Comparing Neural Networks, Linear and Nonlinear Regression Techniques to Model Penetration Resistance

Penetration resistance (PR) is an important property of soils, and can be expressed as cone index (CI). Because of high variability, there are no accurate and representative PR data in most cases. Variable PR is considerably affected by gravimetric soil water content (GWC) and bulk density (BD). In this study, artificial neural networks (ANNs) were used to simulate relationship between BD, GWC, and CI. A data set of 381 samples was collected from 2 study sites, Hamadan and Maragheh. Pedotransfer functions (PTFs) were developed using ANNs and linear and nonlinear regression models to predict CI for the combined data set and each data set separately. For the combined and Hamadan data sets, ANNs produced a greater correlation coefficient (R = 0.85) and lower root mean square error (RMSE) compared with the linear regression model (R = 0.70). For the Maragheh data set, however, the regression model yielded better results. Introducing TP and relative saturation (Qv/TP) into the models improved the prediction of CI. The results further showed that ANN models performed better than nonlinear regression models. Therefore, ANNs were recognized as powerful tools to predict CI by BD, GWC, TP, and Qv/TP as the independent variables under the very diverse conditions of the soils and treatments employed.

Comparing Neural Networks, Linear and Nonlinear Regression Techniques to Model Penetration Resistance

Penetration resistance (PR) is an important property of soils, and can be expressed as cone index (CI). Because of high variability, there are no accurate and representative PR data in most cases. Variable PR is considerably affected by gravimetric soil water content (GWC) and bulk density (BD). In this study, artificial neural networks (ANNs) were used to simulate relationship between BD, GWC, and CI. A data set of 381 samples was collected from 2 study sites, Hamadan and Maragheh. Pedotransfer functions (PTFs) were developed using ANNs and linear and nonlinear regression models to predict CI for the combined data set and each data set separately. For the combined and Hamadan data sets, ANNs produced a greater correlation coefficient (R = 0.85) and lower root mean square error (RMSE) compared with the linear regression model (R = 0.70). For the Maragheh data set, however, the regression model yielded better results. Introducing TP and relative saturation (Qv/TP) into the models improved the prediction of CI. The results further showed that ANN models performed better than nonlinear regression models. Therefore, ANNs were recognized as powerful tools to predict CI by BD, GWC, TP, and Qv/TP as the independent variables under the very diverse conditions of the soils and treatments employed.
Turkish Journal of Agriculture and Forestry-Cover
  • ISSN: 1300-011X
  • Yayın Aralığı: Yılda 6 Sayı
  • Yayıncı: TÜBİTAK
Sayıdaki Diğer Makaleler

Yerfıstığında (Arachis hypogaea L.) Generatif Büyüme, Verim ve Verim Unsurları Yönünden Genotipik Farklılıklar

Sevgi ÇALIŞKAN, Mehmet Emin ÇALIŞKAN, Mehmet ARSLAN

Rapid Characterization of Garlic Clones with Locus-Specific DNA Markers

Meryem İPEK, Ahmet İPEK, Philipp W. SIMON

Comparing Neural Networks, Linear and Nonlinear Regression Techniques to Model Penetration Resistance

Hossein BAYAT, Mohammad Reza NEYSHABOURI, Mohammad Ali HAJABBASI

Feeding and foraging behaviour in two coccinellid predators: Scymnus Ievaillanti muls. and Cycloneda sanguinea L.

Ali Arda IŞIKBER

Effects of loaf weight and storage time on the qualitative properties of white and traditional Vakfikebir breads

H. Gürbüz KOTANCILAR, M. Murat KARAOĞLU, K. Emre GERÇEKASLAN

Effects of Loaf Weight and Storage Time on the Qualitative Properties of White and Traditional Vakfıkebir Breads

H. Gürbüz KOTANCILAR, K. Emre GERÇEKASLAN, M. Murat KARAOĞLU

Comparison of Sea Buckthorn Genotypes (Hippophae rhamnoides L.) Based on RAPD and FAME Data

Sezai ERCİŞLİ, Emine ORHAN, Nalan YILDIRIM, Güleray AĞAR

Ülkemizin Farklı Turunçgil Üretim Bölgelerinden Elde Edilen Turunçgil Tristeza Virüsü İzolatlarının Biyolojik, Serolojik ve Moleküler Karakterizasyonu

Savaş KORKMAZ, Bayram ÇEVİK, Serkan ÖNDER, N. Kemal KOÇ

Feeding and Foraging Behaviour in Two Coccinellid Predators: Scymnus levaillanti Muls. and Cycloneda sanguinea L.

Ali Arda IŞIKBER

Performance Analysis of Collective Set-Move Lateral Sprinkler Irrigation Systems used in Central Anatolia

İdris BAHÇECİ, Ali Fuat TARI, Nazmi DİNÇ, Pınar BAHÇECİ