11. SINIF ÖĞRENCİLERİNİN BİLİŞSEL YAPILARINDAKİ DEĞİŞİMİN KELİME İLİŞKİLENDİRME TESTİ KULLANARAK İNCELENMESİ: KİMYASAL DENGE ÖRNEĞİ

Bilişsel yapılar, öğrenenlerin özel bir bilgi alanında ne bildiklerini değerlendirme fırsatı sunmaktadırlar. Bu yüzden, yeni bilginin yapılandırılmasını etkileyebilecek bilişsel yapıların tanımlanması ve öğretim ile bunların nasıl değiştiğinin incelenmesi önemlidir. Bu çalışmada 11. sınıf öğrencilerinin (15-16 yaş) kimyasal denge ünitesinin temel kavramlarına ilişkin bilişsel yapılarını ortaya çıkarmak ve bunların öğretim sonrası nasıl değiştiğini ortaya koymak amacıyla kelime ilişkilendirme testi kullanılmıştır. Bu amaç doğrultusunda, İzmir il merkezindeki bir ortaöğretim kurumundaki 11. sınıflardaki 30 öğrenci ile bir çalışma yürütülmüştür. Çalışmada veri toplama aracı olarak, 10 uyarıcı kelimeyi içeren kelime ilişkilendirme testi öğretim öncesi ve sonrası uygulanmıştır. Testte kullanılan uyarıcı kelimeler: "denge", "katalizör", "endotermik tepkime", "egzotermik tepkime", "basınç", "molar derişim", "tersinir tepkime", "maksimum düzensizlik", "ileri tepkime hızı", "geri tepkime hızı" dır. Verilerin analizinde, her bir uyarıcı kelimeye verilen cevaplar sayılmış, frekans tablosu hazırlanmış ve farklı kesme noktalarındaki zihin haritaları çizilmiştir. Çalışmanın sonuçları, öğrencilerin öğretim öncesi zihin haritalarında çoğunlukla denge kavramını terazi ve eşitlik gibi cevaplar ile fiziksel denge ile ilişkilendirme eğiliminde olduklarını göstermektedir. Aynı zamanda, öğretim öncesinde "maksimum düzensizlik" ve " tersinir tepkime" uyarıcı kelimelerinin zihin haritalarında yer almadığı, diğer uyarıcı kelimeler arasında da çok az bağlantının kurulabildiği saptanmıştır. Buna karşın öğretim sonrasında ise, öğrenciler denge kavramını kimyasal denge ile ilişkilendirebilmişler, tüm uyarıcı kelimler zihin haritalarında saptanabilmiş ve öğrencilerin uyarıcı kelimeler arasında daha fazla ilişki kurabildikleri saptanmıştır. Bu bulgular, 11. sınıf öğrencilerinin "kimyasal dengeye" yönelik bilişsel yapılarının öğretim sonrası olumlu yönde değiştiğini göstermektedir.

AN INVESTIGATION OF CHANGES IN THE COGNITIVE STRUCTURES OF 11TH GRADE STUDENTS USING THE WORD ASSOCIATION TEST: THE CASE OF CHEMICAL EQUILIBRIUM

Cognitive structures offer an opportunity to assess what learners know with respect to a particular area of knowledge. It is therefore important to identify the cognitive structures that may also influence the structuring of new knowledge and examine how these change with instruction. This study used the word association test to reveal the cognitive structures of 11th grade students in the context of the basic concepts taught in the unit on chemical equilibrium and to understand how these changed after the instruction. In line with this goal, a study was conducted with 30 students enrolled in the 11th grade of a secondary school in the city of Izmir. In collecting data for the study, an association test consisting of ten stimulus words was implemented before and after the instruction. The stimulus words used in the test were, "equilibrium", "catalyzer", "endothermic reaction", "exothermic reaction", "pressure", "molar concentration", "reversible reaction", "maximum disorder", "rate of forward reaction" and "rate of reverse reaction". In the analysis, responses for each stimulus word is counted, a frequencies table is prepared, and mind maps with different cut-off points were drawn up. The results of the study indicated that students were most likely to associate the concept of equilibrium with physical equilibrium in their mind maps before the instruction, responding with words such as "weighing scale" or "balance". At the same time, it was found that the stimulus words "maximum disorder" and "reverse reaction" did not appear in their mind maps and that the responses given to the other concept stimuli revealed very few associations between them before the instruction. Following the instruction however, the students were able to associate the concept of equilibrium with chemical equilibrium; all the stimulus words on the mental map were defined and it was seen that the students were able to form substantially moreassociations between the stimulus words. These findings show that the cognitive structures of the 11th grade students with respect to "chemical equilibrium" changed positively after the instruction. STRUCTURED ABSTRACT Introduction Learners’ cognitive structures has important role in the field of science and chemistry education with the effects of the constructivist learning approach. According to constructivist approach, it is important to know what students know when they come into the classroom to design effective learning environments (Siegler, 1998). For this reason, identifing leaners’ cognitive structures has great importance in the learning process. Thus, Nakiboğlu (2008) stated that cognive structures help educators to understand how the learners’ knowledge change during the learning process. There are many techniques have been used to identify learners’ cognitive structures such as concept maps, flow maps, structured grids, mind maps, and word association test (Kinchin and Hay, 2005; Novak and Gowin, 1984; Anderson and Demetrius, 1993; Tsai, 2001; Tsai and Huang, 2002, Dhindsa, Kasim and Anderson, 2011). Within these techniques, word association test (WAT) has been used by many researchers over the years (Cachapuz and Maskill, 1987; Johnstone and Moynihan, 1985; Kaya and Akış, 2015) . According to these studies, WAT is very useful to identify concepts, and relationship between these concepts in learners’ minds (Bahar, Johnstone and Sutcliffe, 1999; Bahar and Özatlı, 2003) . In chemistry education, WAT was used in many studies, however, there is still a need for studies invesitigating how learners’ cognitive stuctures change with the effects of the instruction. The Purpose of The Study The purpose of this study is to understand students' cognitive structures regarding the topic of chemical equilibrium by using word association test, and to identify how students' cognitive structures are affected by the instruction. In the line of this purpose, these questions were answered in the study:  What concepts did the students have in their cognitive structures about the basic concepts related to the unit on chemical equilibrium before the instruction?  Has there been a change in the students' cognitive structure regarding the basic concepts in the unit on chemical equilibrium after the instruction? If so, what kind of changes have there been. Methodology This research was based on one-group pre-test/post-test study. In this design, before instruction, the Word Association Test (WAT) was applied as a pre-test in the group, after the topic of chemical equilibrium began to be taught. The same test was employed as a post-test one week after the instruction. Sample The study sample included 30, 11th grade students who were studying in a secondary school in Izmir, Turkey. All students had volunteered to participate in the study, and they had similar backgrounds. The ages of the students ranged from 15 to 16 years. Instrument The data of this study was collected through a Word Association Test (WAT). WAT was administered as a pre-test and post-test to all groups. To conduct the WAT, ten key terms selected as cornerstones of chemical equilibrium were selected by the researchers. These key terms acted as stimuli. These were “equilibrium", "rate of forward reaction", "rate of reverse reaction", "catalyzer", "pressure", "molar concentration", "maximum disorder", "endothermic reaction", "exothermic reaction", "reversible reaction" Analysis In the analysis of WAT, three steps were followed. These are: 1. Analyzing the response words for each stimulus word 2. Counting the response words for each stimulus word and preparing a frequency table. 3. Drawing of mind maps. In the first stage, the researchers independently examined the responses to each stimulus word/phrase to check whether they were meaningful or not. After that, the Miles and Huberman (1994) formula was used to calculate the percentage of agreement for the responses. These percentages were respectively: equilibrium (93%), rate of forward reaction (90%), rate of reverse reaction (91%), catalyzer (91%), pressure (92%), molar concentration (92%), maximum disorder (94%), endothermic reaction (95%), exothermic reaction (92%), and reversible reaction (94%). In the second stage of the analysis, the responses included in the analysis for each stimulus word were counted and frequency tables were prepared. The third stage of the analysis included of mind maps that were drawn with using the frequencies of the response words to each of the stimulus words. Findings First research question in the study aims to reveal students’ cognitive structures regarding the basic concepts of chemical equilibrium before the instruction. With this aim, firstly, a frequency table was prepared for the responses to the stimulus words in the pre-test. After that, mind map with different cut-off point were drawn based on frequency table. According to first mind map displaying a cut-off point of 20 and above, students mostly associated the concept of equilibrium with a weighing scale and equality was based on their experiences in daily life. This result is striking in that it reveals the possible alternative conceptions that the students may have had. At the same time, in this mind map, some meaningful connections were determined. For example, molar concentration - mole, endothermic reaction - heat, endothermic reaction- enthalpy, exothermic reaction - heat, exothermic reaction and enthalpy are scientifically and correctly associated. In the second mind map with a cut-off point at 15-19, it was determined that the stimulus words did not change but that the responses to these increased. For example, the stimulus word response "cerebellum" appeared in this mind map. That the students formed an association between the concept of "equilibrium" and "cerebellum" is significant in that this indicates meaningful associations that they had carried with them from their biology lessons. Also, molar concentrationion, molar concentration –volume, pressure- volume and pressure- piston were evidence of the meaningful associations that the students could make. When third mind map for the cut-off point 10-14 was examined, it can be seen that two new stimulus words (rate of forward reaction" and "catalyzer) have been added as compared to first and second mind map. This showed that the students were able to form a two-way association between these concepts. . According to fourth mind map for the cut-off point 4-9, map, 8 of the 10 stimulus words have a place on this map. Differing from the other mind maps, the stimulus phrase "rate of reverse reaction" took its place on the map for the first time. When the students' responses to this stimulus phrase are examined, it can be seen that, just as in the responses to "rate of forward reaction," the same responses of "reaction" and "catalyzer" were given. The aim of second research problem in the study is to determine changes in change in the students' cognitive structures regarding the basic concepts in the unit on chemical equilibrium after the instruction. Similary to before instruction, mind map with with different cut-off point were drawn based on frequency table. In the first mind map for cut-off point 20 and above after instudction, it was seen that 6 stimulus words have found their place on this map. According to this mind map, the responses given to the concept of equilibrium, that is, "reaction," "products" and "equilibrium constant," show that the students' cognitive structures have changed and that what was perceived as physical equilibrium has now been associated with chemical equilibrium. When the mind map for a cut-off point at 15-19 after instruction was examined, it was seen that the number of stimulus words did not change compared to the mind map for the cut-off point 20 and above but that the responses given to the stimulus words have increased. For example, the responses given to the stimulus word "equilibrium" such as Kp, reactants, mole is an indication that the students were able to form meaningful relationships. In the third mind map for cut-off point at 10-14 relating to postinstruction, it is observed that both the number of stimulus words and the responses to these have increased. In fact, the stimulus words "forward" and "reverse reaction rates" appear on this mind map for the first time. The last mind map relating to post-instruction shows that all of the stimulus words given to the students are present in this mind map. In particular, it is striking to see that the two sets of stimulus words representing the concepts of "maximum disorder" and "reversible reaction" have found their way to this mind map for the first time. Results and Discussion The main aim of this study is t determine determining how the cognitive structures of 11th-grade students changed with respect to the topic of chemical equilibrium. With this aim, word association test twice as a data collection tool, was applied once before and once following the instruction. According to the results of the analysis of the pre-instruction WAT, students regarded particularly the concept of equilibrium as a phenomenon referring to physical equilibrium. Thus, there are many studies in which it is reported that students have the tendency of conceptualizing chemical equilibrium in terms of a physical phenomenon, leading to the creation of alternative conceptions (Griffiths, 1994; Hackling and Garnett, 1985; Huddle and Pillay, 1996). On the other hand, after the instruction, the students offered responses that showed that their associations pertaining to the concept of equilibrium were no longer physical but chemical. The responses of "Kd", "reaction" and "products" for the concept of equilibrium indicate this. This mind map at the same time differs from the mind map belonging to before the instruction in that it has more stimulus words and more responses. This result showes that, with regard to the basic concepts of chemical equilibrium, compared to before the instruction, the students were able to form new connections that were associated with each other instead of offering isolated structures. These findings indicate that the cognitive structures of the 11th grade students with respect to "chemical equilibrium" changed positively after the instruction. Similar results were observed in other studies (Cachapuz and Maskill, 1987; Nakiboğlu, 2008).

___

  • Anderson, O. R., Demetrius, O. J., (1993). A Flow Map Method of Representing Cognitive Structure
  • Based on Respondents’ Narrative Using Science Content, Journal of Research in Science
  • Teaching, 30, 953-969. Atabek-Yigit, E., (2016). Kelime İlişkilendirme Testi Aracılığıyla Bazı Temel Kimya Kavramları Konusundaki Bilişsel Yapının Araştırılması, İlköğretim Online, 15(4), 1385-1398.
  • Atabek-Yigit, E., (2015). Exploring the Relationship Between Cognitive Structure Outcomes and
  • Test Achievements of Pre-Service Science Teachers on Chemical Bonding Via Flow
  • Mapping, Journal of Baltic Science Education, 14(4), 524-534. Ausubel, D., (1968). Educational Psychology: A Cognitive View. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
  • Bahar, M., Johnstone, A.H., Sutcliffe, R.G., (1999). Investigation of Students’ Cognitive Structure in Elementary Genetics Through Word Association Tests, Journal of Biological Education, 33(3), 134-141
  • Bahar, M., Özatlı, N.S., (2003). Kelime İletişim Test Yöntemi İle Lise 1.Sınıf Öğrencilerinin
  • Canlıların Temel Bileşenleri Konusundaki Bilişsel Yapılarının Araştırılması, BAU Fen Bil
  • Ens Dergisi, 5 (2), 75-85.
  • Bahar, M., Tongaç, E., (2009). The Effect of Teaching Approaches on the Pattern of Pupils’
  • Cognitive Structures: Some Evidence From Field, The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher, 18(1), 21-45.
  • Bar, V., Travis, A., (1991). Children’s Views Concering Phase Changes, Journal of Research in
  • Science Teaching, 28, 363-372.
  • Bishop, B.A., Anderson, C.W., (1990). Students’ Conceptions of Natural Selection and its Role in
  • Evolution, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 27(5), 415-427. Cachapuz A. F. C., Maskill R., (1987). Detecting Changes with Learning in the Organization of
  • Knowledge: Use of Word Association Test to Follow the Learning of Collision Theory,
  • International Journal of Science Education,9, 491-504. Cachapuz A. F. C., Maskill R., (1989). Using Word Association in
  • Formative Classroom Tests: Following the Learning Of Le Chatelier's Principle, International Journal of Science
  • Education, 11 (2), 235-246. Chambers, K. S., Andre, T., (1997). Gender, Prior Knowledge, Interest and Experience in Electricity and Conceptual Change Text Manipulations in Learning About Direct Current, Journal of
  • Research in Science Teaching, 34, 107-123. Chang, S. L., (2005). The Effects of Facilitation on Cognitive Restructring in Online Discussing,
  • Journal of interactive online learning, 3(3). (retrived from http://www.ncolr.org/jiol/issues/pdf/3.3.2.pdf 15/05/2017)
  • Chin, C., (2001). Eliciting Students' Ideas and Understanding in Science: Diagnostic Assessment
  • Strategies for Teachers, Teaching and Learning, 21(2), 72-85.
  • Dhindsa, H.S., Kasim, M., Anderson, O.R., (2011). Constructivist-Visual Mind Map Teaching
  • Approach and the Quality of Students’ Cognitive Structures, Journal of Science Education and Technology, 20, 186-200.
  • Demircioğlu, G., Ayas, A., Demircioğlu, H., (2005). Conceptual Change Achieved Through a New
  • Teaching Program on Acids and Bases, Chemistry Education Research and Practice, 6(1), 36 – 51
  • Derman, A.,Eilks, I., (2016). Using a Word Association Test for the Assessment of High School
  • Students’ Cognitive Structures on Dissolution, Chemistry Education Research and Practice 17, 902-913.
  • Garnett, P. J., Garnett, P.J., Hackling, M.W., (1995). Alternative Conceptions in Chemistry: a
  • Review of Research and İmplications for Teaching And Learning, Studies in Science
  • Education, 25, 69-96.
  • Griffiths, A. K., Preston, K. R., (1992). Grade-12 Students’ Misconceptions Relating to Fundamental
  • Characteristics of Atoms and Molecules, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 29(6), 611-628.
  • Griffiths, A. K., (1994). A Critical Analysis and Synthesis of Research on Students’ Chemistry
  • Misconceptions. In H. J. Schmidt (Ed.), Problem solving and
  • Misconceptions in Chemistry And Physics (pp. 70-99). Proceedings of the 1994 International Seminar, University of
  • Dortmund, Germany. Dortmund: ICASE.
  • Hackling, M. W., Garnett, P. J., (1985). Misconceptions of Chemical Equilibrium, European Journal of Science Education, 7, 205-214.
  • Huddle, P. A., Pillay, A. E., (1996). An in-depth Study of Misconceptions in Stoichiometry And
  • Chemical Equilibrium At A South African University, Journal of Research in Science
  • Teaching, 33, 65-78Jonassen, D. H., Beissner, K., Yacci, M., (1993). Structural Knowledge: Techniques for
  • Representing, Conveying and Acquiring Structural Knowledge. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
  • Johnstone, A. H., Moynihan, T. F., (1985). The Relationship Between Performance in Word
  • Association Tests and Achievement in Chemistry, European Journal of Science Education, 7, 57-66.
  • Jones, M. G., Brader-Araje, L., (2002). The İmpact of Constructivism on Education: Language,
  • Discourse and Meaning, American Communication Journal, 5(3), 1-10. Kaya, B., Akış, A., (2015). Coğrafya Öğrencilerinin “Hava” Kavramıyla İlgili Bilişsel Yapılarının
  • Kelime İlişkilendirme Testi İle Belirlenmesi, Turkish Studies - International Periodical fo
Turkish Studies (Elektronik)-Cover
  • ISSN: 1308-2140
  • Yayın Aralığı: Yılda 4 Sayı
  • Başlangıç: 2006
  • Yayıncı: Mehmet Dursun Erdem
Sayıdaki Diğer Makaleler

ÖĞRETMEN ADAYLARININ YANSITICI DÜŞÜNME BECERİLERİNDEKİ GELİŞİMİN ÖĞRETİM SÜRECİNİN DEĞERLENDİRİLMESİ BOYUTUNDA İNCELENMESİ

SABİHA ODABAŞI ÇİMER, UFUK TÖMAN

11. SINIF ÖĞRENCİLERİNİN BİLİŞSEL YAPILARINDAKİ DEĞİŞİMİN KELİME İLİŞKİLENDİRME TESTİ KULLANARAK İNCELENMESİ: KİMYASAL DENGE ÖRNEĞİ

Mustafa TOPRAK, GÜLTEN ŞENDUR

ÖĞRETMENLERİN ARGÜMANTASYON TABANLI ARASTIRMA SORGULAMA YÖNTEMİNİ UYGULAMA SEVİYELERİNİ ETKİLEYEN SORU SORMA STRATEJİLERİ

Brian HAND, Nurcan KELEŞ

16-21 YAŞ ARASI ELİT DÜZEYDEKİ TAKIMLARIN GENÇ FUTBOLCULARININ DUYGUSAL ZEKÂ DÜZEYLERİNİN İNCELENMESİ

YUSUF SOYLU, MELİH NURİ SALMAN, SİNAN AYAN

TARİH ALAN YETERLİK ALGISI ÖLÇEĞİ: BİR ÖLÇEK GELİŞTİRME ÇALIŞMASI

FATİH YAZICI, TERCAN YILDIRIM

ORTAOKUL MATEMATİK ÖĞRETMENLERİNİN MATEMATİKSEL İLETİŞİM BECERİSİNE YÖNELİK GÖRÜŞLERİNİN İNCELENMESİ

SELAHATTİN ARSLAN, İLKNUR ÖZPINAR

TÜRK DİLİ VE EDEBİYATI ÖĞRETİMİNDE ÇAĞDAŞ YAKLAŞIMLAR: ÖĞRETİM YÖNTEMİ OLARAK SORULARIN NİTELİĞİ VE KULLANIMI

NERMİN YAZICI

KÜMELEME (CLUSTER) TEKNİĞİNİN YAZILI ANLATIMDA BULUŞ, PLANLAMA VE ANLATIM BECERİLERİNE ETKİSİ

GÜLNUR AYDIN

İLKOKULLARDA GÖREV YAPMAKTA OLAN ÖĞRETMENLERİN KAYNAŞTIRMA EĞİTİMİNE İLİŞKİN DUYGU, TUTUM VE KAYGILARININ DEĞERLENDİRİLMESİ

AHMET ÜSTÜN, Mine BAYAR

ORTAÖĞRETİM KURUMLARININ DİĞER ÖRGÜTLERLE ORTAKYAŞAR İLİŞKİLERİ

Şefika Şule ERÇETİN, Elif Gamze ÖZCAN