MULTİDİSİPLİNER BİR YAKLAŞIM: BİLGİSAYARLI TOMOGRAFİK TARAMA ve İLİŞKİLİ İNCELEME TEKNİKLERİNİN ÇALGI BİLİM ÇALIŞMALARINDA KULLANIMI

Bu makale öncelikle tıp dünyasında insan bedeni üzerindeki kullanımıyla ortaya çıkan ancak daha sonra antropolojik ya da paleontolojik materyalleri incelemeye ilişkin özel bir çalışma alanı haline gelen paleoradyoloji ile bilgisayarlı tomografik tarama teknolojisini ve söz konusu teknoloji ile bağlantılı şekilde çalgı bilim alanında uygulanmakta olan belirli analiz tekniklerini yurt dışı çalışmalardan örnekler sunarak incelenmeyi konu almaktadır. İnceleme kapsamında adı geçen tekniğin kullanımı aracılığıyla gerçekleştirilen 17 adet çalgı bilim çalışması taranmış, söz konusu çalışmalardan proje ismi Strad 3D ve yayın ismi The Girolamo Amati Viola in the Galleria Estense olan ikisine satın alma yolu ile, diğerlerine ise hali hazırda paylaşıma sunulmuş olan internet siteleri üzerinden 20.11.2015-10.12.2015 tarihleri arasında yapılan taramalarla ulaşılmıştır. Makalenin sunduğu incelemenin, söz konusu alanda günümüze kadar ortaya konmuş olan tüm çalışmaları içermek gibi bir hedefi yoktur. Ancak yayın dili İngilizce olan araştırmaların tümü çalışma kapsamına alınmış ve araştırma sürecinde bilgisayarlı tomografi tekniğinin kullanılmış olması gibi ortak bir noktadan hareketle söz konusu yayınlar, bu teknik ve ilişkili tetkik yöntemlerinin çalgı bilim alanındaki genel kullanımında "hangi bilginin" elde edilmesine hizmet ettiğine ilişkin bir soru çerçevesinde incelemeye alınmıştır. Bununla birlikte "karşılaştırma çalışmaları" ve "envanter çalışmaları" şeklinde sunulan iki alt başlık, bilgisayarlı tomografi taraması ve ilişkili inceleme yöntemleri ile elde edilen bilgiden nasıl yararlanıldığı ya da bu bilgi sayesinde çalgı bilim alanına "nasıl" bir katkı sağlandığı sorularını cevaplama yönü ile diğer alt başlıklara göre farklı bir nitelik taşımaktadır

AN INTERDISCIPLINARY ORIENTATION: USAGE OF COMPUTERIZED TOMOGRAPHICAL SCANNING AND RELATED ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES IN ORGANOLOGY STUDIES

This article aims on analysing the computed tomography scanning technology and certain related analysis techniques applied in the field of organology next to paleoradiology which was initially developed with its use on human body in the world of medicine but later became a special field of research on the examination of the anthropological or paleontological materials presenting examples from the studies abroad. 17 organology studies performed with the above-mentioned technique were scanned, the studies called Strad 3D and The Girolamo Amati Viola in the Galleria Estense were bought and the rest were reached by the browsing the web-sites where they were shared between the dates 20.11.2015-10.12.2015. The review presented in this article doesn’t intent to contain all of the studies performed up until today. However, all the studies published in English were included and departing from the common point where computed tomography technique was used in the process of all the researches, these works were examined in terms of the question of “which information” was tried to be obtained by the general use of this technique and the related analysis methods in the field of organology. In addition to this, the two sub-titles presented as “comparative works” and “inventory works” have a different quality compared to the other subtitles with their potential to answer the questions “how the information obtained from computed tomography and related analysis methods” and “what kind of contribution does this information provide for the field of organology?” This article aims on analysing the computerized tomography scanning technology and certain related analysis techniques applied in the field of organology next to paleoradiology which was initially developed with its use on human body in the world of medicine but later became a special field of research on the examination of the anthropological or paleontological materials presenting examples from the studies abroad. 17 organology studies performed with the abovementioned technique were scanned, the studies called Strad 3D and The Girolamo Amati Viola in the Galleria Estense were bought and the rest were reached by the browsing the web-sites where they were shared between the dates 20.11.2015-10.12.2015. The review presented in this article doesn’t intent to contain all of the studies performed up until today. However, all the studies published in English were included and departing from the common point where computerized tomography technique was used in the process of all the researches, these works were examined in terms of the question of “which information” was tried to be obtained by the general use of this technique and the related analysis methods in the field of organology. In addition to this, the two sub-titles presented as “comparative works” and “inventory works” have a different quality compared to the other subtitles with their potential to answer the questions “how the information obtained from computerized tomography and related analysis methods” and “what kind of contribution does this information provide for the field of organology?”. In the article, the Turkish equivalents “önel”, “yanal” and “eksenel” were preferred to use instead of the foreign terms of “coronal”, “sagittal” and “axial” referring to the screening planes of the results obtained through the computerized tomographic scanning device. As the result of the research a similarity was seen between the use of the computerized tomography on human body and on the instruments in terms of general topics. The fact that the image creates results dependent on the energy absorption amount and physical qualities of the scanned is the main reason of this situation whether the scanned is an animate or inanimate object. The CT hardware consists of an X-ray tube positioned correlatively around the area where the table that the scanned object is placed on moves and a sensor system identifying the X-rays reaching to it by passing the scanned object. As a practical description, the difference between the X-ray energy amount sent for the scan and the energy amount reaching the sensor after passing through the scanned object indicates the energy amount absorbed by the scanned object, thus its density information. Various human body contents like water, blood, soft tissue and bone that differ in terms of density values form digital cross-sectional images coded with shades of grey specific to their unique features between the maximum and minimum density levels assigned for water and air. Thus they get their equivalents on the Hounsfield scale. Similarly, the varying density levels of the materials like wood or glue that are used in instrument making change the energy absorption amount and make them visible and searchable together with their qualities that enable to make comparisons with each other just like the human body parts. The facts that the image is obtained “in a very short time” and “without any interference to the current structure” of the scanned object are the qualities that make the computerized tomography technology important in term of restoration and inventory works. These two features are the most important factors having a role in the so-called technology and the related analysis methods’ becoming widespread whether in medical use or in the scanning of the objects with culturally and economically high values. Another feature that makes computerized tomography advantaged in comparison to the classical Xray analysis and wide-spreading is the fact that this technology allows to get non-overlapping cross-sectional images easily. The cross-sectional images obtained from three planes called “önel”, “yanal” and “eksenel” with the Turkish equivalents used in this article made it possible to analyse the old artefacts with high cultural and economic values and to obtain “new” data apart from the medical use. It is seen that this valuable contribution isn’t ignored in terms of the organological studies “abroad” and many new publications were added to the literature. The table above will show the types and distribution range of the analysis methods that came along with the so-called technology and found their place in organological studies within the scope of the publications reviewed through this research more clearly. bbreviations used in the table: R.D : Resource and date. A.S : Acoustic studies. S. H/E : Studies to obtain data on height/ elevation. S.T : Studies to obtain data on thickness. S.D. : Studies to obtain data on density. D.S. : Dendrology studies. C.S. : Copying studies. Comp. S. : Comparative studies. I.S. : Inventory studies. D.S. : Damage assessment studies. S.I.V.V. : Studies to obtain corpus volume values. 3-D.I.S. : 3-d axial image studies. F.C.S. : Fingerprint creating studies. The table above shows that the computerized tomography technology is used in organological studies manly to “obtain data on thickness and density”, to “asses damage” and to “compare instruments”. In addition to this we have to mention that this table and the preferred categorisation has a “limited” power of expression in terms of analysing the situation. For instance all the studies covered in this research serve indirectly to recording the structural features of the analysed instruments and creation of a general information pool even if their main goal isn’t to form an inventory. Similarly, as the computerized tomography scanning is a technology allowing to get cross-sectional images, it is possible to suppose that there are the cross-sectional images available for all the analysed instruments. However, associatively to the “aim” of the study, is seen that these images aren’t presented in the publishing process. Also, the “ultimate” aim of all these studies can be regarded as reaching data concerning the acoustic features of the instruments. In order to overcome this difficulty seen in categorisation, the reviewed studies were evaluated according to the “prior aims” mentioned in the abstracts and Borman’s study which is already a review isn’t included to the table in this article. The studies with the same author and publishing date are given in bibliographic order. In conclusion, it is seen that computerized tomography scanning studies have continued with new projects on morphological analysis of the Italian origin instruments with historical and economical values following the emerge of the so-called technology. When the publications covered in the article are evaluated it attracts the attention that researchers from different disciplines like radiology, software, biomedical engineering collaborate in the organology research groups. Forming the same collaboration and creating similar projects in our country will contribute immensely to the young generation who deals with organology or the art of instrument making to obtain concrete analysis material, to increase the rivalry power of the individuals working in the field when compared to the colleagues active abroad, to increase the cultural awareness and to create the tangible historical reference necessary to talk about an instrument making “tradition” in our country.

___

  • Bissinger, George. v.d., (2007) “A Special Report: Thoroughly Modern Modal Meets Three Old
  • Italian Master Violins”, Journal of Violin Society of America, cilt. XXI, no.1. s.s. 213-222.
  • Borman, Terry, (2009). “Review of the Uses of Computed Tomography for Analysing Instruments
  • of the Violin Family with a Focus on the Future”, Journal of Violin Society of America, VSA Papers, cilt. XXII, no.1, s.s. 1-12. Borman, T., Stoel B.C., (2011). “CT And Modal Analysis of the ‘Vieuxtemps’ Guarneri Del Gesu”, The Strad, s.s. 68-71.
  • Cavka, Mislav, Petaros A., Kavur L., Skirln J., Minaric Missoni E., Jankovic I., Brkljacic B. (2013).
  • “The Use of Paleo Microbiological Testing in The Analysis of Antique Coltural Material:
  • Multislice Computer Tomography, Mammography, and Microbial Analysis of the Trogir Cathedral Cope Hood Depicting St. Martin and a Beggar”, Acta Med History Adriatica, vol.
  • Multidisipliner Bir Yaklaşım: Bilgisayarlı Tomografik Tarama ve İlişkili İnceleme… 917 Turkish Studies
  • International Periodical for the Languages, Literature and History of Turkish or Turkic Volume 11/2 Winter 2016 11, no. 1, s.s. 45-54.
  • Fairbairn, I. (1981). “X-ray Scanning of Violins”, The Strad, cilt. 91, s.s. 889-891. Falke, T.H., Zweypfenning-Snijders M.C., Zweypfenning R.C. (1987). “Computed Tomography of An Ancient Egyptian Cat”, Journal of Computed Assist Tomography, cilt. 11, s.s. 745-747.
  • Fioravanti, M., Rognoni Rossi G., Gallerini P., Biagiotti S., Ricci R., Menchi I., (2014). “The Application of X-Ray CT Scanner to the Documentation of Early Musical Instruments”,
  • Multidisciplinary Approach to Wooden Musical Instrument Identification, Wood MusICKCOST,
  • Cremona. Gattoni, F., C. Melgara, C. Sciola, and C.M. (1999). “Unusual application of computerized tomography: The study of musical instruments”, Radiology, cilt. 97, no. 3, s.s. 170-173.
  • Harwood, Nash DCF. (1979). “Computed Tomography of Ancient Egyptian Mummies”, Journal of Computed Assist Tomography, cilt. 3, s.s. 768-773.
  • Hoffman, H., Torres William E., Ernst Randy D. (2002). “Paleoradiology: Advanced CT in the Evaluation of Nine Egyptian Mummies”, RadioGraphics, cilt. 22, no. 2, s.s. 377-385. http://smithsonianscience.si.edu/2009/11/digital-stradivari-computer-models-of-violinsreveal-the-master-luthiers-secrets/ 21.12.2015, Pazartesi 10.00.
  • http://www.trioviolinproject.com/commentary/2014/3/14/corpus-volume-profile-curves, 8.12.2015.
  • Kaplan, Ayten, (2005). Kültürel Müzikoloji, Bağlam Yayınları, İstanbul. Loen, S. Jeffry, Borman M. Terry, King T. Alvin, (2005). “Path Through the Woods”, The Strad, September, s.s. 68-75.
  • Marx, M, D’Auria SH. (1988) “Three-Dimensional CT Reconstructions of Ancient Human Egyptian Mummy”, American Journal of Roentgenology, cilt. 150, s.s. 147-149. Mazansky, C. (1993). “CT In the Study of Antiquities: Analysis of A Basket-Hilted Sword Relic
  • from a 400-years-old Shipwreck”, Radiology, cilt. 186 (3), s.s. 55-61. Notman, D., Tashijan J., Aufderheide A.C. (1986). “Modern Imaging and Endoscopic Biopsy
  • Techniques in Egyptian Mummies”, American Journal of Roentgenology, cilt. 146, s.s. 93- 96.
  • Scrollavezza, & Zanre – Jan Röhrmann. (2014). Treasures of Italian Violin Making, The Girolamo Amati Viola in the Galleria Estense, Pubbliprint Grafica, Parma. Sirr, S.A., Waddle JR. (1989). “Scroll of A Cello”, Radiology, cilt. 173(2), s.s. 446. Sirr, S.A., Waddle J.R. (1997). “CT analysis of bowed stringed instruments”, Radiology, cilt. 203,
  • s.s. 801-805. Sirr, S.A., Waddle J.R., (1999). “Use of CT in detection of internal damage and repair and
  • determination of authenticity in high-quality bowed stringed instruments”, Radiography-ics, cilt. 19, no. 3, s.s. 639-646. Sirr, S.A., Waddle J.R., (1999). “Computed tomography of humans and bowed stringed instruments. Some interesting similarities”, Minn. Med., cilt. 82, no. 0, s.s. 51-53. Sirr, S.A., Waddle J.R., (2009). “X-ray CT Measurements of the Internal Corpus Volume and a New 918 Murat KÜÇÜKEBE
  • Turkish Studies International Periodical for the Languages, Literature and History of Turkish or Turkic Volume 11/2 Winter 2016 Soundpost-Corpus Volume Relationship for Stringed Instruments of the Violin Family”, Journal of Violin Society of America, cilt. XXII, no.1. s.s. 1-12. Sirr, S.A., Waddle J.R., (2014) “Normal Age Related Distortional Changes of Bowed Stringed Instruments”, Journal of Violin Society of America, cilt. XXIV, no. 2. s. 189-196. Sırr, S.A., Waddle J.R., (2014). “Thin-Section X-Ray CT “Dissection” of Front and Back Plates,
  • Fingerboards, and Corpus Volumes of 14 Cremonese Stringed Instruments: Density, Mass
  • Distribution, and “Balanced Chi” Relationships” Journal of Violin Society of America, cilt. XXIV, no.2. s.s. 170-188. Sirr, S.A., (2014). “Climate Conundrum”, The Strad, s.s. 61-63.
  • Stoel, B.C., Borman T.M., (2008) “A Comparison of Wood Density between Classical Cremonese and Modern Violins”, PLOS ONE, cilt. 3(7). Ulu, Mehmet Oğuz, (2008) “Parçacık Dedektörlerinin Tıpta Kullanımı”, Çukurova Üniversitesi Fen
  • Bilimleri Enstitüsü, Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, s.s. 32-33, Adana. Waddle, J. R., Sirr S. A., Loen S. J., King T. A. (2003). “CT Scan Cross-Profiles Through Cremonese Stringed Instruments”, Catgut Acoustical Society Journal, cilt. 4, no. 8. s.s. 25-31. Waddle, J. R., (2010). “The Progress of Progress”, The Strad, s.s. 56-61.