A Critical Analysis of the Established Explanations about the Nature of Ecotourism

This qualitative study questions the prevailing explanations about the nature of ecotourism. The major aims of the study are (a) to point out that the widespread notions and theoretical attributions about the character of ecotourism should be reconsidered and (b) to express the need for critical questioning and design in qualitative and quantitative academic studies in social, management, administrative and tourism sciences. The article explains, first, the basic rationale for legitimizing, market building, supporting, sustaining and expanding the capitalist market, including ecotourism practices, and connects the concept of environment with economy, and inclusion of tourism and ecotourism in sustainable development. Then, it discusses the nature of dominant explanations of ecotourism. The study concludes that widespread explanations of the nature, structure, activity and outcome of ecotourism rarely match the nature of daily ecotourism practices. Instead, they generally create, employ and sustain functional myths about industrial practices, relations, causes, effects and outcomes of ecotourism. They provide strategically prescriptive and normative ethics and principles that are mostly unattainable. They consciously or inadvertently ignore the fact that the notion of ecotourism is deeply embedded in the logics of ideological normalisation of corporate activities, commodity circulation, technological end-product distribution and use, and global governance of the economic, political and cultural market conditions

PDF

___

Angelica, M., Almeyda, A. M., Broadbent, E. N., (2010). "Wyman, M. S., Durham, W. H." Ecotourism impacts in the Nicoya Peninsula, Costa Rica, International Journal of Tourism Research, No.12, 803-819.

Aitchison, C., (2006). "The Critical and the cultural: Explaining the divergent paths of leisure studies and tourism studies", Leisure Studies, Vol.25 No.4, 417-422.

Bandy, J., (1996). "Managing the other of nature: sustainability, spectacle, and global regimes of capital in ecotourism", Public Culture, Vol.8, No.3, 539-566.

Belsky, J., (1999). "Misrepresenting communities: The politics of communitybased rural ecotourism in Gales Point Manatee, Belize", Rural Sociology, Vol.64, 641- 666.

Bianchi, R. V., (2009). "The 'critical turn' in tourism studies: a radical critique", Tourism Geographies, Vol.11, No.4, 484-504.

Bianchi, R.V., (2004). "Tourism restructuring and the politics of sustainability: A critical view from the European periphery", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.12, No.6, 495-529.

Björk, P., (2000). "Ecotourism from a conceptual perspective, an extended definition of a unique tourism form", International Journal of Tourism Research, No. 2, 189-202.

Björk, P., (2007). Definition paradoxes: From concept to definition. In J. Higham (Ed.) Critical Issues in Ecotourism: Understanding a Complex Tourism Phenomenon (pp. 23- 44), Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford.

Blamey, R., (1997). "Ecotourism: the search for an operational definition", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol. 5, No.2, 109-130.

Bourdieu, P., (1998). Acts of resistance: against the tyranny of the market, New Press, New York:

Burns, P. M., Novelli, M., (Eds). (2008). Tourism development: growth, myths, and inequalities. Cambridge, MA: CABI.

Butcher, J., (2005). "The Moral Authority of Ecotourism: A Critique", Current Issues in Tourism, Vol.8, No.2-3, 114-124.

Butcher, J., (2007). Ecotourism, NGOs and development: A critical analysis, Routledge, NY.

Butcher, J., (2008). The myth of agency through community participation in ecotourism, in: P. M. Burns & M. Novelli (Eds). Tourism development: growth, myths, and inequalities. Cambridge, MA: CABI.

Butcher, J., (2011). "Can ecotourism contribute to tackling poverty? The importance of 'symbiosis", Current Issues in Tourism, Vol.14, No.3, 295-307

Campbell, L., (1999). "Ecotourism in rural developing countries", Annals of Tourism Research, No.26, 534-553.

Cater, E., (2006). "Ecotourism as a western construct", Journal of Ecotourism, Vol.5, No. 1&2, 23-39.

Ceballos-Lascurain, H., (1991). "Tourism, ecotourism and protected areas", Parks, No.2, 31-35.

Cosgrove, C., Prelle, C., Weinstein, J., (2005). The Road Less Traveled: Ecotourism, the Environment and Sustainable Development. Retrieved from http://www.biology.duke.edu/bio217/2005/cmp8/index.html.

Deng, J. S., Qiang, G., Walker, J., (2003). "Assessment on and perception of visitors' environmental impacts of nature tourism: a case study of Zhangjiiajie National Forest Park", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.11, No.6, 529-548.

Di Castri, F., (2000). "Ecology in a context of economic globalization", Bioscience, Vol.50, No.4, 321-332.

Dolnicar, S., Crouch, G. I., Long, P., (2008). "Environment-friendly tourists: what do we really know about them?" Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.16,No. 2, 197-210.

Duffy, R., (2000). "Shadow players: ecotourism development, corruption, and state politics in Belize", Third World Quarterly, Vol.21, No. 3, 549-565.

Duffy, R., (2002). A trip too far: ecotourism, politics and exploitation, Earthscan, London.

Duffy, R., Moore, L., (2010). "Neoliberalising nature? Elephant-back tourism in Thailand and Botswana", Antipode, Vol.42, No.3, 742-766.

Erdogan, N., (2003). Çevre ve (Eko)turizm. Erk, Ankara.

Farrell, T.A., Marion, J. L., (2001). "Identifying and assessing ecotourism visitor impacts at eight protected areas in Costa Rica and Belize", Environmental Conservation, Vol.28, No.3, 215-225.

Fennell, D.A., (2003). Ecotourism: An Introduction, 2nd ed. Routledge, London.

Fletcher, R., (2011). "Sustaining tourism, sustaining capitalism? The tourism industry's role in global capitalist expansion, Tourism Geographies, Vol.13, No.3, 443-461.

Gordon Guide (2005). Gordon guide to ecotourism & cultural tours. Retrieved from http://www.ecotourism-vacations.com/turkey.cfm

Gücü, G., Gücü, A. C., (2003). Is ecotourism an appropriate tool to ensure sustainable Mediterranean monk seal conservation in the Cilician Basin, Turkey? Retrieved from gucu@ims.metu.edu.tr.

Hall, C.M., Tucker, H., (2004). Tourism and postcolonialism, Routledge, Abingdon.

Hall, C. M., (2007). Pro-Poor Tourism: Do 'Tourism Exchanges Benefit Primarily the Countries of the South'? Current Issues in Tourism, Vol.10, No.2-3, 111-118.

Hardt, M., Negri, A., (2000). Empire, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.

Higham, J., (2007). Ecotourism: competing and conflicting schools of thought. In J. Higham (ed.), Critical issues in ecotourism: Understanding a complex tourism phenomenon (pp. 1-14). Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.

Higham, J.E.S., Carr, A., (2002). "Profiling visitors to ecotourism operations", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.29, No.4, 1168-1171.

Honey, M., (1999). "Ecotourism and sustainable development: Who owns paradise?, Island Press, Washington.

Honey, M., (2004). Ecotourism and certification. Retrieved from http://www.ecotourism.org & http://www.ips-dc.org/

Honey, M., (2008). Ecotourism and Sustainable Development: Who owns Paradise?, Island Press, Washington, D.C.

Hvenegaard, G. T., (1994). "Ecotourism: a status report and conceptual framework", Journal of Tourism Studies, Vol.5, No.2, 24-35.

Jamal, T., Stronza, A., (2009). "Collaboration theory and tourism practice in protected areas: Stakeholders, structuring and sustainability", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.17, No.2, 169-189.

Jones, S., (2005). "Community-based ecotourism: the significance of social capital", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.32, No.2, 303-324.

Khan, M., (2003). "Ecoserv: Ecotourists' quality expectations", Annals of Tourism Research Vol.30, No.1, 109-124.

Krugger, O., (2005). "The role of ecotourism in conservation: Panacea or Pandora's box?", Biodiversity and Conservation, No.14, 579-600.

Laudati, A., (2010). "Ecotourism: the modern predator? Implications of gorilla tourism on local livelihoods in Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda", Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, Vol.28, No.4, 726-743.

Lindberg, K., Enriquez, J., Sproule, K., (1996). "Ecotourism questioned: Case studies from Belize", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.23, No.3, 543-562.

Loon, R., Polakow, D., (2001). "Ecotourism ventures: rags or riches?", Annals of Tourism Research, No.28, 892-907.

Lu, W., Stepchenkova, S., (2012). "Ecotourism experiences reported online: Classification of satisfaction attributes", Tourism Management, No.33, 702-712.

Mader, R., (2002). "Latin American Ecotourism: What is it?", Current Issues in Tourism, Vol.5, No.3&4, 272-278.

Mansperger, M. C., (1995). "Tourism and cultural change in small-scale societies", Human Organization, Vol.54, No.1, 87-94.

Marion, J. L., Reid, S. E., (2007). "Minimizing visitor impacts to protected areas: the efficacy of low impact education programs", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.15, No.1, 5-27.

Place, S.E., (1991). "Nature tourism and rural development in Tortuguero", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.18, No.2, 186-201.

Roe, D., Harris, C., Andrade, C., (2003). Addressing poverty issues in tourism standards. PPT Working Paper No. 14, ODI, IIED and ICRT, London.

Ross, S., Wall, G., (1999). "Ecotourism: towards congruence between theory and Practice", Tourism Management, No.20, 123-132.

Ryan, C, K. Hughes & Chirgwin, S. (2000). "The gaze, spectacle and ecotourism", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.27, No.1, 148-163.

Scace, R. C., Grifone, E., Usher, R., (1992). Ecotourism in Canada. Ottowa: Canadian Environmental Advisory Council.

Scheyvens, R., (1999). "Ecotourism and the empowerment of local communities", Tourism Management, Vol.20, 245-249.

Sreekumar, T. T., Parayıl, G., (2002). "Contentions and contradictions of tourism as development option: the case of Kerala, India", Third World Quarterly, Vol.23, No.3, 529-548.

Stem, C.J., Lassoie, J.P., Lee, D.R., Deshler, D.R., (2003). "How 'eco' is ecotourism? A comparative case study of ecotourism in Costa Rica", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.11, No.4, 322-347.

Stone, M., Wall, G., (2004). "Ecotourism and community development: Case studies from Hainan, China", Environmental Management, Vol.33, No.1, 12-24.

Stone, I., Stone, T., (2011). "Community-based tourism enterprises: Challenges and prospects for community participation: The Karma Rhino Sanctuary Trust, Botswana", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.19, No.1, 97-114.

TIES, The International Ecotourism Society (2003). A simple user's guide to certification for sustainable tourism and ecotourism, Retrieved from www.ecotourism.org.

Tosun, C., Timothy, D. J., Öztürk, Y., (2003). "Tourism Growth, National Development and regional inequality in Turkey", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol.11, No.2&3, 133-161.

Tribe, J., (2003). "The RAE-ification of tourism research in the UK", International Journal of Tourism Research, Vol.5, No.2, 225-234.

Twidale, C. R., Bourne, J. A., (2003). "Commentary: Practices, problems and principles for ecotourism - a case study", Tourism Geographies, Vol.5, No.4, 482-492.

Twynam, G. D., Johnston, M. E., (2002). "The use of sustainable tourism practices", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.29, No.4, 1165-1168.

Valentine, P., (1993). "Ecotourism and nature conservation. A definition with some recent developments in Micronesia", Tourism Management, No.142, 107-115.

Vivanco, L., (2002). Seeing the dangers lurking behind the International Year of Ecotourism. The Ecologist, Vol.32, No.2, 26-31.

Vivanco, L. A., (2001). "Spectacular quetzals, ecotourism, and environmental futures in Monte Verde, Costa Rica", Ethnology, No.402, 79-92.

Wall, G., (1997). "Is ecotourism sustainable?", Environmental Management, Vol.21, No.4, 483-491.

Wallace, G., Pierce, M.S., (1996). "An Evaluation of ecotourism In Amazonas, Brazil", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.23, No.4, 843-873.

WCED (World Commission on Environment and Development). (1987). Our Common Future, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Wearing, S., Neil, J., (2009). Ecotourism: impacts, potentials and possibilitiesReconsidered after a Decade, Elsevier, Oxford.

Wearing, S., McDonald, M., (2002). "The development of community-based tourism: the relationship between tour operators and development agents as Intermediaries in Rural and Isolated Area Communities", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, No.10, 191-206.

Weaver, D., (1999). "Magnitude of ecotourism in Costa Rica and Kenya", Annals of Tourism Research, Vol.26, No.4, 792-816.

Weaver, D., (2001). "Ecotourism as mass tourism: Contradiction", Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, Vol.42, No.2, 104-113.

Wenjun, L., (2004). "Environmental management indicators for ecotourism in China's Nature Reserves: A case study in Tianmushan Nature Reserve", Tourism Management, Vol.25, No.5, 559-564.

West, P., Carrier, J. C., (2004). "Ecotourism and authenticity: Getting away from it all?", Current Anthropology, Vol.45, No.4, 483-498.

Wheeller, B., (1991). "Tourism's troubled times: responsible tourism is not the answer", Tourism Management, Vol.12, No. 2, 91-96.

Wight, P., (1993). "Ecotourism: Ethics or Eco-Sell?" Journal of Travel Research, Vol.31, No.3, 3-9.

Ziffer, K., (1989). Ecotourism: the Uneasy Alliance, Conservation International, Washington, DC.

Zapata, M. J., Hall, C. M., Lindo, P., Vanderschaeghe, M., (2011). "Can community-based tourism contribute to development and poverty alleviation? Lessons from Nicaragua", Current Issues in Tourism, Vol.14, No.8, 725-749.