 41. Houston H, Dickerson AE. Improving functional outcomes
for vascular amputees through use of mirror therapy
and elimination of the effects of electromagnetic fields.
Occupational therapy in health care 2016; 30: 1-15.
- 42. Asano M, Rushton P, Miller WC, Deathe BA. Predictors
of quality of life among individuals who have a lower limb
amputation. Prosthetics and orthotics international 2008; 32:
231-243.