A Discussion on Design Fires for an Example High-Speed Railway Train Car

High-speed rail systems are expanding everywhere for carrying thousands of passengers every day. Train cars in underground spaces travel under dense urban areas, tunnels in moun- tainous places and bridges across rivers. Design fire in burning a train car should be studied carefully for fire hazard assessment in those long underground or enclosed spaces. There are full-scale burning testing results on the main combustibles including seat, curtain and pas- senger luggage in some train cars. The heat release rate of a high-speed train car model CRH1 will be studied using such data together with a two-layer fire zone model, the Consolidated Model of Fire and Smoke Transport (CFAST). Simulation will be performed on the full- sized train car with the heat release rate of the seat measured by experiment. Two fire sce- narios with ignition points located in the front and rear areas of the train compartment are considered. The results of the fire simulations show that the heat release rate can reach 43 MW. The value is similar to the full-scale burning experiments on train cars in Sweden and South Korea. Active fire protection systems have to be seriously considered in those under- ground or enclosed areas.

PDF

___

[1] Lo TY. Reactivating high-speed railway systems between Singa- pore and Laos. Yazhou Zhoukan, 2022; Issue 50, Cover Feature (In Chinese).
[2] Chow WK. A discussion on estimating the heat release rate of de- sign fires in Hong Kong. J Applied Fire Sci. 2012-2013; 22(2), 143-149.
[3] Chow WK. Several points to watch on fire hazards of railway sys- tems. The 4th Workshop on Railway Operation for Safety and Re- liability (Special session of IEEE Global Reliability and Prognos- tics & Health Management Conference, PHM-2020, 16-18 Octo- ber 2020, Shanghai, China), Organized by City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, 17 October 2020.
[4] Pardhi S, Deshmukh A, Ajrouche H. Modelling and simulation of detailed vehicle dynamics for development of innovative power- trains. Int J Automot Sci Technol. 2021; 5(3), 244-253.
[5] Qu L, Chow WK. Common practices in fire hazard assessment for underground transport stations. Tunnelling Underground Space Technol. 2013; 38, 377-384.
[6] Proceedings of 2011 Exchange Meeting for SFPE Asia-Oceania Chapters – Transportation Fire Safety, Korea Railroad Research Institute & SFPE Korean Chapter, Seoul, Korea, 28 April 2011.
[7] Lattimer B, Beyler C. Heat release rates of fully-developed fires in railcars. Fire Safety Science – Proceedings of the Eighth Inter- national Symposium, 2005, pp. 1169-1180.
[8] Dowling VP, White N, Webb AK, Barnett JR. When a passenger train burns, how big is the fire? Proceedings of the 7th Asia-Oce- ania Symposium on Fire Science and Technology, pp. 19-28, Hong Kong, September 2007.
[9] Chow WK. Safety to watch in crowded railway systems. Asia- Oceania SFPE Chapters Conference, Jakarta, Indonesia, 29 May 2015. [10] White N. Fire performance of passenger trains. Fire Australia, 1 January 2017.
[11] Ingason H. Model scale railcar fire tests. Fire Saf. J. 2007; 42, 271- 282.
[12] Ko YJ, Michels R, Hadjisophocleous GV. Instrumentation design for HRR measurements in a large-scale fire facility. Fire Technol. 2011; 47, 1047-1061.
[13] Schebel K, Meacham BJ, Dembsey NA, Johann M, Tubbs J, Al- ston J. Fire growth simulation in passenger rail vehicles using a simplified flame spread model for integration with CFD analysis. J Fire Protect Eng. 2012; 22(3), 197-225.
[14] Lönnermark A, Claesson A, Lindström J, Li YZ, Kumm M, Ingason H. Full-scale fire tests with a commuter train in a tunnel. SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden, SP Report: 2012.05.
[15] Capote JA, Jimenez JA, Alvear D, Alvarez J, Abreu O, Lazaro M. Assessment of fire behaviour of high-speed trains’ interior materials: small-scale and full-scale fire tests. Fire Mater. 2014; 38, 725-743.
[16] Zicherman J, Lautenberger C, Wolski A. Challenges in establish- ing design fires for passenger rail vehicles. Fire and Materials 2015 Conference, 2-4 February 2015, San Francisco, USA.
[17] Lee D, Park WH, Hwang JH, Hadjisophocleous G. Full-scale fire test of an intercity train car. Fire Technol. 2016; 52(5), 1559-1574.
[18] Chen JM, Yao XL, Yan G, Guo XH. Comparative study on heat release rate of high-speed passenger train compartments. J Proce- dia Eng. 2014; 71, 107-113.
[19] Zhu J, Li XJ, Cheng FM. Combustion performance of flame-ig- nited high-speed train curtains via full-scale tests. Journal of Rail- way Science and Engineering, 2015; Issue 2, 257-263.
[20] Li ZG, Li ZQ, Liu WM. Study on the calculation methods of high- speed train heat release rate. Railway Locomotive and Car, 2018; 01-0015-04. (In Chinese)
[21] Peacock RD. CFAST Volume 4: Software Quality Assurance. Na- tional Institute of Standards and Technology, USA, 2018.
[22] Peacock RD, McGrattan K.B, Forney GP, Reneke PA. CFAST Volume 1: Technical Reference Guide. National Institute of Standards and Technology, USA, 2018.
[23] Peacock RD, Reneke PA, Forney GP. CFAST Volume 2: User’s Guide. National Institute of Standards and Technology, USA, 2018.
[24] Peacock RD, Reneke PA, Forney GP. CFAST Volume 3: Verifi- cation and Validation Guide. National Institute of Standards and Technology, USA, 2018.
[25] McGrattan K, Hostikka S, McDermott R, Floyd J, Weinschenk C, Overholt K. Fire Dynamics Simulator, User’s Guide. NIST Spe- cial Publication 1019, Sixth Edition. National Institute of Stand- ards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland, USA, and VTT Technical Research Center of Finland, Espoo, Finland, November 2013.
[26] Huang X, Ren Z, Zhu H, Peng L, Cheng CH, Chow WK. A mod- ified zone model on vertical cable tray fire in a confined compart- ment in the nuclear power plant. J Fire Sci.2018; 36(6), 472-493.
[27] Hong Kong Airport Authority. Hong Kong International Airport Tenant Design Guideline, Appendix A Sample Fire Engineering Report, April 2011 version, Issue no. 3, 2011.
[28] Buildings Department. Code of Practice for Fire Safety in Build- ings 2011 (October 2015 version). The Hong Kong Special Ad- ministrative Region.
[29] Ivanov M, Peng W, Wang Q, Chow WK. Sustainable smoke ex- traction system for atrium: A numerical study. Sustainability, 2021; 13(13): 7406.
[30] Li J, Li YF, Bi Q, Li Y, Chow WK, Cheng CH, To CW, Chow CL. Performance evaluation on fixed water-based firefighting system in suppressing large fire in urban tunnels. Tunnelling Under- ground Space Technol. 2019; 84, 56-69.
[31] Chow WK, Han SS. Heat release rate calculation in oxygen con- sumption calorimetry. J Appl Therm Eng. 2011; 31, 304-310.
[32] Fleury R, Spearpoint M, Fleischmann C. Evaluation of thermal ra- diation models for fire spread between objects. University of Can- terbury, Department of Civil and Natural Resources Engineering, 2010.
[33] Noordijk L, Lemaire T. Modelling of fire spread in car parks. HERON, 2005; 50(4), 209-218.
[34] National Fire Protection Association. NFPA 921, Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigations, National Fire Protection Associa- tion, USA, 2004.
[35] Chen JM, Yao XL, Li SP. Study on the influence of ventilation condition on the heat release rate of the CRH passenger rail car. J Procedia Eng. 2013; 62, 1050-1056.
[36] Lönnermark A, Ingason H. Fire spread between industry premises. Fire Safety Science – Proceedings of the 10th IAFSS Symposium, 2011; pp. 1305-1317.